Chapter 2 The Other Woman

1510 Words
Elara didn't trust me at first. I couldn't blame her. From her perspective, I was the woman who had taken her place. The wife. The one with the legal document. She had spent four years in a cottage on the edge of the estate, raising Julian's son, waiting for a man who never intended to make her anything but a secret. I showed up at her door three days after the wedding. She almost didn't let me in. "I'm not here to fight," I said. "I'm here to talk." "About what?" "About what he told you. And what he told me. And why they don't match." She let me in. We sat in the living room, and Theo played with his train, and we talked for two hours. By the end of it, she was crying, and I was trying not to. "He told me you'd hate me," she said. "He said you'd make me leave. He said the best I could hope for was a settlement and a chance to see Theo on weekends." "He told me you were a problem to be managed. He said I should arrange your move into the main house and act like it was charity." She wiped her eyes. "Why would he do that?" "Because he wanted us to hate each other. If we hated each other, we wouldn't compare stories. We wouldn't figure out that he was lying to both of us. And he'd get exactly what he wanted." "What's that?" "Control. Over you, over me, over Theo. Over the whole situation. He'd be the center of it. The man in charge." She shook her head. "I've been so stupid." "No, you haven't. You've been trapped. There's a difference." Theo ran into the room and climbed onto Elara's lap. She held him close, and I saw the way her shoulders curved around him, the way she was always shielding him from something. "He wants to take him," she whispered. "Julian. He wants Theo to grow up as a Vane. He said if I didn't cooperate, he'd file for custody. He said he'd tell a judge that I was unfit, that I couldn't provide for him, that I'd abandoned him." "Did you abandon him?" "Never. Not once. I've been here every day for three years. I'm the one who taught him to walk. I'm the one who taught him to talk. Julian came by maybe once a week to take a picture for his mother and then leave." "Then we have a case." She looked at me. "You'd do that? For me?" "I'd do it for him. He's a child. He deserves better than Julian's version of fatherhood." The first hearing was a disaster. Julian's lawyer, a man named Phillip Crane who had been with the Vane family for twenty years, argued that the clause was invalid on the grounds that it violated Julian's rights as a father. He claimed that Elara had been compensated for her silence, that she had agreed to the arrangement, that she was now trying to use the lawsuit to extort more money from the family. The judge asked Elara to testify. She stood up in her cotton dress and her borrowed shoes and told the truth. She told the judge about the first year, when Julian had promised to leave his family and marry her. She told him about the second year, when Julian had stopped promising and started making demands. She told him about the third year, when she realized she was a prisoner in a cottage with a garden and a child and no way out. "He told me I couldn't leave," she said. "He said if I tried to take Theo, he'd have me arrested. He said he had friends in the police department. He said I'd never see my son again." The judge wrote something down. Phillip Crane objected. He said Elara was coached. He said she was a gold digger. He said she had no proof. Marcus Reed stood up and handed the judge a folder. In it were text messages, emails, bank statements. Elara had saved everything. Every message Julian sent, every promise he made, every threat he issued. She had been documenting her own entrapment for three years, waiting for a day when she might need it. "Your Honor," Marcus said, "the evidence shows a pattern of coercion and manipulation that extends far beyond the marriage contract. Mr. Vane used his wealth and his name to control Ms. Reyes for four years. He threatened her with losing her child. He isolated her from her support network. He created a situation where she had no choice but to comply." Crane argued back. He said the messages were taken out of context. He said Elara had agreed to everything. He said the clause was irrelevant. The judge didn't agree. She ordered an investigation into Julian's conduct, and she granted temporary custody to Elara pending the full hearing. She also ordered Julian to pay Elara's legal fees. Outside the courtroom, Julian stopped me in the hallway. "You think you've won," he said. His voice was low. His eyes were cold. "I think you've lost," I said. "There's a difference." "You'll regret this." "Maybe. But I won't regret standing up to you." He walked away. His shoes echoed on the marble floor, and I watched him go, and I felt something like relief. The kind of relief you feel when you finally put down a weight you didn't know you were carrying. Elara and Theo moved into a small apartment near the university. I helped her unpack. We put Theo's bed in the corner of the second bedroom, and we hung a picture of a dinosaur on the wall, and we sat on the floor and drank coffee out of paper cups because we hadn't found the mugs yet. "He's going to fight," Elara said. "I know." "He's going to try to take Theo." "I know." "What do we do?" I looked at Theo. He was asleep on a mattress in the corner, his mouth open, his hands curled into fists. He looked peaceful. He looked like a child who had never known anything but love. "We fight back," I said. "Every step. Every hearing. Every motion. We don't let him win." She nodded. She looked at me like I was something she hadn't expected. "Why are you doing this?" she asked. "You could have walked away. You could have taken the settlement and moved on. You didn't have to help me." "I know." "So why?" I thought about the pen hovering over the signature line. I thought about my grandmother. I thought about the four generations of Ashford women who had signed that clause because they knew what men like Julian did. "Because it's the right thing to do," I said. "And because no one else is going to do it." She smiled. It was the first real smile I'd seen on her face. "Thank you," she said. "Don't thank me yet. We're not done." The hearing was two weeks later. Julian showed up with a new lawyer, a woman named Diane Marsh who had a reputation for winning cases she shouldn't. She argued that Elara was an unfit mother because she had no income, no education, and no stable home. She argued that Theo would be better off with his father, who could provide him with every advantage. Marcus countered. He pointed out that Elara had been living in the same cottage for four years, that she had been providing for Theo on her own, that she had never once neglected him. He pointed out that Julian had been an absent father, that he had visited once a week for an hour at most, that he had never attended a doctor's appointment or a parent-teacher meeting or a birthday party. Diane Marsh called Julian to the stand. He testified that he loved his son. He testified that he had always provided for him. He testified that Elara was unstable and vindictive and that she was only doing this to punish him for getting married. Marcus asked him one question. "If you loved your son so much, why did you sign a marriage contract that required you to hide his existence?" Julian didn't have an answer. The judge ruled in Elara's favor. She was granted primary custody. Julian was granted supervised visitation, twice a month, at a location determined by the court. He was ordered to pay child support. He was ordered to attend parenting classes. He was ordered to undergo a psychological evaluation. Outside the courtroom, Diane Marsh approached me. "You know this isn't over," she said. "I know." "He's not going to stop." "I know that too." She looked at me for a long moment. "You're not what I expected." "What did you expect?" "Someone who would fold. Someone who would take the settlement and go." "I don't fold." She smiled. It wasn't a nice smile, but it wasn't entirely unfriendly either. "Good luck," she said. "You're going to need it."
Free reading for new users
Scan code to download app
Facebookexpand_more
  • author-avatar
    Writer
  • chap_listContents
  • likeADD