When No One Agrees
1007 Words
When No One Agrees
By the seventh day, disagreement had become routine.
In Ilyra, even the air seemed to carry arguments now—half-finished sentences drifting through streets, carried from one corner of the city to another. What had once been decided in moments of silence beneath the oracle’s voice now stretched into hours of debate.
And nothing agreed with anything else.
Eris stood at the center of the Hall of Glass as the council argued around her.
“This allocation is unfair.”
“It is necessary.”
“It is reckless.”
“It is survival.”
She had stopped trying to track who was right.
Because everyone was, in their own way.
That was the problem.
The High Keeper struck his staff once against the stone floor.
“Enough.”
The sound echoed sharply, and the room quieted—but only slightly. Even silence here felt temporary now, like something waiting to be interrupted.
“We cannot continue like this,” one council member said. “Every decision turns into a conflict.”
“Because we no longer have guidance,” another replied.
Eris exhaled slowly at that.
That word again.
Guidance.
As if it had ever been simple.
She stepped forward.
“You still have guidance,” she said.
Heads turned toward her.
“What do you mean?” someone asked.
Eris gestured toward the table covered in reports, estimates, and conflicting accounts.
“You have information. You have people. You have competing needs. That is guidance.”
A few scoffed.
“That is confusing.”
“No,” Eris replied firmly. “It is reality.”
The room grew tense again.
A council elder leaned forward. “Reality does not help us decide.”
Eris met his gaze.
“No,” she said. “It forces you to.”
A pause.
This one is longer than the others.
The High Keeper watched her carefully.
“You are saying we should proceed without agreement?” he asked.
“I am saying,” Eris replied, “that agreement is not always possible.”
That landed heavily.
Because it was true.
And truth, without the oracle to soften it, felt sharp.
A council member stood abruptly.
“So what now? We argue forever? We delay everything until someone gives in?”
Eris shook her head.
“No. You decide. And you accept that not everyone will agree.”
“That is unstable,” the man snapped.
“It is honest,” she replied.
Silence followed again—but this time, it felt different.
Not empty.
Fractured.
The High Keeper spoke slowly.
“This is what the oracle prevented,” he said.
Eris turned to him.
“Did she prevent it,” she asked quietly, “or erase it?”
The question lingered.
No one answered immediately.
Outside the Hall, the city was no quieter.
Messengers moved faster now, not calmer. Urgency had replaced hesitation. Every district wanted answers, but none agreed on what the answers should be.
At the river market, Eris found a dispute escalating.
Two traders argued over water rights, voices rising, drawing a small crowd.
No oracle.
No verdict.
Only competing claims.
Eris approached—but did not intervene.
Not immediately.
She listened.
One trader insisted the northern channel had always belonged to his family.
The other argued it had been redistributed years ago.
Both were certain.
Both were wrong in different ways.
A bystander noticed Eris.
“Tell us what is right,” the man said urgently.
Heads turned.
The expectation returned instantly.
Familiar.
Heavy.
Eris hesitated.
She felt it—the old reflex of the city. The need to outsource certainty.
But there was no voice to fall back on anymore.
Only people.
“I cannot tell you what is right,” she said.
Frustration rippled through the crowd.
“Then why are you here?” someone demanded.
Eris looked at them.
Because that was the real question now.
“I am here,” she said slowly, “to remind you that disagreement does not mean failure.”
A few people scoffed.
Others stayed quiet.
“You will not all agree,” she continued. “And that will feel wrong. But wrong is not always dangerous.”
The trader nearest her shook his head.
“That is not how the oracle worked.”
Eris nodded once.
“No,” she said. “It isn’t.”
A pause.
Then she added, “And maybe that is why you are struggling.”
The crowd shifted uneasily.
Because she had not given them certainty.
But she had not left them empty either.
After a long silence, one of the traders spoke again.
“If we cannot agree… what do we do?”
Eris glanced between them.
“Then you decide how to live with the disagreement.”
It was not satisfying.
But it was real.
By evening, word of the river dispute had spread—not because it was resolved, but because it wasn’t.
And still, people had chosen.
Not perfectly.
Not unanimously.
But deliberately.
Back at the Hall, the High Keeper met Eris as she returned.
“You are changing how they think,” he said.
Eris shook her head slightly.
“I am not changing them,” she replied. “I am just removing the idea that someone else will do it for them.”
He studied her for a moment.
“That is dangerous,” he said.
“Yes,” she agreed.
A pause.
Then she added, “So was dependence.”
The High Keeper looked toward the empty center of the Hall.
For a moment, neither of them spoke.
Then he said quietly, “The city is not breaking.”
Eris followed his gaze.
“No,” she said. “It is splitting.”
“And yet,” he said, “it is still standing.”
Eris nodded slowly.
“For now.”
Outside, night settled over Ilyra again.
And for the first time since the oracle’s silence began, the city did not pretend to agree.
It simply continued.
- Writer
- chap_listContents
- likeADD