Noah Bennett had another theory.
Actually, he had many theories.
Most of them were wrong.
But this one felt painfully correct.
Nothing good ever happened after someone said, “After school. Gym.”
Because that sentence usually meant one of three things:
A fight
A competition
Public embarrassment
And today…
it was definitely number two.
By lunchtime, the entire school knew.
Not just the seniors.
Not just the juniors.
Even the freshmen—who still got lost trying to find the bathroom—knew.
There was going to be a basketball showdown.
Ryan Walker vs. Ethan Cole.
Captain vs. New Guy.
King vs. Challenger.
Confidence vs. Confidence.
Jake slammed his tray on the cafeteria table like a news reporter breaking a story.
“Ladies and gentlemen,” he announced loudly, standing up, “history is about to be made.”
Grace immediately pulled him back into his seat.
“Sit down before you embarrass yourself,” she snapped.
Jake gasped.
“Too late.”
The squad sat around their usual table.
Noah.
Lily.
Jake.
Sophie.
Oliver.
Maya.
Ben.
Ryan.
Grace.
Nine teenagers and one mountain of noise.
Sophie leaned forward dramatically.
“This is the most exciting thing that has happened since the vending machine ate my dollar.”
Oliver rolled his eyes.
“That was yesterday.”
“Exactly,” Sophie replied. “Drama never sleeps.”
Maya flipped her hair.
“I just hope the new guy loses,” she said.
Ryan raised an eyebrow.
“Oh?”
She nodded confidently.
“You’re our captain. We’re loyal.”
Ryan smirked.
“Good answer.”
Jake pointed his fork at Ryan.
“If you lose,” he said seriously, “I will pretend I don’t know you.”
Ryan laughed.
“You already pretend that.”
“Fair point.”
While everyone argued loudly, Noah sat quietly.
Poking his fries.
Not eating them.
That alone was suspicious.
Jake noticed immediately.
“Why are you not eating?” he demanded.
Noah shrugged.
“Not hungry.”
The entire table froze.
Jake stood up slowly.
“Ladies and gentlemen,” he announced, “this is an emergency.”
Grace frowned.
“What now?”
Jake pointed dramatically at Noah.
“He said he’s not hungry.”
Gasps.
Real gasps.
Even Ryan looked concerned.
“Are you sick?” Ryan asked.
“No,” Noah said.
“Heartbroken?” Sophie guessed.
Noah choked on air.
“WHAT?! No!”
Jake nodded wisely.
“Yes,” he said. “Definitely heartbroken.”
Noah groaned.
“I’m fine.”
But he wasn’t.
Not really.
Because across the cafeteria…
Lily was laughing.
And Ethan was sitting beside her.
Talking easily.
Comfortably.
Like they had known each other forever.
Jake followed Noah’s gaze.
Then he sighed dramatically.
“Ah,” he said. “The Handsome Problem.”
Noah rubbed his face.
“Please don’t call it that.”
Jake ignored him.
“Look,” he continued, whispering, “new guy is cool. But you’re the original.”
Noah frowned.
“The original what?”
Jake shrugged.
“The original i***t in love.”
Noah stared at him.
“…Thanks.”
“You’re welcome.”
RIIIIIIIIING.
The bell rang.
Students jumped up instantly.
Chairs scraped.
Backpacks swung.
Noise filled the cafeteria.
And the tension returned.
Because everyone knew what came next.
After school. Gym.
At exactly 3:15 p.m., the gym doors opened.
Students poured inside like popcorn exploding in a microwave.
The bleachers filled quickly.
Freshmen.
Sophomores.
Juniors.
Seniors.
Even a few teachers pretending they were “supervising.”
Jake sprinted in first and jumped onto the bleachers dramatically.
“I claim this seat in the name of snacks!” he shouted.
Grace sat beside him.
“You’re impossible.”
He nodded proudly.
“Correct.”
Noah sat down slowly.
Heart pounding.
Not because of the game.
But because of the girl sitting two seats away.
Lily.
She looked excited.
Eyes bright.
Smile wide.
And Ethan…
was already on the court.
Ryan walked onto the court first.
Tall.
Confident.
Focused.
The crowd cheered instantly.
“RYAN!”
“CAPTAIN!”
“LET’S GO!”
He bounced the ball once.
Twice.
Calm.
Controlled.
Then—
The gym doors opened again.
And Ethan stepped inside.
The noise doubled.
Girls whispered.
Boys watched carefully.
Even the teachers leaned forward.
Jake grabbed Noah’s arm.
“Brother,” he whispered dramatically, “this is cinema.”
Noah swallowed.
Ryan dribbled the ball smoothly.
Fast.
Precise.
He shot.
SWISH.
Perfect.
The crowd roared.
Jake jumped up.
“HE DOES NOT MISS!”
Grace pulled him back down.
“Sit.”
Meanwhile, Ethan picked up another ball.
He bounced it casually.
Then shot.
SWISH.
Also perfect.
The gym went silent.
Jake blinked.
“…Okay,” he whispered. “Plot twist.”
The Match Begins
Coach Daniels blew the whistle.
“First to ten points,” he announced.
“Let’s play.”
The game started instantly.
Ryan moved first.
Quick.
Sharp.
He dribbled left.
Then right.
Then sprinted forward.
He jumped—
SHOT.
SWISH.
1–0.
The crowd exploded.
Jake screamed.
“CAPTAIN!”
Noah leaned forward.
Heart racing.
Not just from excitement.
But from tension.
Because Lily was clapping loudly.
Smiling.
Cheering.
And he couldn’t tell who she was cheering for.
Ethan took the ball.
Calm.
Focused.
He dribbled slowly.
Watching.
Thinking.
Then suddenly—
He moved.
Fast.
Faster than anyone expected.
Ryan tried to block him.
Too late.
Ethan jumped.
SHOT.
SWISH.
1–1.
The gym erupted again.
Jake grabbed his head.
“This is illegal,” he said.
Grace nodded.
“Very illegal.”
The Turning Point
The game continued.
2–2.
3–3.
4–4.
Neither player backed down.
Neither player missed.
Sweat dripped.
Shoes squeaked.
Hearts pounded.
Then—
Score: 9–9.
Match point.
The entire gym stood.
Silence.
Heavy silence.
Ryan held the ball.
Breathing hard.
Determined.
He dribbled once.
Twice.
Then charged forward.
He jumped.
SHOT—
BLOCK.
Ethan’s hand hit the ball.
Hard.
The ball bounced away.
The crowd gasped.
Ethan grabbed it.
Ran forward.
Jumped.
Shot—
SWISH.
Game over.
10–9.
The Shock
Silence filled the gym.
Total silence.
Even Jake forgot to breathe.
Then—
The crowd exploded.
Students screamed.
Whistles blew.
Chaos everywhere.
The new guy had won.
Ryan stood still.
Breathing heavily.
Staring at the floor.
Then slowly…
he looked up.
At Ethan.
And to everyone’s surprise—
Ryan smiled.
He walked forward.
And held out his hand.
“Good game,” he said.
Ethan shook it.
“Good game.”
Respect.
Real respect.
The tension melted.
As the crowd cheered, Lily jumped up from the bleachers.
Excited.
Laughing.
Happy.
She ran toward the court.
Straight toward Ethan.
Noah watched.
Heart pounding.
She reached Ethan.
Grinning.
“That was amazing!” she said.
Ethan laughed.
“Thanks.”
Then—
Without thinking—
She hugged him.
Just a quick hug.
Friendly.
Normal.
But to Noah…
it felt like thunder.
Jake slowly turned toward him.
“…You okay?”
Noah didn’t answer.
Because he wasn’t.
Not even close.
As the crowd slowly began to leave the gym, Sophie suddenly gasped loudly.
Everyone turned.
“What?” Maya asked.
Sophie stared toward the entrance.
Eyes wide.
“Uh…” she said slowly.
“Guys…”
Noah followed her gaze.
And felt his stomach drop.
Standing at the gym doors…
arms crossed…
face cold…
was Tyler “Viper” Reed.
And behind him—
Marcus.
Dylan.
The bullies.
Waiting.
Watching.
Smiling.
Like they had just found their next target.
And this time…
it was Ethan.