The handle turned with an agonizing slowness, every creak amplified in the tense silence of Sophie’s room. Liam was frozen on the floor, his legs refusing to cooperate as his brain screamed at him to run. Sophie, on the other hand, grabbed the flashlight and stood up, her posture defiant but her grip trembling.
“Who’s there?” she called, her voice sharper than usual, trying to mask the edge of fear.
No answer.
The door didn’t fully open, either. It just sat there, slightly ajar, the hallway beyond swallowed in darkness.
“Sophie, please,” Liam whispered, tugging at her sleeve. “Let’s wake your parents.”
“And tell them what? That a ghost knocked on my door?” she hissed back, though her bravado was cracking.
A cold breeze swept through the room again, rustling papers and sending a shiver down Liam’s spine.
“This isn’t normal,” he whispered.
“Yeah, no kidding,” Sophie muttered, inching toward the door. She pushed it open with the flashlight, peering into the hallway.
Nothing. Just shadows and the faint hum of the heater kicking on downstairs.
“There’s no one there,” she said, exhaling in relief.
But Liam wasn’t convinced. “Then who turned the handle?”
The rest of the night passed uneventfully—if you could call lying awake until dawn, listening for every creak and groan of the house, “uneventful.” By morning, they were both bleary-eyed and jumpy.
Over breakfast, Sophie’s mom noticed their exhaustion.
“Late-night movies again?” she teased, pouring orange juice.
“Something like that,” Sophie mumbled, shoving a piece of toast into her mouth. Liam avoided eye contact, too nervous to say anything.
The box remained untouched in Sophie’s closet, but the folded note haunted them both. Liam couldn’t stop thinking about it, replaying the words over and over: Leave it alone. Don’t look for me.
Later that day, Sophie dragged Liam back to her room.
“Okay,” she said, shutting the door behind her. “We need to figure this out.”
“Figure what out?” Liam asked. “The box is creepy. That’s all we need to know. Let’s just get rid of it.”
“No way,” Sophie said. “What if it’s connected to something bigger? Something important?”
“Or something dangerous,” Liam countered.
Sophie ignored him, grabbing the journal from the box. She flipped through the pages, stopping at the last entry—the one they’d read before.
“Look at this,” she said, pointing to a faint smudge in the corner of the page.
“It’s a coffee stain,” Liam said, unimpressed.
“No, it’s something under the stain,” Sophie insisted. She grabbed a pencil and began shading over the area, revealing faint, scratched letters beneath.
Find the key.
Liam’s heart sank. “That’s… not good.”
“It’s a clue,” Sophie said, her eyes lighting up.
“Or a warning,” Liam muttered.
But Sophie was already diving back into the box, rifling through its contents with the energy of someone who had just unlocked a treasure chest.
“There’s nothing that looks like a key,” she said after a few minutes, frowning.
“Good,” Liam said. “Maybe we’re not supposed to find it.”
Sophie shot him a look but didn’t argue. For once, she seemed just as unnerved as he was.
That night, Liam couldn’t shake the feeling that they’d crossed some invisible line. He kept glancing over his shoulder, half-expecting to see a shadow move where it shouldn’t.
At 3 a.m., his phone buzzed, dragging him out of a restless sleep.
It was a text from Sophie:
Sophie: I found something.
Liam: WHAT? WHY ARE YOU AWAKE?
Sophie: Couldn’t sleep. Went through the photos. Look at this.
A picture came through: one of the faded Polaroids from the box. It showed the same woman they’d seen before, standing in front of a house. But this time, Liam noticed something new—a dark figure in one of the windows, almost hidden by the curtains.
Liam: NOPE. NOPE. DELETE IT.
Sophie: It’s not that scary. Probably just the lighting.
Liam: Or it’s Marjorie. Watching us.
Sophie: Don’t be dramatic. We need to figure out where this house is.
Liam stared at the photo, dread settling in his chest. He knew Sophie wouldn’t let this go. And deep down, he wasn’t sure he wanted her to.
Because as much as he hated to admit it, he needed answers too.