The Things the Lake Keeps
867 Words
Chapter Five: The Things the Lake Keeps
That night, Elmridge slept peacefully.
Which felt deeply inappropriate.
Inside the Vale house, nobody slept at all.
Lira lay on her back, staring at the ceiling as if answers might be written there in invisible ink. Lyra sat by her window, watching the moon rest on the surface of the lake like a coin someone had forgotten to pick up.
The silence between them was no longer accidental.
It was present.
Intentional.
Heavy.
Around midnight, Lira got up and walked into the hallway.
At the exact same time, Lyra opened her door.
They met in the dim light.
Neither looked surprised.
“We’re going,” Lira said.
Lyra nodded. “I know.”
They didn’t wake their father. Explaining midnight lake visits had never gone well in the past, and tonight did not feel like a night for explanations.
The path was colder than usual. The air thinner. Even the insects seemed to have filed a complaint and gone home early.
When they reached the water, the lake was not calm.
It moved gently, like something breathing beneath it.
They stood at the edge.
Waiting.
“For what?” Lira whispered.
Lyra swallowed. “I don’t know.”
A strange memory surfaced in both of them at once.
Not from yesterday.
Not from childhood.
From before that.
Darkness. Water. A loud crack of thunder.
A woman’s voice.
Crying.
Lira grabbed her head. “Do you remember that?”
“Yes,” Lyra said shakily. “But I don’t know how.”
The lake rippled harder.
And then—
They saw it.
Not in the reflection.
In the water itself.
A shape beneath the surface.
Not a person.
Not an animal.
Just a shadow that seemed to stretch toward them.
Lira stepped back.
Lyra did not.
Instead, she felt a pull in her chest. A familiar one.
The same pull she had always felt toward Lira.
Only now, it was coming from the lake.
“Lyra,” Lira said carefully. “Step away.”
“I can’t,” Lyra whispered.
She wasn’t afraid.
She was… recognized.
As if the lake had just found something it had misplaced years ago.
Suddenly, footsteps crunched behind them.
They both turned.
Adrian.
Breathless.
“I knew you’d be here,” he said. “You left the house lights on. I got worried.”
Lira almost laughed. “We’ve stood here at midnight and that’s what worried you?”
“Yes,” he said honestly.
Lyra turned back to the water.
The shadow beneath it had grown clearer.
Longer.
Reaching.
Adrian stepped closer. “What are you looking at?”
Before either sister could answer, the water shifted violently.
A wave rolled toward the shore without wind.
Lira grabbed Adrian’s arm and pulled him back.
Lyra stood frozen.
And then she heard it.
Not with her ears.
Inside her mind.
A voice that was not a voice.
Come back.
Her breath caught.
Lira saw the change in her expression. “Lyra? What is it?”
Lyra’s lips trembled. “It’s calling me.”
Adrian frowned. “Who is?”
Lyra pointed at the lake.
But neither of them saw what she saw.
Because now the reflection showed only one girl.
Standing where Lyra stood.
Lira’s heart pounded. “Get away from the water!”
Lyra shook her head slowly. “I think this is where we started.”
A sudden flash of lightning split the sky.
Thunder followed instantly.
The same kind of storm from the night they were born.
Rain began without warning.
Heavy. Cold. Blinding.
Adrian grabbed Lira’s hand. “We need to go!”
But Lira couldn’t move.
Because Lyra had stepped forward.
Into the water.
“Lyra!” Lira screamed.
The moment her feet touched the lake, Lyra felt something snap into place inside her.
Not painfully.
Perfectly.
Like a puzzle piece returning home.
Memories flooded her.
Their mother crying.
The midwife shouting.
The storm raging.
A choice made in fear.
A soul divided so one body could survive.
Lyra gasped.
“We were never meant to be two,” she said through the rain.
Lira’s vision blurred with tears. “Then come back!”
Lyra turned to her.
And smiled.
A calm, knowing smile that Lira had never seen before.
“I think I was the part that stayed behind.”
Lightning struck the water.
The lake exploded in white light.
Adrian shielded his eyes.
Lira screamed Lyra’s name.
And then—
Silence.
The rain stopped.
The thunder faded.
The lake became still.
Too still.
Lira stood alone at the edge of the water.
Adrian looked around wildly. “Where is she?!”
Lira’s chest rose and fell rapidly.
She looked down at her hands.
She could feel something again.
Warm.
Familiar.
Complete.
Tears rolled down her face.
“She’s here,” Lira whispered.
Adrian stared at her. “What?”
Lira looked up.
Her eyes were different.
Softer.
Deeper.
Both sunlight and moonlight at once.
And when she spoke, her voice carried an echo that had not been there before.
“We were never two people,” she said gently.
“We were one soul… trying to live twice.”
- Writer
- chap_listContents
- likeADD