Elena's phone light flickered—once, twice—before steadying. The battery indicator showed 20%. She needed to act fast.
Drawing a deep breath, she forced herself to think methodically. The electricity failure wasn't necessarily sinister; Mr. Bianchi had warned her about the wiring. But combined with everything else...
She swept her light across the foyer, checking corners, doorways, shadows. Nothing moved. The painting above the stairs showed only what it had moments ago—the mysterious woman still stood on the Ponte Vecchio, eternally holding her letter.
"Right," Elena muttered, her voice too loud in the darkness. "Locksmith first."
She pulled out her phone's contacts, finger hovering over the number Mr. Bianchi had given her for emergencies. Then she paused. Her grandmother's warning echoed: Trust no one who comes asking about the past. Would that include people recommended by the estate agent?
The front door's lock clicked.
Elena spun toward the sound. The handle began to turn, slowly, deliberately. She backed away, heart thundering. She'd locked that door herself after Mr. Bianchi left. She still had all the keys, including the mysterious new one.
All the keys except—
The door swung open.
Elena bolted for the servant's stairs, her phone's beam bouncing wildly. She took the steps two at a time, using the railing to pull herself around the corners. Behind her, she heard the front door close. Then footsteps, unhurried but purposeful, crossing the foyer.
The stairs emerged onto the second floor. Elena paused, listening. The footsteps continued below, heading toward the library. She had minutes, maybe less.
Start in the attic, her grandmother had written.
Elena looked up the main staircase toward the third floor. Going higher seemed like madness with someone in the villa, but so did trying to escape without knowing what she was running from. Her grandmother had left her clues for a reason. Whatever was hidden in the attic might help her understand what was happening now.
Decision made, she crept up the stairs. The steps here were narrower, steeper. At the top landing, a single door stood closed. When Elena tried the handle, it didn't budge.
The old key from the hall table fit perfectly.
Beyond the door, the attic stretched into darkness. Unlike the organized chaos below, this space felt purposeful in its arrangement. Sheets draped oddly-shaped objects in neat rows, like an army of ghosts standing at attention. The air was thick with the smell of old canvas and wood.
Elena's light caught glints of gilt frames leaning against walls, stacks of crates marked with shipping labels, rolled carpets bound with twine. An art storage room, then. But these pieces weren't covered in decades of dust like everything below. Someone had been maintaining this space.
She moved deeper into the attic, scanning for anything "out of place" as her grandmother had suggested. It was hard to tell what qualified when everything seemed deliberately placed.
Then she saw it.
In the far corner stood an easel, uncovered, supporting a large canvas. Unlike the other paintings she'd seen in the villa, this one was turned to face the wall.
From downstairs came the sound of someone climbing the main staircase.
Elena hurried to the easel. The canvas was heavy, but she managed to turn it without making noise. Her light revealed a portrait, nearly life-sized, of a man in military uniform. The style was similar to the sketch of her grandmother—the same confident lines, the same ability to capture character beyond mere appearance. In the bottom corner, she found the signature she expected: M. Vincenti, 1943.
But it was the subject that made her blood run cold.
She recognized the face from photographs in history books. The man in the portrait was Heinrich Böhm, the SS officer who had overseen the looting of Florence's art during the Nazi occupation. He'd disappeared in 1944, along with countless masterpieces that had never been recovered.
The footsteps reached the second floor.
Elena's hands shook as she photographed the portrait, making sure to capture the signature clearly. When she turned the canvas back to the wall, something fluttered to the floor—a sheet of paper that had been stuck to the back of the frame.
She snatched it up just as a floorboard creaked on the attic stairs.
The paper was old, but Elena could make out what looked like a list of paintings, each followed by a string of numbers and letters. At the bottom was a note in her grandmother's handwriting: The real ones were never lost. Look behind the oldest lie.
Footsteps approached the attic door.
Elena turned off her phone's light and pressed herself into the shadow of a large armoire. Her pulse roared in her ears as she heard the key turn in the lock.
The door opened. A beam of light swept the attic.
"Dr. Romano?" a woman's voice called. The accent was American. "I know you're up here. We need to talk about your grandmother—and about what really happened in 1944."
Elena held her breath. The voice sounded young, professional. Not threatening, exactly, but...
Trust no one who comes asking about the past.
"Your grandmother left things out of order," the woman continued. The light beam moved closer. "If we don't put them right, people will die. The same people who died back then."
Elena clutched the paper tighter. The footsteps were just on the other side of the armoire now.
"The Vincenti portrait changes everything," the woman said. "Once people know it exists—"
She broke off. In the sudden silence, Elena could hear papers being moved, canvas rustling.
"The list," the woman breathed. "Where is it?"
Elena looked down at the paper in her hand, now damp with sweat. In the darkness, she could just make out one line of text she hadn't noticed before, written in the margin in faded pencil:
The paintings are the key, but the frames hold the truth.
The woman's light swung toward Elena's hiding place.