Grace offered a gentle, empathetic smile. “It often can be. Let’s park that translation for a moment. How did you feel when he said it?”
“Small. Like I was an option he was scrolling past.”
“And what would it feel like to be his priority?”
As Sarah spoke, painting a picture of desired weekend plans and text messages that didn’t take six hours to get a reply, Grace felt the familiar, quiet nudge in her spirit. Patience. Kindness. Not self-seeking. The words from 1 Corinthians, the love chapter, surfaced not as a verse to be quoted, but as a lens through which to view the problem.
“Sarah,” Grace said softly when she paused. “Let’s try a different framework. Instead of dissecting what his words mean, let’s talk about what you need. Not from him, but for you. If patience isn’t being offered by him, what does it look like to offer it to yourself? If his actions feel unkind, what would an act of profound kindness toward yourself be this week?”
It was faith translated into action, stripped of its scripture, offered as a practical tool for survival. Sarah’s shoulders loosened a fraction. “So… you’re saying I should buy myself the expensive flowers instead of waiting for him to do it?”
Grace laughed, a warm, genuine sound. “I’m saying that your value isn’t determined by his attention span. And yes, the shop down the road has fantastic peonies for $9.99. Consider it an investment in your own worth.”
After Sarah left, looking slightly lighter, Grace took a moment. She closed her eyes, in prayer, a brief, silent exhale of intention. Help me to see them as you see them. Help me to listen. Help my own baggage to stay out of the room.
She glanced at the clock. Next was Mark, a new client whose intake form mentioned “recurring patterns of relationship failure” and “trust issues stemming from parental abandonment.” Heavy, familiar work. She refreshed her tea pot, a routine act.
Before Mark arrived, her eyes fell on the Bible on the shelf. Her fingers brushed over its spine, a quick touchstone for strength. This was her Monday morning ministry. Not in a pulpit, but in a comfortable armchair, with a box of tissues close at hand, helping the lonely and the hurting navigate the messy, beautiful, complicated map of the human heart, one carefully chosen, faith-informed but never faith-forced word at a time.
Her assistant Olivia soft voice came through the intercom. “Mark is here, Dr. Carter.”
“Send him in, please.”
The door opened slowly. Mark was a man in his late thirties, dressed in clean, slightly faded jeans and a button-down shirt that looked like it had been ironed with nervous hands. He had the build of someone who might have played college sports but had since traded the field for a desk. His eyes, a warm hazel, darted around the room, taking in the bookshelves, the abstract art on the walls, the comfortable armchair opposite hers, before finally landing on her. He offered a tight, brief smile.
“Mark, hello. I’m Grace,” she said, her voice calm and warm, gesturing to the chair. “Please, make yourself comfortable.”
“Thanks,” he said, his voice a little rough. He sat perched on the edge of the cushion, as if ready to bolt. He clasped his large hands together, his knuckles white.
They went through the necessary preliminaries—confidentiality, the structure of their sessions. He nodded along, his gaze fixed on a point just over her shoulder.
“Your intake form mentioned some recurring patterns in relationships,” Grace began, leaning forward slightly, her posture open and non-threatening. “And some trust issues. I’d like to hear about that in your own words, when you’re ready.”
Mark was silent for a long moment, studying his hands. The quiet in the room wasn’t empty; it was thick with unspoken history.
“I just… I don’t get it,” he finally blurted out, his voice cracking with a frustration that seemed to surprise even him. He looked up, and for the first time, his eyes met hers directly, pleading for an answer. “I do everything right. I’m a nice guy. I listen. I remember birthdays. I don’t play games. I’m… available.” He said the word like it was a weakness. “And it’s like they smell it on me. They get bored. Or they find someone more… exciting. More of a challenge. And then they leave.”
He looked down again, deflated. “It’s always the same. It’s like I have a sign on my back that says ‘Kick me, then leave.’”
Grace listened, not just to his words, but to the shame laced through them. He wasn’t just describing heartbreak; he was describing a fundamental flaw he believed he possessed.
“That sounds incredibly painful, Mark,” she said, her tone imbued with a deep empathy that felt holy in its simplicity. “And exhausting. To consistently show up with integrity, only to feel it’s the very reason you’re rejected.”
He nodded, his throat working. He seemed startled to be understood so directly.
“You used the word ‘available’,” Grace continued softly. “And you said it like it was a bad thing. Can you tell me what you think being ‘available’ means?”
Mark shrugged, a helpless gesture. “I don’t know. Needy, I guess. Predictable. Boring.”
The words hung in the air, heavy and familiar. Grace felt that quiet nudge in her spirit, a compulsion to reframe, to offer a different lens—one polished by her faith but offered in a universal language.
“I’d like to offer a different perspective, if I may,” she said. He nodded, watching her warily. “What if ‘availability’ isn’t weakness? What if it’s the greatest strength one can bring to a relationship? What you’re describing—showing up, listening, being present—that’s not being boring, Mark. That’s building a foundation of safety. It is the absolute bedrock of trust.”
She chose her next words with immense care, stripping them of any specific doctrine. “In any meaningful human connection, showing up consistently and authentically is the highest form of respect. It’s a quiet courage. The ‘challenge’ you mentioned… that often isn’t strength. It’s often fear, disguised as excitement.”
Mark was listening intently now, his body slowly uncoiling, sinking back into the chair as if the bones had been removed from his body. He looked like a man who had been braced for a blow that never came.
“The right person,” Grace said, her voice firm yet kind, “won’t be bored by your decency. They will be drawn to it. They will see that safety not as a cage, but as the freedom to be their truest self. The problem isn’t your availability, Mark. The problem is you’ve been offering it to people who don’t have the capacity to value it.”
A single, surprised tear escaped and traced a path down his cheek. He quickly wiped it away, embarrassed.
“Sorry,” he muttered.
“Please don’t be,” Grace said, handing him the box of tissues without hesitation. “That’s what this room is for.”
He took a tissue, clutching it in his fist. “So what do I do? Just… keep getting hurt until I find this mythical ‘right person’?”
“No,” Grace said, smiling gently. “We work on helping you see your own worth so clearly that you stop accepting crumbs from people who can’t appreciate the feast you’re offering. We work on helping you trust yourself first.”
The session ended a few minutes later. As Mark stood to leave, his posture was different. Still heavy, but less defeated. Less alone.
“Thank you, Dr. Evans,” he said, his voice quieter, but steadier.
“It was my honor, Mark. I’ll see you next week.”
After he left, Grace sat for a moment in the quiet room. She looked at the empty chair where a man had just entrusted her with his deepest shame, and she sent up a silent, grateful prayer to God, not for her own skill, but for the privilege of being able to offer a sliver of light in someone else’s darkness. It was, she thought, the best salary any job could pay. And the most exciting part of her entire day.
Now for the second exciting part of her date, her date with Marcus.