It had been two days since the banner incident, but the fallout still hung in the air like heavy fog.
Some students whispered. Others stared. A few—strangers who had never looked at her before—now offered Emery sympathetic smiles she didn’t ask for. The worst were the people who said nothing at all. The ones who just watched her as if she were entertainment.
Luca hadn’t left her side since it happened.
He walked her to class, waited outside the tutoring lab, dropped coffee on her desk without a word like it was the most normal thing in the world. He didn’t press. He didn’t make promises. He was just… there.
But even that couldn’t stop the storm she felt brewing inside her.
Because the more he showed up, the more she wanted to believe this—them—was real.
And the more terrified she was that it wouldn’t last.
⸻
That afternoon, as she crossed the quad in the rain, Emery spotted a familiar figure standing under the stone arch that led to the athletic wing.
Brielle.
This time, there was no smile. No venom disguised as charm. Just arms crossed, makeup perfect, umbrella tilted against the wind.
“You win,” Emery said simply, stopping a few feet away. “You got under my skin. You got the whole school watching.”
Brielle gave a small, mirthless laugh. “You think this is about you? This is about him.”
“Of course it is,” Emery snapped. “Because you don’t know how to want something without owning it.”
Brielle’s jaw clenched. “You have no idea who he is. The things he’s done. You think you’re some kind of cure? You’re just a distraction.”
“And you’re scared,” Emery said softly. “Because deep down, you know he never looked at you the way he looks at me.”
For the first time, Brielle said nothing.
But the look on her face—cold, stunned, wounded—was answer enough.
⸻
That night, Emery sat with Luca in his apartment, curled on his couch with her knees tucked to her chest. Rain pattered against the window. His record player played soft, scratchy jazz in the background—something old and strange that didn’t match the bruised tension between them.
“You ever wonder what would’ve happened if we’d met somewhere else?” she asked suddenly.
He looked up from the counter where he was making tea. “Like where?”
“Not here. Not this place with its nameplates and perfect families and rankings. Just… normal.”
Luca crossed the room, setting a mug beside her. “We wouldn’t have talked.”
“Why not?”
“Because I wouldn’t have deserved you then either.”
“Don’t say that.”
“It’s the truth.” He sat beside her. “I was angry, reckless, high off chaos. You wouldn’t have even seen me.”
“Maybe. But I see you now.”
She said it quietly, without hesitation.
Luca looked at her—really looked at her—and for the first time in days, he let his guard drop completely.
“You scare me,” he admitted.
Emery blinked. “What?”
“You make me want things I told myself I didn’t deserve. Peace. Trust. Something real.”
“You do deserve it.”
“No. I don’t.” He swallowed hard. “Not when I’ve been lying to you.”
Her stomach dropped. “Lying?”
“I didn’t know how to tell you. I should’ve told you weeks ago. Before we got close.”
He reached into his duffel bag on the floor and pulled out a folded envelope. Slid it across the coffee table toward her.
“What is this?”
“My family’s law firm. It’s… handling the case against the guy who made that banner. Brielle’s name is tied to it.”
Emery frowned. “Okay… so your parents are helping?”
“They’re not just helping.” He took a breath. “They’re pressing charges. And they’re using my name to do it. Without asking me.”
Her heart raced.
“So that’s why you’ve been quiet. You think I’ll hate you for it?”
“I think if Brielle goes down in court, everything explodes. Her family, mine. It won’t be just gossip anymore. It’ll be a war.”
“Luca…” She leaned forward, voice tight. “She tried to destroy me.”
“I know that,” he said. “And I’ll back you. All the way. But if this goes public, everything changes. I’m suspended already. The scouts are walking away. If we go nuclear, there’s no coming back.”
“So what are you saying?” Emery asked. “You want to let her get away with it?”
“No,” he said softly. “I want you to decide. I won’t push this if it costs you more peace. If you just want it all to stop, I’ll tell them to walk.”
She stared at him.
Luca Caldwell—bad boy, fighter, heir to the coldest dynasty at Halston—was giving her the final say. Over his career. His reputation. His family’s empire.
Because she mattered more.
And that terrified her.
But maybe love wasn’t the fairy tale. Maybe it was this—late-night storms, impossible choices, and someone standing beside you even when everything else fell apart.