By the time the doorbell rang, the house was waiting. Helena had staged the dining room like a battlefield disguised as a magazine spread—linen napkins folded into sharp triangles, wine breathing in crystal, the roast rabbit centered like a trophy kill. The twins had even made their beds, which spoke volumes about who was coming.
Ethan opened the door before the bell could sound a second time.
“Mom.” His voice softened, warm in a way reserved for her alone.
Patricia Hale swept in like winter wind wrapped in cashmere—gray coat, silk scarf, heels that spoke fluent authority. Her perfume—Chanel, unapologetic—threaded through the air as her smile curved, cool and precise.
“Ethan.” She kissed his cheek, cool lips leaving a faint trace of lipstick. “You didn’t think I’d miss dinner, did you?”
“Never,” he murmured, resting a hand briefly at her elbow. For all her edges, he loved this woman with a loyalty that felt carved into his bones. She had fought for him when no one else did. Her approval had always been his quiet compass—even when it pointed due north through a storm.
Helena appeared from the kitchen with a smile stretched like plastic wrap. “Patricia! We’ve been waiting. Everything’s ready.”
“How… thoughtful,” Patricia said, eyes gliding over the table with the detachment of a Sotheby’s appraiser confronted with amateur art.
“Grandma!” The twins spilled in like champagne foam, hugging her waist, giggling. Patricia allowed the affection, delivering a brief pat to each glossy head before stepping free.
She turned to Ethan with a glint that could cut glass. “You’re certain these are yours? I only ask because stupidity isn’t hereditary in our line, yet here they are speaking like reality television wrote their curriculum. Did you ever check the DNA?”
“Mom,” Ethan said under his breath, though the corner of his mouth twitched despite himself.
The seating arrangement formed a fragile truce around the table. Crystal chimed, plates gleamed, and for five whole minutes, civility held. Then Patricia cut into the rabbit, lifted one delicate bite, and paused mid-chew with the gravity of a surgeon halting on the operating table.
“Well,” she said finally, dabbing her lips with a napkin. “That’s… bold.”
Helena froze, fork in hand. “Bold?”
Patricia inclined her head, tone velvet lined with steel. “Yes. So much salt. A lesser palate might call it seasoning. I call it an act of defiance.”
Color flared high on Helena’s cheeks. “You know what, Patricia? I’m sick of it. Nothing is ever good enough for you. Not the house, not the wine, not the damn rabbit—”
“Helena.” Patricia’s voice sliced the air like silk through water. Calm. Cold. Perfectly measured. “If you believe excellence feels like persecution, that’s not my failing. It’s yours.”
Helena’s mouth opened, closed. Rage painted her face but left her speechless.
Patricia returned to her plate with a serenity that mocked storm clouds. “Mmm,” she murmured, slicing another bite. “Persistent, though. Like a shoe stain that won’t scrub out. Admirable, in a tragic way.”
The twins pretended not to hear, eyes fixed on their screens under the table. Ethan took a slow sip of wine and said nothing. It wasn’t worth stoking fire when his mother was already building pyres with surgical precision.
When the last dish clinked into the sink and Helena fled upstairs under the excuse of “a headache,” Patricia glided into Ethan’s study without waiting to be invited.
The door closed. Silence gathered like smoke. Patricia settled into the leather chair opposite his desk, legs crossed in a line of elegance magazines would kill to print.
“You’re quiet,” she observed, smoothing an invisible crease on her skirt. “Which means you’re thinking. Hard.”
“Just a long day,” he said, but his voice lacked conviction.
Patricia’s gaze sharpened like glass under sunlight. “You’ve lost weight.” She tilted her head, eyes narrowing in slow calculation. “And gained something else.”
“Such as?”
“A spark,” she said simply. “I haven’t seen it in you for years. So—” Her mouth curved, feline. “Who lit it?”
Ethan let out a soft laugh, shaking his head. “There’s no one.”
“Oh, Ethan.” Patricia leaned forward, her perfume threading into his breath. “I’ve known you since your lungs screamed for air. You can’t lie to me. Not successfully.”
He didn’t answer. His silence was answer enough.
Patricia reached for his wrist, fingers cool, rings winking under lamplight. “Listen to me. If you want out, I’ll make it clean. The firm I use is discreet, surgical, and savage. Helena will walk away wondering which way was up.”
“Mom—”
“I’ll do better,” she said, voice dropping like a blade. “I’ll hire a private investigator. We’ll collect her sins, wrap them in ribbons, and drop them at your lawyer’s desk. Judges love evidence. And she’s careless—I can smell it from here.”
“Mom.” Ethan’s tone softened, threaded with reluctant amusement. “Not tonight.”
Patricia studied him another long moment, then rose, smoothing her coat with elegant finality. She bent, kissed his cheek, and whispered near his ear:
“I don’t care who she is—the woman who put that fire back in your eyes. I’m just glad she exists.”
Then she was gone, leaving the door ajar, her perfume lingering like an absolution and a dare in the same breath.
Ethan sat there, staring at nothing, her words circling like hawks in the dusk of his thoughts.