Catherine's POV.
"But I kept mute because I don't wanna ruin your dinner." I defended my actions.
"And when did I plead with you not to ruin my dinner?" He asked back and I opened my eyes wide in surprise, my lips parted to bring out words but I was speechless.
"Answer me Red hair, did I ask you to keep mute and watch other people ridicule you and call you names? Did I?" He asked again and I sighed, totally stunned by the new turns.
I'm entirely surprised by this new man sitting in front of me, talking to me with respect, "I just don't want to ruin things, people believe that I ruin lots of things so... I don't even know what to do, I'm just surprised right now." I expressed sincerely, astonished and unable to truly understand whatever was going on.
"I know how hard life has been w
