HIS GUILTY PLEASURE

CAUGHT BETWEEN US! 5

Chapter 5

Sophia’s POV

“f**k my legs are still shaking and his c*m is leaking down my thigh right now,” I whispered under my breath as I slipped out of the pool house first trying to fix my bikini top so it didn’t look like I just got railed hard against the wall.

My p***y felt raw and full from Ben’s thick load still dripping inside me, mixing with the fresh memory of him pounding me while my sister and husband splashed in the pool.

I walked back to the loungers slowly. My heart was hammering so loud I thought everyone could hear it.

Ben came out a minute later from the other side carrying those towels like nothing happened but his face was flushed and his swim trunks sat a little crooked.

Alex and Olivia were drying off by the pool edge laughing about who won the laps. “There you two are,” Alex called out, tossing cards on the table.

“We thought you got lost. Come on, let's play some cards before lunch. The loser buys the next round of drinks.”

Olivia waved me over her wet hair sticking to her shoulders looking so much like me it twisted the guilt deeper in my chest.

“Yeah sit down Sophia. You look all glowy. That sunscreen must be working well. Ben you join too. Family game time.”

I sat down carefully crossing my legs tight so none of Ben’s c*m would show but I could feel it slick between my folds every time I shifted.

My c**t was still sensitive from the way he rubbed it while thrusting deep and the pregnancy secret made my stomach flip harder now.

We dealt the cards and the game started light with laughs flying around but my mind kept spiraling back to the pool house.

The way Ben had growled in my ear calling my pregnant p***y while he filled me up again.

God I was dripping for more even now sitting right across from my twin.

“Got any sevens Alex?” Olivia asked, tossing a card down her foot brushing mine under the table like old times.

“You’re quiet today sis. Is everything okay? You seem a little off like your head is somewhere else.”

I forced a laugh picking up a card, my n*****s still hard under the wet bikini.

“I’m fine Liv, just the sun making me lazy. Your turn Ben. You got that jack I need?”

Ben’s eyes met mine across the table dark and full of heat as he slid a card over his knee pressing against mine hidden from the others. “Yeah here. But I’m thinking about other things too. Like how good that last round felt.”

His voice stayed casual but the words hit me low making my p***y clench around the mess he left inside me.

Alex chuckled dealing another hand. “You two are acting weird today. Ben you look like you just ran a marathon. Pool house too hot or something?”

Ben grinned wiping his face. “Something like that. These cards are killing me though. Olivia you winning again?”

The game went on with more trash talk and laughs but my body stayed on edge every brush of Ben’s leg sending fresh sparks to my swollen c**t.

The guilt pressed heavy too.

I had just let my sister’s husband f**k me raw while carrying a baby that might be his and now we were all playing cards like one big happy family.

My t**s felt heavier in the bikini top sensitive as hell from his mouth earlier and morning sickness mixed with the thrill making my head spin.

Olivia won the round and set her cards down, noticing me spacing out again. “Okay that’s it.

Sophia came with me real quick to the garden edge. Girl talk. You boys chat about tools or whatever while we do twin stuff.”

She grabbed my hand and pulled me aside near the flower bed away from the pool but still close enough to hear the guys talking.

Alex and Ben started chatting about the fence, repairing their voices low and easy like nothing was wrong.

Olivia turned to me, her face soft and serious, our identical eyes locking.

“Sis what’s going on? You know you can tell me anything. We’ve had that unbreakable bond since we were little, sharing every secret, even the dirty ones.

Is it Alex? Is he not f*****g you right? Or work stress? I hate seeing you like this.”

Her words made tears prick my eyes and fresh guilt crashed over me. I squeezed her hand tight feeling the warmth of her skin like mine.

“Liv it’s nothing bad I promise. Just some stuff on my mind.

You and me we’ve always been there for each other through every f****d up thing.

Remember when we switched dates in high school? This is like that but bigger.

You’re right though our bond is everything. I love you so much and I don’t want anything to mess that up.”

Olivia pulled me into a hug, her wet bikini pressing against mine, our bodies mirroring each other again.

“Good. Because I need you sis. Ben and I are talking kids soon and I want our families tight like this forever.

If something’s eating at you spill it later okay? We share everything, even the naughty fantasies.

I told you how Ben f***s me so good but sometimes I wonder if he thinks about other s**t. But with you here I feel safe.”

I hugged her back harder, my p***y still throbbing with Ben’s c*m leaking as I lied through my teeth.

“Yeah we share everything.

You’re perfect Liv. Don’t worry about Ben, he's lucky to have you.”

Inside my head the filth swirled heavily. I just let him stretch my cunt and pump me full while you swam laps.

This secret pregnancy might be his and I’m standing here lying to your face.

We pulled apart smiling softly and walked back toward the guys.

Ben glanced at me quickly, his hand adjusting his trunks like he was still half hard thinking about it.

Alex laughed at something Ben said, clapping him on the shoulder completely clueless.

Olivia looped her arm through mine. “Alright boys enough shop talk. Let’s head inside for lunch. I’ll throw some sandwiches together. Sophia you coming?”

I nodded but my legs felt weak from the mix of pleasure and shame. “Yeah in a minute. I need to hit the bathroom first to freshen up. Catch you inside.”

I excused myself quickly heading toward the house, my heart still racing as their voices faded behind me.

Ben’s gaze burned into my back one last time full of dirty promise and I wondered how much longer I could keep pretending before the truth f****d everything apart.