32

Chapter 3: Midnight and the Contract

Midnight came like a sentence.

Isabella stood barefoot in the hallway, the red dress clinging to her skin like it had a mind of its own. The mansion was quiet. Too quiet. Every step she took echoed, announcing her surrender before she even reached his door.

She didn’t knock.

She didn’t need to. The door opened before her hand touched it.

Donatello stood there, sleeves rolled up, black shirt open at the collar. No jacket. No mask. Just him. The Don who made men kneel and women run. But his eyes… they weren’t cold tonight. They were fire.

“You came,” he said. Like he wasn’t sure she would.

“You said midnight,” she answered. Her voice shook. She hated that. “I keep my word.”

“Even when it breaks you?” He stepped aside. “Come in, Mrs. Moretti.”

The room was dark except for a single lamp. No guards. No witnesses. Just the weight of the contract between them and the ring on her finger catching the light.

Isabella walked in, arms wrapped around herself. The dress felt like a mistake now. Too much. Too little. “Is this how it works? You give orders and I obey?”

Donatello closed the door. The click echoed louder than any gunshot. “No. This is how it works when you belong to me.”

He moved closer, slow, like he was giving her time to run. She didn’t. She couldn’t. Running meant prison. Running meant death. Staying meant… this.

“Take it off,” he said quietly.

Her breath caught. “The dress?”

“The armor.” His eyes didn’t drop from hers. “The walls. The hate you wear because you think it’ll protect you. Take it off, Isabella. With me, you don’t have to pretend.”

She laughed, sharp and broken. “Pretend? You bought me. There’s nothing real here.”

“Then why are you shaking?” He reached for her hand. His fingers were warm, calloused, sure. He turned her palm up and pressed a kiss to the inside of her wrist. Right over her pulse.

Her whole body betrayed her with a shiver.

“Because I’m scared,” she admitted. The truth tasted like blood. “Of you. Of this. Of wanting you when I should hate you.”

Donatello’s thumb brushed her knuckles. “Good. Fear keeps you alive. Want keeps you mine.”

He didn’t touch her anywhere else. Not yet. He just stood there, holding her hand like she was something fragile instead of collateral. Like she mattered.

“You can still say no,” he murmured. “I won’t force you, Isabella. I don’t want a corpse in my bed. I want you. All of you. Willing or not at all.”

The words cracked something in her chest. Every monster in her nightmares took what they wanted. Donatello was offering a choice. And that terrified her more.

“I chose the ring,” she whispered. “I chose this. I chose you.”

“Then choose me now,” he said. Not a command. A plea, wrapped in steel.

Isabella stepped forward. Her hands found his chest, fisting in his shirt. His heartbeat was steady under her palms. Strong. Certain. The opposite of her chaos.

His hands came up to frame her face, thumbs brushing her cheeks like she was made of glass. “Look at me,” he ordered softly. “No more hiding.”

She did. And drowned.

The kiss wasn’t soft. It wasn’t gentle. It was years of control snapping, possession turning to hunger, hate twisting into something darker, hotter, impossible to name. He kissed her like she was his salvation and his sin. Like he’d been starving and she was the only thing that could feed him.

Isabella kissed him back. Fierce. Desperate. Angry at him, angry at herself, angry at the way her body melted into his like it had been waiting for this exact destruction.

His hands slid down her back, careful even while his mouth demanded more. When he broke away, both of them were breathing hard.

“Rules,” he breathed against her lips. “Never lie. Never run. Never forget who owns you.”

“Never,” she whispered back, “forget that I own you too.”

Something dangerous flashed in his eyes. Pride. Lust. Maybe love, though neither of them would dare call it that yet.

He lifted her. She didn’t fight him. She wrapped her arms around his neck instead, hiding her face in the crook of his shoulder as he carried her to the bed. The red dress pooled around them like blood and sin.

Outside, the Moretti mansion kept its secrets. Inside, two people with too much pride and not enough sense started a war neither of them could win.

Because this wasn’t just consummation. This was surrender.

And surrender, Isabella was learning, was the most dangerous kind of power.

When dawn broke, she was still in his arms. The ring on her finger no longer felt cold. It felt like a brand.

Donatello traced the line of her jaw with his thumb, watching her sleep. “Mine,” he murmured, too soft for her to hear.

Isabella dreamed of fire. And woke up burning.