The Debate
1439 Words
Katherine had learned to read a room without lifting her head.
She could tell when laughter was about her. She knew which chairs creaked louder when she sat down. She could sense when someone leaned in just close enough to whisper—never to her, always about her.
And she had mastered the art of disappearing in plain sight.
But that Tuesday morning, something changed.
She walked into third period Honors Civics and saw her name written on the whiteboard.
Next to Kristoff Santiago’s.
Her stomach dropped.
“Surprise, surprise,” Mr. Reeves announced with exaggerated cheer. “Our school’s been invited to compete in this year’s Regional Academic Debate. And guess what? We’re going with our two top-performing seniors. Congratulations to our representatives—Kristoff Santiago and Katherine Diaz.”
Murmurs spread across the room like wildfire.
“Wait, they’re partners?” someone whispered.
“Poor Kristoff,” Cara muttered with a smirk. “He’ll have to carry her and her lunch.”
Kristoff leaned back in his seat and tossed a glance over his shoulder. His expression wasn’t confused—it was insulted.
“Reeves,” he called out lazily, “You sure you didn’t mix up the pairings?”
“Nope,” Mr. Reeves said without missing a beat. “You two are perfect opponents. I mean, partners.”
The class chuckled. The boys in the back row high-fived each other.
Katherine stared at the board, throat dry.
This was the opportunity of a lifetime. Regionals were a big deal—college scouts watched those debates. Winners often landed scholarships, not just trophies.
It was the platform she needed.
But standing next to Kristoff? Sharing a podium with the boy who made her life miserable?
This wasn’t just a challenge. It was a setup. A test. A cruel joke she didn’t have the luxury to laugh at.
The first meeting was held after school in the debate room, a space lined with dusty trophies and cracked leather chairs. Katherine arrived early. Her notes were already spread out, color-coded and tabbed with ruthless precision.
Kristoff strolled in ten minutes late, his football jacket slung over one shoulder, a water bottle in hand like he’d just come from track practice.
“Nice of you to join us,” she muttered without looking up.
“Don’t sound so excited,” he replied, dropping into the chair across from her and stretching out. “Let me guess. You've already outlined our entire case and assigned me the parts that make me sound dumb?”
Katherine didn’t rise to the bait. “The prompt is on education reform. We’ll be arguing the effectiveness of government-funded charter schools.”
“Riveting,” he said with a yawn. “Let me guess. You’ve got a hundred statistics ready to bore the audience to death.”
“At least they’re real,” she snapped. “Try reading something other than your reflection for once.”
He chuckled under his breath. “You’ve got claws, Diaz. Cute.”
She flushed but didn’t respond. She wouldn't let him drag her into a game he’d already mastered. He was fire, and she’d been burned enough.
The next few sessions were brutal.
Kristoff was arrogant, dismissive, and half the time, completely unprepared. He challenged her not to improve their arguments but just to prove he could. He interrupted. He mocked. He questioned her data with smirks instead of facts.
“You’re acting like you’re the coach,” he said one afternoon, tossing her flashcards into the air like confetti. “We’re partners, remember?”
“No,” Katherine replied, gathering the cards. “We’re a genius and a narcissist forced to collaborate. Big difference.”
He rolled his eyes. “You say that like it’s a bad thing.”
It didn’t matter how brilliant her outlines were or how airtight her rebuttals sounded—Kristoff found ways to undermine her, one sarcastic comment at a time.
“Flashcards? Really?” he said. “What are we, fifth graders?”
“They help,” she replied through gritted teeth.
“They make you look desperate.”
Katherine stared at him for a moment. “Better desperate than lazy.”
He scoffed and leaned back, spinning a pen between his fingers. “You should be thanking me, you know. Being paired with me might be the only reason anyone in the audience stays awake.”
Outside of debate prep, the bullying didn’t stop.
Cara posted a photo of Katherine eating alone at lunch with the caption: “A queen eats alone when no one wants to be near her throne.”
It made the rounds in less than an hour.
Miguel “accidentally” knocked her books into a puddle outside the locker room. When she knelt to retrieve them, drenched and muddy, the cheer team snickered in the distance.
Kristoff passed by with his hands in his pockets. He looked down at the scene for a moment, jaw tightening—
Then kept walking.
No words. No help. No smirk this time.
Just indifference.
And honestly, that was worse.
The night before the debate, Katherine sat on the floor of her bedroom, surrounded by notes and half-drunk mugs of tea. The window beside her was open, letting in the cold bite of autumn.
This debate could change everything.
She didn’t just need to win.
She needed to own that stage.
She could already picture it—Kristoff in his tailored blazer, grinning at the audience like it was prom night.
And beside him, her.
The girl no one expected to shine.
She wouldn’t let them forget her name.
On debate day, Katherine wore a simple navy skirt and a white blouse. Her hair was tied back in a clean ponytail. No makeup. No frills.
Kristoff arrived looking like a model out of a prep school brochure. Slate-gray suit. Blue tie. Polished shoes.
“You ready, Diaz?” he asked as they stood backstage, arms folded.
She didn't respond.
“Don’t choke,” he added, smirking. “I’d hate to win this thing by myself.”
She shot him a look. “Don’t worry. I’m used to doing things alone.”
He grinned wider, like he’d won the exchange. “So dramatic.”
The auditorium lights dimmed.
They walked on stage.
Kristoff delivered the opening statement. Predictably charming. Slightly shallow. But loud and confident enough to make people listen.
Then it was Katherine’s turn.
She stepped up to the podium and cleared her throat.
And for the first time in a long time, the world quieted.
She spoke with calm, measured conviction. Her voice didn’t shake. Her points were structured with surgical precision—statistical data followed by human impact, case studies followed by ethical questions.
By the time she finished, the room was dead silent.
Then came the applause. Slow at first, then spreading.
Katherine stepped back, face flushed, but proud.
Kristoff didn’t look at her.
He didn’t need to.
He felt it too.
They won the debate.
The margin was narrow, but it was a win.
Afterward, teachers patted Kristoff on the back. Classmates hovered around him, offering high-fives and fake compliments. Katherine stood a few feet away, clutching her folder, unsure where to stand.
Someone passed her and muttered, “Didn’t think she had it in her.”
Cara brushed by her and said under her breath, “Probably memorized the whole thing. Nerds always have tricks.”
Kristoff didn’t even glance her way. He soaked up the spotlight like it was made for him.
And when Mr. Reeves offered his congratulations, Kristoff shrugged and said, “Not bad for a pity pairing.”
The words hit Katherine like a slap.
She blinked. For a moment, she thought he’d say something real—acknowledge her work, her grit, her mind.
But no.
There was no redemption here.
Just another reminder.
Even when she succeeded, she would never be enough for them.
That night, Katherine received a message on her school account.
Anonymous.
“Congrats. You got lucky.”
She stared at the screen.
She didn’t reply.
She didn’t save it.
She closed her laptop, turned off the lights, and lay back in bed.
The silence of her room was kinder than any words they could give.
Because she knew the truth:
They didn’t cheer for her.
They cheered despite her.
And if they clapped, it was because she’d forced them to listen.
Not because they wanted to.
Not yet.
But someday…
They would.
And when that day came—
She wouldn’t need their applause.
She’d be far too busy building the life they said she could never have
- Writer
- chap_listContents
- likeADD