Chapter Five
The scent of bacon, eggs, and fresh scones hung in the air like a peace offering no one trusted.
Sunlight poured through the tall windows of the dining room, bouncing off the polished surfaces and casting golden patterns across the table. It was the kind of morning that tried too hard to feel normal.
Betty made sure it wouldn’t be.
She walked in slowly, deliberately. The black mini dress clung to her frame, short enough to raise eyebrows, tight enough to shut mouths. Her shoulders were bare, her chin high, and the soft tap of her heels against the hardwood floor was the only sound in the room for a few seconds.
Chris looked up — and immediately choked on his toast.
His hand flew to his mouth, eyes bulging as he coughed and reached blindly for his glass of juice. Betty didn’t flinch.
Laura turned her head.
Her jaw clenched.
"Good morning," Betty said brightly, sliding into the seat directly across from Chris, who was still struggling to recover.
Bennett, halfway through buttering his bread, froze. His eyes moved from Betty’s legs to her face, then back again, like he was trying to convince himself he was imagining it.
“What,” he began, blinking hard, “are you wearing?”
“A dress,” Betty replied, pouring herself a glass of water like she belonged there.
“It’s barely a dress,” Laura said coolly, folding her hands on the table. “Where exactly do you think you're going?”
“Here,” Betty said. “To breakfast. Unless there’s a sign somewhere that says legs must be covered to enter.”
Chris let out a sharp laugh, then quickly turned it into a cough when Laura shot him a look sharp enough to slice through the butter.
“I bought it yesterday,” Betty went on casually, picking up a fork. “Figured if I’m going to be paraded around like someone’s long-lost daughter, I might as well look the part.”
“There’s a difference between fashion and… indecency,” Laura muttered, reaching for her teacup.
Betty smiled without warmth. “Good thing I didn’t ask for your opinion.”
“Betty,” Bennett said, voice low. “This is not how we do things here.”
“I’m not a ‘we,’” she said. “I’m still figuring out what I am in this house. But one thing I’m sure of? I’m not invisible.”
Chris was staring at her now. Not in shock anymore. In something that looked dangerously close to admiration.
Betty stabbed a piece of bacon with her fork. “Besides,” she added, without looking up, “I’ve got legs. Would be a shame not to use them.”
Silence.
Even the clock on the wall seemed to tick slower.
Laura sat back stiffly, the corners of her mouth twitching as if she wanted to say more—but for once, didn’t.
The tension settled like steam above the plates.
Chris finally broke it.
“Well,” he muttered under his breath, eyes on his eggs, “breakfast just got interesting.”
Betty didn’t smile, but the corner of her mouth lifted slightly.
Mission accomplished.
The clinking of cutlery, the sharp glances, the silence that followed every word — it all faded behind her as Betty stepped out into the garden after breakfast.
The heels came off first. She carried them in one hand, her bare feet sinking slightly into the damp grass. The dress still hugged her tightly, but out here, with the wind brushing against her skin and the distant chirping of birds, she finally felt like she could breathe again.
“Girl, you are mad,” came a voice from the stone bench under the lemon tree.
Betty turned and saw Tasha grinning wide, sunglasses perched on her nose and a half-eaten mango in her lap.
“Tasha,” Betty said with a small sigh, collapsing onto the grass beside her. “Please tell me you didn’t see that whole thing.”
“Oh, I saw everything,” Tasha said between bites. “Laura’s face looked like she’d swallowed a lemon whole. And Chris? I thought he was going to pass out.”
Betty chuckled. “He actually choked.”
“You walked in like a hurricane,” Tasha said, laughing now. “All that drama before 9 a.m.? Iconic.”
Betty groaned and fell back into the grass, staring up at the sky. “I didn’t even do it for attention. I just… I needed to feel like myself. Or at least in control of something.”
Tasha pulled off her sunglasses and looked down at her. “And did it work?”
Betty was quiet for a second. “Yeah,” she said finally. “I think it did.”
Tasha nodded, thoughtful. “Good. Because in that house? They’ll eat you alive if you let them.”
Betty sat up slowly. “You know, no one talks about how weird it is. Being dropped into this rich, perfect family with secrets in every corner and tension thick enough to choke on.”
“Welcome to the club,” Tasha said. “Bennett’s world is all about appearances. Laura runs it with a smile and a scalpel. And Chris…”
“What about Chris?” Betty asked, trying to sound casual.
Tasha gave her a knowing look. “Chris is the wild card. Keeps to himself. Doesn’t trust easily. And if you’re smart, you won’t start thinking you’re different.”
“I don’t,” Betty lied.
Tasha smirked. “Sure.”
A breeze rustled the lemon tree above them. Betty picked a blade of grass and twisted it between her fingers.
“I miss my dad,” she said quietly. “Even when he was drunk, even when he forgot my birthday… he was still mine. Still familiar.”
Tasha’s tone softened. “It’s okay to miss what’s broken. Doesn’t make you weak.”
They sat in silence for a while, the weight of everything unspoken between them.
Then Tasha stood and brushed off her jeans. “Come on, troublemaker. I’ll take you to town. You need something sweet. And maybe pants.”
Betty smiled. “I will go and change.”
Downtown was already heating up, the Texas sun rising high and proud over red-bricked storefronts and faded painted signs. Betty walked alongside Tasha on the uneven sidewalk, her sandals slapping gently as they passed a diner, a hardware store, and a thrift boutique with a “BUY 1 GET 1” scrawled in chalk on the window.
“You know,” Betty said, munching on a powdered donut from a brown paper bag, “for a place that looks like it hasn’t changed in fifty years, it kinda works.”
Tasha grinned, sipping sweet tea from a to-go cup. “That’s ‘cause it hasn’t changed. This town is stuck in the past — but in the charming kind of way.”
They stopped at a corner, where a few food trucks lined up near the courthouse square. The smell of brisket and grilled onions floated in the air, mingling with the twang of country music playing from a nearby radio.
Betty turned to a stall selling handmade jewelry. “I don’t even wear bracelets, but I want five of these.”
“Tourist energy,” Tasha teased. “You’ll get over it.”
“Bet.”
They were still laughing when a voice rang out across the square — smooth, cocky, and way too confident.
“Well I’ll be. Didn’t think the Bennetts let y’all off the ranch without a chaperone.”
They turned.
A tall guy leaned against a navy blue pickup, cowboy boots crossed at the ankle, a ball cap tugged low over a head of tight curls. His skin was golden brown from the sun, his smile lazy like he had nowhere to be and knew you'd come to him anyway.
Tasha rolled her eyes. “Here we go.”
“Who’s that?” Betty muttered under her breath.
“MJ Ryder,” Tasha said. “His daddy owns the auto shop on Main. Thinks he’s God’s gift ‘cause he can rebuild an engine and sing country blues.”
“You forgot devastatingly charming,” MJ added, strolling toward them. His belt buckle gleamed in the sunlight. “So… you’re the mystery girl living up in the big white house.”
Betty crossed her arms. “You people really talk about me that much?”
“It’s a small town, sweetheart. A new face in Bennett’s house? That’s practically front-page news.”
She smirked. “Sorry to disappoint. I don’t bite.”
“Shame,” MJ said, grinning. “I’m a sucker for girls with sharp teeth.”
Tasha groaned. “MJ, leave her alone. She doesn’t have time for your cowboy nonsense.”
MJ ignored her, eyes still on Betty — not leering, just intrigued. “I’m just being friendly. You got that look, though… like you’re not here to play nice.”
Betty tossed her donut wrapper into a trash bin and looked him dead in the eye. “I’m not.”
He chuckled. “Thought so.”
She turned and started walking. “Tell your small town to get better gossip. I’m boring.”
“Oh, honey,” MJ called after her, “you just made this town a whole lot more interesting.”
Tasha burst into laughter as they walked away. “Girl. He’s gonna be obsessed with you now.”
Betty shrugged. “Let him. I’ve got bigger problems.”
But her smile gave her away
They made their way to the edge of the square, where a row of vintage shops spilled their treasures onto shaded sidewalks. Tasha ducked into a consignment store, already oohing over a rack of embroidered denim jackets, but Betty hung back by the window, distracted.
Something tugged at her — a prickle on the back of her neck.
She turned.
Across the street, MJ still stood by his truck, arms crossed, sunglasses pushed up on his head. He was watching her — openly. But not just watching.
Talking to someone.
A man, older, maybe in his forties, stood beside him. Greying beard, stiff posture, a sheriff’s badge clipped to his belt.
The man glanced at Betty, his expression unreadable.
MJ said something with a grin, but the man didn’t smile back. Just gave a curt nod, then walked off toward the courthouse, boots hitting the pavement like punctuation marks.
Betty frowned.
Tasha returned a moment later with two shopping bags and a beaming smile. “Okay, I got a jacket I absolutely didn’t need and some earrings that scream ‘I’m reckless.’ Success.”
Betty nodded slowly, eyes still on the courthouse steps. “Hey… who’s the guy MJ was talking to?”
Tasha followed her gaze. “Oh. That’s Deputy Cole. Town watchdog. If someone so much as breathes too loud, he knows.”
“He looked at me like I’d broken a law.”
“Because you did,” Tasha said with a wink.
“Does he not like my mom?” she asked.
Tasha hesitated. “Your mom’s… complicated in this town. People respect her name. They just don’t love the way she earned it.”
Betty glanced down at her outfit, suddenly aware of how out of place she looked among denim, boots, and cotton sundresses. Her tiny designer bag felt loud against the rhythm of this quiet town.
“Maybe I should’ve stayed home.”
“Nope,” Tasha said firmly, looping her arm through Betty’s. “They can side-eye all they want. You belong wherever you choose to stand.”
They started walking again, but the feeling in Betty’s gut hadn’t left.
Not everyone welcomed strangers here.
And she was no longer invisible.