The final morning of the academic retreat began with an air of anticipation.
Inside the conference hall, students whispered nervously as faculty members took their seats.
The dean stepped onto the stage.
“Before we conclude this retreat, we have an important announcement.”
The room fell silent.
“Each faculty mentor may endorse only one research paper to represent the university in the Inter-University Research and Innovation Competition.”
A wave of surprise spread through the audience.
Only one?
Ariana’s heart sank.
She had assumed all finalists would advance.
Instead, they would now compete against one another.
⸻
After the announcement, Professor Kael gathered the students under his supervision.
“I will evaluate your work based on one criterion.”
Everyone listened carefully.
“The quality of your research.”
One student raised a hand.
“Professor… will participation in class or our relationship with you affect your decision?”
Kael’s expression remained calm.
“No.”
He looked at each student in turn.
“I do not choose favorites.”
“If your paper deserves to represent this university, it will.”
“And if it doesn’t…”
He paused.
“You will revise it until it does.”
⸻
Later that afternoon, Ariana remained in the seminar room, reviewing her latest draft.
She rubbed her tired eyes.
No matter how much she revised, it never seemed enough.
“You’ve been staring at the same paragraph for fifteen minutes.”
She looked up.
Professor Kael stood beside the table.
“I can’t figure out how to strengthen my conclusion.”
He pulled out a chair—but deliberately left a respectful distance between them.
“Read it aloud.”
She did.
When she finished, Kael folded his arms.
“You’re summarizing.”
“I know.”
“Don’t summarize.”
She frowned.
“Convince.”
Those single words changed everything.
Ariana looked back at her laptop.
Instead of repeating her findings, she began explaining why they mattered.
Her fingers moved quickly across the keyboard.
Several minutes later, she smiled.
“I think… I got it.”
Kael read the revised paragraph.
After a long silence, he nodded once.
“Better.”
Coming from him, that single word felt like an achievement.
⸻
As they left the seminar room, neither of them noticed a phone camera pointed in their direction from the end of the hallway.
A student quietly took a photograph.
The image showed Ariana and Professor Kael walking out of the room together.
From that angle, it looked far more suspicious than it really was.
The student smirked.
“This should be interesting.”
⸻
Monday morning…
The university had returned to its usual rhythm.
Students hurried between classes, unaware that an anonymous envelope had been slipped beneath the dean’s office door.
Inside were several printed photographs.
Among them…
A picture of Ariana and Professor Kael leaving the seminar room side by side.
Attached was a typed note.
“A professor should know the boundaries between mentoring and favoritism. Please investigate before the university’s reputation is damaged.”
The dean quietly set the photographs on the desk.
There was no proof of wrongdoing.
But there was enough to warrant a closer look.
Outside, Ariana walked across campus carrying her research notes, completely unaware that a single anonymous complaint had placed both her future—and Professor Kael’s career—under scrutiny.
⸻
End of Chapter 9
Chapter 10 Teaser:
Professor Kael is called to the dean’s office to answer questions about the anonymous complaint. To protect both Ariana and the integrity of the university, he makes a difficult decision that leaves Ariana confused and hurt, unaware that he is trying to shield her from the growing controversy.