They drove in silence.
Inside, the dashboard lights cast shadows over his face, making him look like a ghost from a story Sienna wanted to forget.
She sat stiff in the passenger seat, holding her bracelet tightly inside her coat pocket. Her other hand scrolled through an encrypted folder on Lucas’s old tablet. It had photos, notes, and names. Malbridge’s address was highlighted in red.
"She moved out here?" Sienna asked, glancing at the run-down houses. "I thought she left the state."
"She did. Oregon. But she came back a year ago. Quietly. No work, no social media. Changed her name.
"She’s hiding."
Lucas nodded. "So are we all?"
Sienna sighed. City lights faded behind them. “I feel like this is a trap.”
“Maybe it is,” Lucas replied. “But if we want answers, she’s the first real lead we have.”
They turned onto a narrow street. At the end was a small apartment building, three stories tall, made of yellow brick. One flickering hallway light was visible outside. Lucas parked two blocks away and turned off the engine quickly.
As they stepped into the cold night, Sienna’s instincts screamed.
“Lucas,” she whispered, slowing down. “Something’s wrong.”
He looked around the street, then faced her. “What did you see?”
“Nothing. That’s the problem.” She made a subtle gesture. “No cars, no lights, no one smoking outside. It’s too quiet.”
Lucas reached into his jacket and pulled out a small black, compact handgun.
Sienna blinked. “You always carry that?”
He didn’t answer but signaled for her to stay behind him.
They moved carefully, boots crunching broken glass. Lucas tested the front door. It was locked.
Then Sienna noticed something.
A faint glow behind a second-floor window. She saw movement, a shadow pacing back and forth. Then it disappeared.
“There's someone upstairs,” Sienna whispered.
They circled to the back, where a fire escape climbed the wall like ribs. Lucas tested it; it felt solid.
Sienna followed him as he climbed.
Lucas looked through a c***k in the curtains on the second floor.
He swore softly. “It’s her.”
He knocked twice.
Inside, nothing moved.
He knocked harder.
Finally, the curtain lifted slightly. A pale, lined face looked out. It was Ms. Malbridge, older, thinner, but still her. Her eyes locked on Lucas, then darted to Sienna.
They widened in fear.
She shook her head quickly and mouthed something. Not now.
Lucas raised his hands, showing he meant no harm.
She pointed behind them.
Sienna turned just in time to see a black car pulling up slowly.
“Run!” Lucas hissed.
A figure with the face hidden by a scarf and hat stepped out of the car.
Lucas and Sienna slid down the fire escape into the alley. Something hit the railing where they had been seconds earlier. A silenced shot.
They ran fast.
Lucas pulled her behind a dumpster, crouched low, gun ready, breathing hard.
“That was a warning,” Lucas said quietly.
“No,” Sienna answered, heart pounding. “That was a message.”
Moments later, they were back in their car driving in silence, slightly shaken from the encounter.
“She tried to warn us,” Sienna said. “She’s scared.”
“She has every reason to be.”
Lucas turned onto an old highway, pulling out his phone and typing quickly. “I hacked her apartment signal. She’s using a burner phone. I’m sending her an encrypted message.”
“What if they already got to her?”
“Then we’re out of options.”
Suddenly, the phone buzzed once.
One line.
"Meet me at the old theater. Midnight. Come alone."
Sienna read the message, her heart pounding. "She’s still in the game."
Lucas nodded grimly. "Then we better play to win."
The old theater looked like a forgotten relic from a faded photo.
Sienna arrived under the awning at 11:57 p.m., shivering with her coat.
Lucas had driven two blocks away, hidden out of sight.
They agreed only one should go inside. She hated the plan but knew it made sense.
Inside, a faint light flickered through broken glass doors. She took a step in.
The air smelled of dust and old times. Crumpled posters clung to the walls. A damp smell filled the space.
Her heels echoed as she moved toward the main auditorium. Then she saw her.
Ms. Malbridge sat in the third row, near the center aisle. She wore a gray coat. Her hair, once dark, was now white and thin, tied in a loose braid. A big thermos rested on her lap. It looked like she’d come to watch a film and refused to let time stop her.
"Ms. Malbridge?" Sienna spoke softly.
The woman didn’t turn. "Don’t call me that," she said. "Not anymore."
Sienna stepped carefully. "Then what do I call you?"
"Dead, if you keep standing out in the open," she snapped, her voice sharp despite her raspy tone.
Sienna quickly moved to the next seat and crouched beside her. The woman finally looked at her. Her face was older, tired from years of silence and secrets. Her eyes, though, were still sharp. Still haunted.
"You shouldn’t have come," she said.
"You told me to," Sienna replied.
"I warned you," Malbridge added.
Sienna took out the bracelet. Malbridge flinched.
"I remember more," Sienna said. "The blood. The scream. I remember Mira standing over the body. And I remember someone backstage, watching."
Malbridge’s lips quivered. "You were never meant to remember."
"But I do. And now Jaxon’s trying to control me. Blackmail me. He says I saw who did it. That I know the truth."
The older woman looked down at her hands. "You do."
Sienna’s breath caught. "Then it was him?"
Malbridge shook her head slowly. "No. It was worse."
Sienna leaned closer. "Tell me."
She hesitated. Then she opened the thermos and took a long sip. It wasn’t coffee. Sienna could smell whiskey, cheap and bitter.
"I didn’t just see it," Malbridge whispered. "I was part of it."
Sienna felt her footing shift. "He was not to die," she said. "We only wanted to scare him. Humiliate him. Make him leave things alone.
Sienna’s voice trembled. "Micah?"
Malbridge nodded. Her eyes looked empty. She took out an old, thick envelope from her coat. She handed it to Sienna. "Photos, notes, security footage not shown in the report. I made copies and hid them. I thought someday someone would ask."
Sienna's hands shook as she took it.
"They will hunt you," the woman said. "You know that?"
"Not this time," Sienna replied.
Malbridge gave a faint smile. "That’s what I thought once."
Behind them, a sound broke the silence. Sienna froze. So did the woman.
A door creaked somewhere deeper in the theater.
"You need to go," Malbridge hissed, full of panic. "They found me."
"Take the envelope. Show the truth. Don't let them change the story again."
Sienna stood, holding the envelope tight. She moved back as another creak came closer.
She turned and ran.
Outside, Lucas was already heading toward her. "What is it?"
"She gave me proof," Sienna said. “But someone is inside.”
A brief flash of light appeared, then a loud noise echoed, like a fight or struggle. A scream echoed but was quieted quickly.
Lucas grabbed her hand. “We need to leave now.”
They ran fast down the street, lost in the night.
The old theater behind them fell silent again.