Chapter 3 Costsof Secrets
1541 Words
“But then my family happened,” Hayley finished for her, nodding slowly.
Emily said nothing.
Hayley waited until she left before kicking off her shoes and sinking onto the bed. Her hands pressed against her face as everything hit her at once.
Dexter. Her kids. The past. The present. The fact that he stood right there, looked her in the eye and didn’t see her at all.
Now here he was. And the truth hung between them like a live wire.
He doesn’t know they’re his.
And she couldn’t tell him. Not like this. Not when his hatred ran so deep.
She stood, walked to the dresser, and stared at herself in the mirror. Blonde waves framed her pale face. Her blue eyes were hollow. Her lips pressed tightly, holding in screams she couldn’t afford to release.
“You don’t get to break me, Dexter Domenico. You don’t get that satisfaction.” she whispered under her breath.
But deep down, she knew she was already cracking.
Because she was afraid of marrying a man she didn’t love.
-------------------
Rob Walsh, Hayley’s ex-fiance, sat in his rented car across the street from the small elementary school in Houston. The late afternoon sun glinted off the windshields of the parked cars, and parents gathered on the sidewalk, chatting and waiting for their kids. He leaned forward, squinting as he watched Jacqueline Johnson, Hayley’s best friend, step out of the school building. Her dark curls bounced as she walked, her face serene but focused.
He had never planned to come to Houston, but the picture on Jacqueline's f*******: page had changed everything. The twins. The girl. A bright-eyed, blonde-haired child with an undeniable resemblance to Hayley. His heart thudded as he saw Jacqueline stride toward the parking lot.
It wasn’t just curiosity driving him anymore, it was a gnawing certainty.
Rob waited as Jacqueline got into her car, his fingers tapping the steering wheel nervously. When she drove off, he followed, maintaining a careful distance. The short drive to a nearby nursery school felt like an eternity, and when Jacqueline emerged holding the hands of two little children, his suspicions solidified.
He could see it now, the way the little girl tugged on Jacqueline’s hand with the same pout Hayley used to give him when she was annoyed. And her blonde hair, those blue eyes; it was like looking at a miniature version of her.
Jacqueline juggled the twins' backpacks as they squirmed in her grasp, eager to be free. As she unlocked the door to her small, cozy home, she felt the unease of being watched. She turned sharply, scanning the quiet street, but saw nothing out of place.
“Inside, guys,” she said firmly, ushering the twins in.
As the door closed behind her, Rob stepped out of his car. He crossed the street with purpose, his heart pounding.
Jacqueline froze when the knock came. It was firm and insistent, not the kind of knock she expected from neighbors or friends. She opened the door cautiously, and her heart sank.
“Rob?” Her voice wavered, surprise morphing into alarm. What the hell was he doing here? How did he get her home address?
He stood there, his expression sinister. “We need to talk,” he said.
Jacqueline stepped outside, closing the door behind her. “ We have nothing to talk about. You shouldn’t be here,” she replied.
Rob’s jaw tightened. "I didn’t come all this way to be turned away," he said firmly. "Whose kids are they, Jacqueline?”
Her face remained impassive. “That’s none of your business.”
“They’re Hayley’s, aren’t they?” Rob pressed. I saw the picture. The girl looks just like her!”
Jacqueline folded her arms, standing her ground. “Rob, I’m not discussing this with you. You need to leave.”
“Don’t lie to me!” he said smugly. “If those kids are Hayley’s, I have a right to know.”
Jacqueline’s eyes flashed with anger. “No you don't. You both aren't a couple anymore. Now go before I call the police.”
Rob stared at her, his mind racing. Her refusal to deny it outright only confirmed his suspicions. Finally, he took a step back, smiled broadly before turning and walking away.
---
Back in Las Vegas, Rob paced the living room of his apartment, his phone clutched in his hand. June watched him from the couch, her arms crossed.
“You’re sure about this?” she asked.
Rob nodded. “I saw them, June. The girl looks just like Hayley. I’d bet my life on it.”
June tilted her head, her lips curling into a sly smile. “Well, well. Looks like our dear Hayley had a few secrets after all.”
Rob stopped pacing and looked at her. “What do you mean?”
June leaned forward, her tone conspiratorial. “Think about it," she said softly. "Hayley’s been dodging us, keeping her distance for a few years now. But if these kids are hers, she’s got a weakness now, a secret she doesn’t want to get out."
"Yeah...."Rob nodded attentively. Five years ago, after Hayley caught him cheating with June and ended their engagement, she disappeared. Perhaps she fled to hide the fact that she was already pregnant.
"Then who is their father?" June asked puzzled. "You should be..."
Rob's eyes widened as the possibility of his fatherhood dawned on him. His lips broke into a mischievous smile.
"I never thought of that," Rob said slowly. "Did she move to Houston to have my kids in secret?"
June chuckled. "Well, if those kids are yours..." Her voice trailed off in conspiracy.
---------------------
Dexter leaned back in his leather chair, the dim light of his office casting long shadows across the room. A manila folder lay on the desk in front of him, its contents spilling slightly at the edges. He flipped it open for the third time, scanning the meticulous report Alfred Wood, his right-hand man, had compiled.
“Hayley Summer Darnell,” Dexter muttered, tapping a finger against the photograph paper clipped to the file as he read. Thirty-three-year-old adopted daughter of mafia queen Miarbel Darnell. Parents killed in an accident. The drunk driver was never caught.
"Good job Mirabel," Dexter scoffed.
But why did Hayley move to Houston, and why had she missed Mirabel’s funeral?
He picked up another photo. It captured Hayley and a dark-haired woman in a restaurant. There was another photo of the same dark-haired woman walking out of a modest daycare, holding two little kids.
Dexter skimmed through the accompanying reports.
Jacqueline Johnson, Hayley’s best friend. Thirty-one years old, an elementary school teacher. Single, no criminal record, no debts, no scandals. A model citizen. But it wasn’t Jacqueline who intrigued Dexter. It was the children she was with. Whose kids were they?
----------------
The grand cathedral was cloaked in an air of cold austerity, its towering stained-glass windows casting fractured light onto the silent congregation. Both sides of the aisle were filled with members of the Domenicos family and a few dignitaries of Las Vegas who sat shoulder to shoulder, their faces painted with astonishment, and a hint of suspicion. Muted whispers rippled like waves, curiosity crackling in the air. Everyone was here to witness the unthinkable, a union of sworn enemies.
There was no one from the Darnell family in attendance, which everyone noticed. Clutching the bouquet in her trembling hands, Hayley’s heart pounded like a distant drum as she walked down the aisle. Had she made the right call? Her flowing white gown shimmered as if mocking the storm that brewed in her heart. The faces of the crowd blurred as her eyes fixed on the man at the altar.
Dexter stood like a statue carved from ice, his sharp suit darker than the shadows cast by the grand chandelier. His jaw was set, his expression unreadable, and his piercing gaze pinned her in place. He was the heir to everything she had been taught to despise, yet here she was, marrying him to fulfill the will of Mirabel.
As she reached the altar, Dexter offered her his hand. It was cold, firm and unyielding. His calmness unnerved her, made her feel smaller in his shadow.
Standing before him, her gaze lingered on Dexter’s steely grayish-blue eyes for a fraction of a second, and at that moment, her breath caught.
'Dylan'
For a fleeting heartbeat, she thought she saw her son’s face mirrored in Dexter’s features. The memory of Dylan’s bright laughter and mischievous smile surfaced, and her knees nearly buckled.
Her reverie was shattered as the priest began the ceremony, his voice echoing through the cavernous space.
“Dearly beloved, we are gathered here today to join...”
The priest’s words were cut short by the sound of the heavy doors of the cathedral bursting open with a resounding sound. A collective gasp rippled through the crowd as Rob strode in, his voice cutting through the sanctity of the moment like a knife.
“Stop this farce!” he bellowed, his eyes blazing as they locked onto Hayley. “You think you can stand here in white and hide the truth?”
- Writer
