The Wrong Question

1377 Words
Episode Two: The Wrong Question She didn't sleep. Not really. She lay on top of her covers with the letter on the nightstand, face down, like it might behave itself if she couldn't see it, and she watched the ceiling until the light outside turned from black to gray to the flat white of a Tuesday morning nobody wanted. By seven she'd made a decision, and by seven-fifteen she'd unmade it twice. She wasn't going to call him. Calling him meant admitting the letter had done exactly what it was supposed to do, which was make her afraid enough to reach for the one person in her life she had a genuine reason not to trust. That wasn't logic. That was fear dressed up as curiosity, and she knew the difference, even at seven in the morning with no sleep in her. She went to work instead. It didn't help. She sat through a client call about signage and heard maybe half of it. She caught herself typing Adrian's name into three different search bars and closing them before hitting enter, like that made it not count. At lunch, Priya slid into the seat across from her with the particular look she got when she already knew something. "You look like hell," Priya said. "Thank you." "No, I mean it as a diagnostic tool. What happened." Mara hesitated long enough that Priya's eyebrows went up. "Nothing happened," Mara said. "I just didn't sleep." "Uh-huh. And this has nothing to do with the mystery man from Saturday who apparently knew where you live." "I didn't tell you that part." "You told me enough of it that I filled in the rest." Priya leaned in. "Mara. I say this with love. If a strange man tells you he knows your building and your work schedule, that's not a meet-cute, that's a police report." "I know." "So?" "So I'm handling it." Which wasn't a lie, exactly. She just hadn't decided yet what handling it looked like. She didn't tell Priya about the letter. She didn't tell anyone about the letter. That had always been the rule underneath the rule — some things you didn't hand to other people, because once they knew, they had opinions, and opinions became worry, and worry became the kind of attention that made people feel like they had a claim on you. She went home at six, and Adrian was sitting on the step outside her building like he'd been invited. She stopped four feet from him. Didn't get closer, didn't run. "This is the part where you tell me how you knew I'd come home this way." "You always come home this way," he said. "It's two minutes longer than the other route. You take it because it passes the bakery, even though you never go in." "You've been watching me." "Not the way you mean." He stood, slow, hands visible, like he'd thought about how this would look before he did it. "I need to ask you something, and I need you to actually think about the answer instead of deciding what you're supposed to say." "I don't owe you a conversation." "No," he agreed. "You don't." He didn't move toward her. That, more than anything he'd said, was what made her stay. "Ask," she said. "The letter you got yesterday." He watched her face when he said it, and whatever he saw there, he didn't look satisfied by it — if anything, he looked like he'd been hoping he was wrong. "Who else knows you received it?" Her stomach dropped the exact same way it had at her kitchen table. "How do you know about the letter." "Answer the question first." "No one," she said, before she could stop herself, before she could remember that she hadn't agreed to trust him with anything. "No one knows. I didn't tell anyone." Something in his shoulders eased, just slightly, like a held breath let partway out. "Good. Keep it that way. For now." "For now." She laughed, and it came out sharper than she meant it to. "You show up outside my apartment, you know things about a letter I burned four years ago, and your advice is keep it that way for now? Who are you? What do you actually want from me?" "I want you to survive the next part," he said. "That's not an answer, I know. It's the only true thing I can give you right now." "That's not good enough." "It's the truth. Sometimes those aren't the same thing as satisfying." She crossed her arms, planting herself, refusing to be the one who looked unsettled even though her pulse was doing something erratic under her ribs. "Then let me ask you something. And I want the truth, not the riddle version." "All right." "Is someone controlling my life?" She expected him to deflect. She'd built the question wanting him to deflect, honestly, because some small cowardly part of her preferred the version of this where he was simply an obsessive stranger and not something worse. He didn't deflect. "You keep asking who is in control," he said quietly. "But you're asking the wrong question." "Then what is the right question?" He stepped closer, close enough that she could see he hadn't slept either — the same gray under his eyes that she'd caught in her own mirror that morning. "Why do you think there has to be someone in control?" The words landed wrong, sideways, like a door opening onto a room she hadn't known was in her own house. She wanted to laugh it off, call it pretentious, tell him that of course something had been in control, because things didn't fall apart the way her life had fallen apart by accident, not all at once, not that cleanly. But she looked at his face, and for just a second — less than a second — she saw something there she hadn't expected. He looked afraid. Not of her. Not of getting caught in whatever game he was playing. He looked afraid the way you look when you've said something true out loud for the first time and immediately regretted how true it was. "Adrian." His name came out of her before she decided to say it, softer than she meant it. "What aren't you telling me?" He opened his mouth. Whatever he was going to say, it didn't come. Because behind him, at the end of the block, a car had pulled up that Mara recognized — dark, unremarkable, the same one that used to sit outside her mother's house in the last year of her life, when her mother had started locking every window even in summer, and telling Mara stories that sounded like fairy tales and turned out to be warnings. Adrian followed her gaze and went very still. "Go inside," he said. "Now. Lock the door. Don't open it for anyone, not even me." "Who is that." "Mara." His voice had changed completely, all the careful stillness gone out of it. "Please. Go inside." For the second time in three years, she found herself doing exactly what someone else told her to do, and hating how much safer it felt than deciding for herself. She didn't see what happened on the sidewalk after her door closed. She only heard it — low voices, then nothing, then the sound of a car pulling away too fast for a quiet residential street. When she looked through the peephole ten minutes later, Adrian was gone. So was the car. And sitting on her welcome mat, placed there with the same deliberate care as the letter two days before, was a single photograph she had never seen before — an old one, creased and yellowed, of three people standing together outside a house she didn't recognize. Her mother. A man she didn't know. And a woman standing slightly apart from both of them, watching the camera like she resented being made to stand still for it. Mara had never seen this woman's face before in her life. And yet, looking at it, she felt the strangest, most unwelcome certainty settle into her chest. She knew exactly who this woman was. She just didn't understand how that was possible.
Free reading for new users
Scan code to download app
Facebookexpand_more
  • author-avatar
    Writer
  • chap_listContents
  • likeADD