Unlikely Lovers

Chapter17

Cait POV (Involves s****l content, if not interested please skip)

What have I got myself into? I think to myself as I make a crazy bet. I fully expected the guys to beat me at the game to take the pressure off of me. Unfortunately that is NOT what happened. I won. Now I have to figure out what to do with BOTH of them. Hopefully I don't make a fool of myself or ruin this before it even gets started.

"Which room are you wanting to do this in?" Was Brandon's question as we got back in the house.

"Who has the biggest bed?" I was delaying this as much as possible.

"I think that would be me," Brandon answered. Seeing my nervousness, "We don't have to do this tonight if you aren't ready. We aren't going to force you into anything."

"I am just worried about disappointing you both."

"There is no way that's going to happen." Tyler and Brandon said.

"Why don't you go get into something comfy and we'll meet you in my room? If anything, we can just chill and watch a movie on my TV." His suggestion was sweet and I went to my room to find something to wear. When I entered his room, I saw he'd brought some healthy snacks and waters up to his room. Tyler was lying on one side of the bed with his head propped up and Brandon was on the other. They'd made room for me in the middle. As I crawled in between them, they each took one of my hands and kissed them. They let me pick the movie and I picked one of my all time favorites, Odd Thomas. Tyler rolled his eyes and Brandon looked at him with confusion. He'd never seen it. The guys behaved themselves for most of the movie, but near the middle, where the action started to pick up, they started to run their hands on my sides and over where the baby was growing. Near the end, Brandon started nibbling on my neck and Tyler followed suit. He put my hand on his growing bulge and he asked me if I liked what I felt. Then he kissed me. Brandon was kissing my shoulder and tweaking my n****e through my silk top. As Tyler ended the kiss so I could breathe, Brandon stole my lips for a kiss of his own.

"Is this okay or are we moving too fast?" Brandon asked me after he kissed me.

"I'm fine. What about you?" He took my hand and showed me how hard he was."I guess that answers my question."

"Can we take ur shirt off? I really want to see your breasts." Brandon confesses.

"They are amazing," Tyler answers before I get my shirt off.

"How do you know?" As far as I know, Tyler had never seen them.

"I kinda peeked at you one time in the shower when we were teens. I also caught a glimpse in a picture you sent Jeremy." Tyler admitted.

"Well now you can truly see them," I said as I took my shirt off and motioned them to do the same. They had muscles that I couldn't help but touch. They didn't let me ogle their chests for too long. I was settled back on the pillows as they both picked a breast and started showering attention on it. Each of them had a different style and both felt amazing. Before I knew it, my night shorts were joining the pile on the floor.

"I think Tyler should get the privilege to taste you first since he has been waiting the longest," Brandon says.

"Does he want to?" I ask out loud. Before I can blink, I feel his breath on my v****a.

"Does that answer your question?" He asks as he runs kisses on the sides of my thighs. I moan and open my legs for him to explore more. Brandon uses the opportunity to play with my other breast. Before long, they both have me to the point of orgasming. It's something Brandon does that has me orgasming all over Tyler's tongue. Needing a break before they do anything else to me, I have them lay side by side as I switch off between stroking one c**k and sucking the other. Brandon decided I'd had a long enough break and decided to have a taste of my p***y. Gently flipping me around. He made sure I could still reach both c***s while he tasted me. His oral game was so good I started to get distracted. Especially when Tyler moved and started sucking on my n*****s. I was no longer able to do anything but enjoy the sensations the guys were giving me. Brandon upped the sensations when I felt something warm between my ass cheeks. Then he added a finger. I thought I was going to shoot into the atmosphere. He gently added another finger and then a third. At that point, he was making me feel like I was going to explode and then I did, all over his face, dosing him and the pillow. As I came down from the orgasm, both guys were still playing with my breasts and gently rubbing my p***y.

"Wow! That was mind blowing."I said as I was able to talk again.

"Now is the hard question, do you want one of us at a time or both?" Tyler asked. I thought and decided I'd do one at a time first and then move to both. Just like with oral, Brandon let Tyler go first. His only request was that I give him head while I rode Tyler. I wasn't sure how that would work, but Brandon quickly showed me how it could be done. After I came on Tyler's c**k, they pulled a switch on me again and I was doing doggy with Brandon in my p***y and Tyler's c**k in my mouth. He added new sensation by flicking my c**t with his tongue while Brandon had his c**k in me. Before long they had me on the verge of another orgasm. Brandon changed direction and suddnly was filling my ass with his c**k. I came all over Tyler. Next thing I knew, I had Tyler's c**k in my p***y again and Brandon was in my ass. I became such a ball of sensation it seemed I never stopped orgasming. I felt Tyler tense and then shortly after Brandon came. As we all came down from our respective climaxes, I realized I'd just had s*x with two guys.

"Don't be getting in your head. It was amazing and we don't think less of you for this. If anything it makes us want you more." Brandon said as he kissed me and got up."I plan to come back and cuddle, but I need to clean up first. Unless you want to join?"

"Tyler?"

"It's an operation to get into a shower for me right now. Go get cleaned up, I'll be right here."

"It will just be a clean up shower this time," Brandon told him. I began to wonder what wild ideas he had.

"Just make sure our girl isn't regretting what we just did. I found it amazing." Tyler said lounging on the pillows.

By the time we got out of the shower a little bit later, Tyler had put on another movie and looked like he was about to fall asleep. I crawled into the middle of the bed and cuddled into Tyler. Brandon got into bed behind me and we fell asleep in that position.