Mark Lancaster stands outside Alicia’s apartment with a brown paper bag clutched in both hands. His knuckles are white, his palms damp; he’s checked his watch twice in the last five minutes and, for the fifth time, runs his fingers through the messy shock of sandy hair on his forehead. He rehearses—again—the joke he wants to open with, but it slips away, replaced by the hammering in his chest.
There’s a light in Alicia’s window, a soft, homey glow that spills out past the crooked blinds. Her building is nothing like the mausoleum he grew up in; it’s three stories of painted brick, with a front stoop pitted by old winters and the friendly clutter of potted plants and worn welcome mats. He taps his foot, counts the seconds, then finally knocks.
It’s barely a beat before Alicia answers, as if she’s been waiting just on the other side. She’s in an oversized sweatshirt, wild curls uncontained, eyes bright even in the dim hallway. “Mark!” she says, opening the door with both arms as if she could hug the whole world in one go. “Come in, it’s freezing.”
He does, ducking under her arm, embarrassed at how his shoulders almost brush the doorframe. Alicia is small but not fragile—she moves with the purposeful energy of someone used to being busy, to taking care of things and people. The apartment is close and warm, filled with the smell of cinnamon and oranges and maybe, somehow, vanilla extract. There are books stacked on every flat surface, mugs left mid-sip, a stack of folders with colored tabs on the tiny dining table. It feels lived in, like a place that expects company.
She takes the bag from him and sets it on the kitchen counter. “I hope you brought the good cookies this time,” she teases, peeking inside.
“I tried,” Mark says, voice a bit too loud in the quiet space. He clears his throat, fumbles with the buttons on his coat. “The guy at the bakery said the snickerdoodles were fresh. But he’s lied to me before, so.”
“They look fresh,” Alicia says, producing two chipped plates from a cupboard. She smiles at him over her shoulder, and it hits him all over again, how good it feels to see her happy. “Tea? Or is tonight a cider kind of night?”
He hesitates, then: “Cider. If you have it.”
Alicia grins, spinning around to the fridge. “I always have it. There’s a little bit of rebel in me,” she confides, wriggling a jug from the packed shelf. “Don’t tell my sister. She thinks I live on herbal tea and good intentions.”
Mark laughs, the sound fraying at the edges. He stands awkward in the middle of the room, hands now shoved in his pockets, rocking on his heels.
Alicia looks back, clocking the movement. “You okay?”
He blinks. “Yeah! I mean. Yes. Sorry. I just—uh—long day.” He clears his throat. “Long week, really.”
She doesn’t press. Instead, she pours cider into two heavy ceramic mugs and sets them on the coffee table, which is covered in a constellation of glue sticks, paper scraps, and a half-built scrapbook with pastel pages curling at the corners.
Alicia’s apartment is a map of her life. There are photos tacked to the walls with washi tape, polaroids wedged in the mirror, a string of origami stars drooping from the bookshelf. There’s a stuffed bear on the sofa, battered but upright, and a dish towel with a motivational quote that would have made Vondrel’s skin crawl. Mark breathes in, lets the warmth soak into his bones.
He finally shrugs off his coat and drapes it carefully over the arm of a chair. Alicia is already cross-legged on the sofa, patting the seat next to her.
He sits, trying to keep his knees from touching hers, but the sofa is so narrow that they’re almost forced to overlap. He holds his mug with both hands, and for a moment, neither of them speaks.
“So,” Alicia says, “was it the boardroom, or the endless emails, or did someone spill coffee on you again?”
He laughs, almost choking on the cider. “How do you always know when it’s a coffee emergency?”
She points to his shirt, where a faint brown stain halos the edge of his cuff. “Clues,” she says, winking. “I could be a detective in another life.”
He smiles, shaking his head. “You’d be a great detective. People would just confess everything to you.”
She lifts her eyebrows, mock serious. “That’s the dream.”
Mark watches her for a second, wants to tell her something real, but the words stall in his throat. He’s never been good at this—at naming the thing he wants, at stepping out of the shadow cast by his own family’s gravity. He takes a deep breath, lets it out. “You, uh, working on a new scrapbook?”
Alicia’s eyes light up. “It’s for the wedding,” she says, pushing the book toward him. “I know it’s silly, but I wanted to make something for Mark and Rhonda to remember the day. I found this picture of them when they were little—Rhonda has Mark in a headlock, and he’s laughing so hard he’s purple.”
He grins at the image, then sobers. “Is that… is she still mad at me?”
Alicia shrugs, tucking a loose curl behind her ear. “She’s not mad. She’s… Rhonda. She wants you to be happy. She just doesn’t trust people who wear suits for fun.”
Mark looks down at his slacks, blushes. “I swear, it’s never for fun.”
They both laugh, and some of the tension in his chest eases.
The room falls into an easy hush, the kind that only comes when two people have known each other long enough to be silent together. Alicia sips her cider, watching him over the rim of her mug. “You’re really nervous,” she says quietly.
Mark’s grip tightens. “Is it that obvious?”
“Only to me.” She sets the mug aside and reaches out, covering his hand with hers. “You don’t have to say anything you don’t want to.”
He closes his eyes, grateful and ashamed all at once. “I do want to,” he says, “I just… I don’t know how.”
Alicia’s voice is soft, almost a whisper. “Start with the easy part, then. Why are you here?”
He opens his mouth, then shuts it. He looks at her—at her gentle eyes, her impossible patience—and tries again. “I missed you,” he says, and the words are so true, so simple, it almost breaks him.
She smiles, this time a little bit sad. “I missed you too, Mark.”
He wants to reach for her, wants to say all the things he’s been holding back, but his hands are shaking. He presses them together, staring at the point where her skin meets his, and finally, finally, manages to speak.
“I think,” he says, “I think I’m more afraid of what will happen if I lose you than if I lose everything else.”
Alicia blinks, caught off guard. “You’re not going to lose me.”
“I know,” he says, and tries to smile. “But sometimes, it feels like I’m going to lose myself.”
She squeezes his hand, gentle but sure. “You’re not your brother, you know.”
He laughs, a hollow, helpless sound. “No. But I’m not sure I know how to be me, either.”
Alicia shifts closer, so their knees touch, so he can smell her hair and feel the heat of her body. “You could start tonight,” she says. “Just… be here. With me.”
Mark looks at her, and for the first time all day, his heart slows down. He nods, swallowing the lump in his throat. “I’d like that,” he whispers.
“Good.” Alicia smiles, leaning back. “Because I made a playlist, and I’m not letting you leave until you listen to at least three songs.”
He laughs, a real laugh this time. “That’s blackmail.”
“Maybe,” she says, eyes sparkling. “But you’re worth it.”
They sit together, side by side, as the night settles in and the playlist hums softly from an old speaker on the shelf. Mark finds himself humming along, the words coming easier now, the warmth of the apartment seeping into places he thought were frozen for good.
Outside, the city is cold and dark, but in here, it’s nothing but light.