The drive back to Elkhorn was a blur. The trees whipped by in streaks of green and gold as the wind played with my hair through the open window. The scent of pine and wildflowers drifted in, mingling with the faint hint of rain still clinging to the air from the storm earlier that morning. It felt like freedom...or maybe just exhaustion disguised as it. Either way, I didn’t complain. I needed the peace of the drive, the hum of the tires against the asphalt, the sound of the wind roaring in my ears like a lullaby.
When I pulled into the long gravel driveway, the familiar crunch under my tires sent a little jolt of comfort through me. The barn looked the same, weathered red wood, crooked roof, and all, but somehow it felt different, as though the air around it was holding its breath. The big oak beside it creaked softly in the breeze, branches stretching out like old, tired arms. I sat there for a moment with the engine idling, staring at it all. It should have felt like coming home. But there was something in my chest that still felt untethered, like I’d left a piece of myself somewhere on the road.
With a sigh, I turned off the ignition and climbed out. The wind tugged at the hem of my shirt as I opened the back hatch to grab my duffel bag. My clothes smelled faintly of road trip coffee and motel soap...not exactly glamorous. I slung the bag over my shoulder and kicked the door shut behind me.
Inside, everything was just as I’d left it: slightly chaotic, slightly cozy, like the house had its own heartbeat that never really stopped even when I was gone. My boots left faint prints on the worn wood floor as I crossed to the laundry room. Hanging from the drying rack was Pepper’s dress; a soft lavender thing covered in delicate embroidery that looked like it belonged in a fairy tale. I had borrowed it for the weekend, and I could already imagine her waiting for it back, hands on her hips, pretending to be mad that I hadn’t returned it sooner.
I folded it carefully over my arm and smiled to myself. If I knew Pepper, she’d be waiting for me with a hug, a lecture, and at least three pastries I didn’t ask for.
The moment I stepped into her kitchen, the smell hit me like a wave; sugar, butter, and something tangy-sweet, like berries simmering in a pot. The kitchen itself looked like a baking war zone. There was flour on every possible surface, streaked across the counters like a crime scene. Mixing bowls sat stacked precariously beside the sink, which was overflowing with sticky utensils and berry-stained spoons. I could practically hear the health inspector fainting somewhere in the distance.
And there she was, Pepper, elbow-deep in a bowl of dough, her hair sticking out in every direction, cheeks flushed from the oven heat. Her apron was speckled with flour and streaked with berry juice, and she was humming something upbeat that I couldn’t quite place.
“Oh, Maggie!” she exclaimed when she saw me, her whole face lighting up like I was the best surprise she’d had all week. “Thank the Moon Goddess you’re back! I made fruit tarts just for you.”
“You made fruit tarts for me,” I repeated, glancing around at the flour-covered c*****e. “Did you also declare war on your kitchen, or was that just a side effect?”
She rolled her eyes dramatically and wiped her hands on her apron. “It’s called creative process, thank you very much.” Then she presented me with a plate of perfect, golden pastries that gleamed under the kitchen lights like tiny treasures. “See? Worth it.”
I grinned. “I do love tarts.”
“And I love you too, sweets.” Pepper winked and nudged the plate toward me. “Oh, and you have my dress. Let’s trade.”
Before I could even hand it over, she was gone, vanishing down the hallway. I laughed softly to myself and leaned against the counter, nibbling on a tart. When she came back, she was holding a sleek black garment bag, which she hung carefully on the back of a chair.
“Your grandma sent this yesterday,” she said, lowering her voice like it was a secret. “She said she saw you looking at it when you were at the mall, so she went back for it.”
I froze mid-bite, crumbs on my lip. “She didn’t…”
“She did,” Pepper confirmed, eyes twinkling. Then she reached for a plastic container and began loading it with tarts. “These ones are cracked on the bottom, so I cannot serve them. You must save me from disgrace by eating them immediately.”
“I see. A noble cause.”
“Exactly. Now get out of my kitchen and go get ready. You’ve got a big night ahead.”
Before I could protest, she shooed me out the door, laughing as she did it. I could still hear her humming as I climbed the stairs.
*****
In my room, I laid the garment bag across my bed and slowly unzipped it. The crimson dress shimmered in the afternoon light like it was alive, deep and rich, with layers of soft tulle that looked like they’d float if I so much as breathed too hard. I traced the edge of the neckline with my fingers, feeling the fine stitching and delicate beadwork. I’d admired this dress for weeks, but I’d walked away because the price tag made my soul leave my body. Apparently, Grandma Ellis had other plans.
I smiled and shook my head. That woman had a sixth sense for spoiling me.
Kicking off my boots, I carried the container of fruit tarts to the couch. I needed snacks and background noise before I could even think about showering. I queued up a true crime documentary and sank into the cushions. The tarts were heavenly, sweet, tart, buttery perfection that practically melted in my mouth. I licked the sugar from my thumb and muttered to no one, “Pepper could probably solve half the world’s problems if people just ate her pastries.”
The documentary played on, and I found myself weirdly relaxed. Something about listening to calm narrators talk about unsolved mysteries always soothed me. Maybe it was the order of it, the way every crime had evidence, every clue had meaning. Unlike life, where things just… happened, and you had to make peace with the chaos.
When it ended, I tossed the empty container into the dishwasher and finally dragged myself toward the shower. The hot water was a blessing, washing away the last remnants of exhaustion clinging to my body. I closed my eyes, tilting my head back, and let the steam fog up the mirror. The scent of my rose shampoo filled the air, soft and nostalgic.
By the time I finished, I felt human again. I wrapped myself in a towel and stood in front of the mirror, studying my reflection. My curls were wild, sticking out in defiance, so I grabbed the curl forms Aunt Lila had sent me last Christmas. They always made me look like an alien, but at least they worked.
I applied gel, wrapping each curl form around sections of hair with methodical precision. The hum of the blow dryer filled the air, and I laughed at my reflection, big, ridiculous, and shiny. “Ten out of ten, totally prom queen material,” I muttered.
Afterward, I sat on the bed, plugged in my little UV nail kit, and picked out a polish, deep crimson to match the dress. The gel gleamed under the light as I carefully painted each nail, toes included, because no self-respecting girl wears stilettos without matching polish. When the final layer hardened, I held my hands up, admiring the sparkle. “Royalty,” I whispered dramatically.
With my hair setting and my nails perfect, I curled up with my laptop and scrolled through Netflix again. Hours slipped by. I watched an episode of something I didn’t even care about just to fill the time. Every now and then, I caught myself smiling for no reason...maybe from excitement, maybe from nerves. The night ahead loomed like a glittering promise.
When the timer on my phone chimed, I went back to the vanity. It was time.
I sat down in front of the mirror, heart fluttering like I was about to walk on stage.