It was late in the afternoon. Bobby had called and asked everyone to meet him in the restaurant at the motel where they were staying in downtown Ossining. He promised that he had some exciting news. Jenny, Reuben, and Jonathan were waiting in a back booth when Bobby arrived. Jonathan was sitting next to Reuben, and Jenny sat across from them by herself. Bobby walked over to the table and sat down next to Jenny. A skinny teenage waitress came over and asked if he wanted coffee. He nodded, and she left to get him a cup, giving them a strange look as she went. Bobby smiled. It wasn’t often that you found a sheriff, an Amish man, a short-haired Amish girl, and a hippie all seated at the same table.
Jenny looked at Bobby expectantly.
“The man in the car was definitely Joseph K. Bender,” Bobby
