“What does it profit a man to gain the whole world and lose his soul?” Olivia’s voice thundered through the stained glass cathedral like a judgment bell wrapped in silk.
The air in St. Augustine’s Chapel held its breath. Every eye, freshmen, professors, rich trustees, bitter exes, remained locked on the slim figure standing at the pulpit. Dressed in her ivory lace blouse and navy skirt, Olivia Castillo looked like an angel descended from scripture. Her voice, though, held the heat of a prophet.
“You sit in this chapel every Wednesday, hands folded, eyes closed, pretending to pray. But tell me,” she said, her dark eyes narrowing, “what do you worship? God? Or your ambitions? Your grades? Your name?”
Silence. Heavy and waiting.
Only one man dared move, a shadow leaning against the last pew, arms folded. His jaw was bruised, lip slightly cracked. A boxer’s souvenir. But it was his stare that unsettled: cold, calculating, amused. He didn’t blink when Olivia’s gaze swept the crowd like fire across a dry field.
Michael Moretti.
He knew sermons. Knew performances. This girl, this pastor’s daughter, was better than most men he’d watched lie on TV or beg for their lives in backrooms. She didn’t tremble. Didn’t flinch.
She wasn’t acting.
Olivia’s fingers tightened around the edge of the pulpit. She felt her pulse in her neck, rapid. Her palms were slick, but her face remained composed, like her mother had taught her. Like her father expected. Preach to the soul, not the flesh. And yet, her mind whispered, you’re lying too, aren’t you?
She swallowed.
“I challenge you,” she said slowly. “To choose purpose over pretense. To search your heart and if you find nothing there, then maybe... it’s time you built something worth saving.”
Applause crackled through the pews like nervous static. Olivia gave a short nod, stepped down, and smiled as the choir began a soft hymn. People rose, murmured praise, handed her crumpled thank-you notes. But her feet carried her toward the chapel doors faster than she meant them to.
Outside, the cool spring wind hit her like absolution. She leaned against the marble archway and exhaled, trembling now. Her hands weren’t shaking because of nerves. They shook because she didn’t believe half of what she’d said.
And that terrified her.
“Nice sermon.”
The voice startled her. Deep. Rough. Amused.
She turned quickly.
Michael stood under the shadows of the chapel trees, cigarette in hand, bruises blooming along his cheekbone like violet war paint. He wasn’t a student. That much was obvious from the scars, the jagged tattoos under his collarbone, and the look in his eyes, like he’d already seen her naked soul and wasn’t impressed.
“Do I know you?” she asked, crossing her arms.
“No,” he said. “But you will.”
She blinked. “Excuse me?”
Michael stepped closer, dropping the cigarette and grinding it under his boot. “Juliet Bell. You were friends, right?”
The name slammed into her chest. Olivia straightened.
“Did something happen to her?”
Michael gave a bitter smile. “She’s dead.”
The words hit harder than any punch. Olivia grabbed the side of the chapel door to steady herself. “No. That can’t be. I just saw her last week. She said she was going to expose something about the student council-”
“Exactly,” Michael cut in, voice low now. “She was onto something big. And someone made sure she didn’t talk.”
Olivia stared at him. “How do you know all this?”
Michael stepped even closer. Too close. He smelled like metal and cedar and something burnt. “Because Juliet used to love me. Because I watched her die.”
A lump formed in Olivia’s throat. “Are you police?”
He laughed. Short. Dark. “No. I’m worse.”
She turned to go. “I think you need to leave. I don’t know what game you’re playing.”
Michael caught her wrist, not hard, but enough to freeze her. “You want the truth? You already know the university is dirty. You just haven’t looked close enough.”
Olivia yanked her hand free. “Don’t touch me.”
“Fair,” he said, stepping back. “But if you want to know who killed your friend, if you want to live long enough to finish your next sermon, you’ll meet me tonight. Off-campus. Warehouse 19. Midnight.”
She stared at him like he was insane. “Why would I trust you?”
“You shouldn’t,” Michael said, smirking. “But you will.”
Then he turned and vanished into the crowd of students spilling out of the chapel. Like a ghost.
Olivia stood there for several long minutes, heart pounding. Juliet was dead? And this man, this dangerous stranger knew why?
Her world tilted.
But what scared her most wasn’t the stranger’s words.
It was the part of her that wanted to meet him.