The Hollow sat three blocks off campus, small and easy to miss if you didn't already know it was there, tucked between a laundromat and a shop that sold nothing but candles. I'd found it my first week at Thornridge and never told anyone about it, not even Madison, because some places feel like they're only yours if you keep them quiet.
I ordered a coffee I didn't finish and took the table in the back corner, the one half-hidden behind a bookshelf nobody ever restocked, and let my shoulders drop for the first time all day.
Nobody here knew my name.
Nobody here had watched the video.
I pulled out my psych notes and stared at them without reading a single word, my mind still stuck on Ryan's face, on the word protection, on the way he'd said it like a kindness instead of a warning.
The bell over the door chimed.
I didn't look up. People came and went from The Hollow all the time, and none of them were my business.
Then a voice, low and familiar, cut clean through the espresso machine noise.
"You still have my jacket."
My head snapped up.
Vinai stood a few feet from my table, hands in his pockets, dressed down in a gray henley that did nothing to hide how broad he actually was. In daylight he looked even less like something that belonged in an ordinary coffee shop. Too still. Too aware. Like he'd clocked every exit in the room within a second of walking through the door.
"You found me," I said, and it came out more surprised than I meant it to.
"Small town." He nodded at the empty chair across from me. "Mind?"
"It's a free country."
He sat, and the chair looked briefly too small for him, and something in my chest did an embarrassing little flip that I decided to blame on the coffee.
"I actually do have your jacket," I admitted. "It's in my dorm. I wasn't avoiding you, I just didn't know how to find you again."
"I wasn't hard to find."
"You disappeared into a tree line like a ghost story."
That almost-smile again, sharper in daylight, softer around the edges than I remembered from the dark.
"Dramatic effect," he said. "Keeps girls wondering."
"Is that what I'm doing? Wondering?"
"Aren't you?"
I didn't answer that, because he wasn't wrong, and admitting it out loud felt like handing him something I wasn't ready to give away yet.
We talked for almost an hour after that. Easy things, at first. Classes. The terrible dining hall coffee compared to The Hollow's actually decent coffee. He asked what I was studying and actually listened to the answer instead of using the pause to talk about himself. I asked what he did for fun and he went quiet for half a second too long before saying, simply, "Sports. Keeps me busy in the fall."
I didn't push. Something in the way he said it told me not to.
"You never asked me what happened Saturday," I said eventually, turning my coffee cup slowly on the table. "Everyone else on campus already knows."
"Figured you'd tell me if you wanted to."
"You're not even a little curious?"
"I'm curious about a lot of things." His eyes held mine, steady, unreadable in a way that should have unsettled me and instead did the opposite. "Doesn't mean I need you to perform your worst day for me before I decide you're worth talking to."
Something in my throat tightened, and it took me a second to realize it wasn't sadness this time.
Nobody had ever put it like that before. Like my pain wasn't a price of admission. Like I got to just exist in front of him without explaining myself first.
"Thank you," I said quietly. "For Saturday. And for this."
"You don't have to thank me for being decent."
"You'd be surprised how rare that actually is."
Something shifted behind his expression, dark for just a second, like my words had landed somewhere he didn't let people see.
"Yeah," he said. "I would know something about that."
His phone buzzed against the table before I could ask what he meant. He glanced at the screen, and whatever he saw there changed something in his posture immediately, spine straightening, jaw setting, the easy warmth from a moment ago folding itself away behind something colder, sharper, more controlled.
"I have to go," he said, already standing.
"Everything okay?"
"Fine." He said it too fast to be entirely true. "Team thing."
"I thought you said sports kept you busy in the fall. What team?"
He paused at the edge of the table, and for just a second I watched him decide something, weigh it, choose his words the way you choose which door to walk through when you're not sure what's on the other side.
"Long story," he said instead. "I'll tell you sometime."
"Is that a promise?"
"I don't make promises I can't keep."
He was almost to the door when he stopped, turned back, and looked at me one more time across the length of the shop, something unreadable and warm and dangerous all at once behind his eyes.
"Same time next week?" he asked. "You know where to find me now."
Before I could answer, the bell over the door chimed again, and he was gone, out into the gray afternoon, leaving nothing behind but the ghost of cedar in the air and a question I couldn't shake.
Team thing.
I turned the words over in my head, and something about the phrasing snagged, small and sharp, like a splinter I couldn't quite locate.
Through the front window, just before he disappeared down the block, I caught a flash of red and black fabric shoved half into his gym bag. A jersey, maybe. Numbers I couldn't quite read from this distance.
Not Thornridge colors.
Our colors were navy and gold.
I sat there long after my coffee went cold, staring at the door he'd walked out of, and for the first time since Saturday night, the ache in my chest wasn't about Ryan at all.
It was about a boy with gold eyes and a jersey that didn't belong to my school, and the growing, unshakable feeling that whoever Vinai really was, he was about to turn my entire world upside down all over again.