That would be quite cruel, wouldn't it? It's ridiculous, but her life is pretty ridiculous. She wouldn't mark it as impossible.
Another thing that made her question the woman's veracity is also how she so casually brought up that they were childhood friends. Alpha Castle didn't grow up here. There would be photos, no doubt, and the staff would be more familiar with him if he had spent his childhood here. He does not seem particularly interested in settling down here, only to finalize some business matters his uncle had left. Then again, they could have studied elsewhere and it is mere coincidence that brought them both in this island?
There's also the matter of Beth never asking for Alpha James during the conversation. She wouldn't have known that James would be gone, seeing as he was ca
