Ah. So Cara didn't know about Jay. Or didn't know about Dawn. Or didn't know that Dawn was my niece. Or all three of these. This would be interesting.
"So... is it okay if I put the platter back on the table? I'm kind of freezing my goodies off here."
Cara made a point of looking me straight in the eyes as she said, "Yes, of course." I kept eye contact with her as I sat the platter onto the table. She kept it up for five seconds, then her eyes flicked down to my crotch. And lingered there. As usual, the attention made my c**k start to grow again. Cara said, "Oh, my."
Mary Beth snickered.
"Okay, it doesn't happen very often, but I'm getting embarrassed here," I said. "Either you two ladies get naked or I'm putting some pants on."
Mary Beth looked at me, then at her mom, then at me agai
