The whispers reached Karl secondhand, the way village whispers always did, arriving twice removed and slightly distorted by the time they found him.
It was Rowan who told him first, catching up with Karl on the road out of the market with the particular urgency of someone who'd been waiting all morning for the chance. "People are talking," he said, without preamble. "About you. About your family looking better fed than a household with a sick man and no coin ought to look."
"Talking how?" Karl asked, keeping his voice level, though something cold had already settled in his stomach.
"Just talking. You know how it is here — somebody notices something, tells somebody else, and by the third telling it's become a whole story nobody bothered to check was true." Rowan fell into step beside him, closer than he needed to. "Diego's been the one stirring it, mostly. Asking around. Being Diego about it."
Karl kept walking, jaw tight, running back through the past two weeks — the stew Maren had brought exactly when he'd needed it, the easier trades, the stone-hauling work that had come to him unprompted, small kindnesses that had felt, at the time, like nothing more than ordinary luck finally turning their way. He'd told himself none of it added up to anything worth noticing. He understood now, walking home with Rowan's warning settling heavy in his chest, that he'd been wrong to think no one else would notice it too.
"It's nothing," Karl said. "People exaggerate. You said so yourself."
"Sure." Rowan didn't sound convinced, but he let it drop, the particular kindness of a friend who sensed a door being closed and chose not to force it open. "Just — be careful, is all. Diego doesn't chase a story for no reason. Man's got an instinct for anything that smells like coin or trouble, and he doesn't seem to care much which one it turns out to be."
Karl said nothing further the rest of the walk home, but Rowan's warning sat with him long after they'd parted ways, and that night, alone in the cottage while his father slept, he took the ring from around his neck and looked at it for a long time in the dim firelight.
"I can't," he said quietly, to no one, to the ring, to whatever part of himself had whispered that first small wish into the dark eleven nights before. "Whatever you are. Whatever you can do. I can't keep using you and hope no one notices, because someone already has, and I don't know what happens if people start asking the wrong questions."
He wrapped it back in its scrap of cloth, tucked it beneath a loose floorboard near the hearth rather than wearing it against his chest the way he had every night since the bargain, and told himself, with as much conviction as he could manage, that this was the end of it. No more wishes, spoken or unspoken. No more strange good fortune that might be traced back to a boy who'd fought two serpents and walked away with something no ordinary woodcutter's son should possess.
It felt, in the moment, like the responsible choice. It felt, over the following days, like carrying a stone in his chest that never quite settled.
* * *
Jemarie noticed before anyone else did — before Diego's whispers had fully made their way around the village, before even Rowan's second, more pointed warning a few days later. She noticed the way Karl had gone quiet in a way that wasn't like him, jumpy at sudden sounds, prone to trailing off mid-sentence like his mind had wandered somewhere he wouldn't name.
She found him at the well on a gray, overcast morning, drawing water with more focus than the task strictly required, and studied him for a long moment before she spoke.
"You've been strange all week," she said, without preamble, in the direct way that had always been particularly hers. "Strange even for someone whose father's been sick. What's going on, Karl?"
"Nothing's going on."
"You're a terrible liar. You always have been — you get this look, like you're concentrating very hard on not saying something." She set down her own water jug, arms crossed, patient in the way that meant she wasn't going anywhere until she got something closer to the truth. "Is it about the forest? Rowan said you've been going in more than usual, and coming back different each time."
Karl's hand found the rope of the well bucket, giving himself something to do that wasn't meeting her eyes. "I don't want to talk about it. Not because I don't trust you. Because I don't fully understand it myself yet, and until I do, I don't think it's fair to drag you into whatever it turns out to be."
Jemarie's expression shifted — not offended, exactly, but sharpened, the particular focus she got when a puzzle had presented itself and she had no intention of leaving it unsolved. "That's not really an answer. That's a very polite way of telling me to stop asking."
"Maybe it is," Karl admitted.
She was quiet for a moment, studying him with an intensity that made him distinctly uncomfortable, and then, unexpectedly, she nodded, as though some private decision had been reached.
"All right," she said. "I won't push. Not today."
She picked her jug back up, turning to go, and then paused, glancing back at him with an expression Karl couldn't quite read — equal parts affection and stubbornness. "But you should know, Karl, that not pushing isn't the same as not looking. Whatever you're protecting me from, I'm going to figure it out eventually. I always do."
She left him standing at the well, water forgotten, her words settling into him with a weight he couldn't quite name — relief that she hadn't pressed harder, and underneath it, a colder, more familiar unease.
He had no way of knowing, watching her walk back toward the village, that Jemarie's own family held secrets far closer to Trubongco than either of them yet understood — secrets that her curiosity, once fully engaged, was about to start slowly, carefully unearthing.