The Hidden Drawer

2235 Words
James lay still in the dark, listening to Evelyn breathe. She had fallen asleep twenty minutes ago. He knew because he had counted her breaths, measured the deepening rhythm, tested her name twice in a soft whisper. No response. She was under. But he couldn't move. His body felt heavy, pressed into the mattress by something heavier than exhaustion. His mind raced through possibilities, discarding each one as quickly as it appeared. Evelyn had lied about his middle name. That was fact. But why? A wife of nine years would know something so basic. Either she had never known—which meant something was wrong with their entire relationship—or she had forgotten in a moment of stress—which meant nothing and everything. Or she had lied deliberately because the truth would have revealed something she wanted to hide. James turned the pill bottle over in his mind. Dr. Mark Ellsworth. Mercy Hospital. Lisinopril. Blood pressure medication. His father had died of suicide, not heart disease. But high blood pressure ran in the family. It was plausible. Too plausible. Every lie that worked was built on a foundation of truth. Evelyn was smart. She knew how to construct a believable story. She did it every day with her patients, helping them reframe their narratives, find new meanings in old memories. What if she was doing that to him? James sat up slowly. The bed creaked. He froze. Evelyn's breathing didn't change. He swung his legs over the side of the bed and stood. The floor was cold beneath his bare feet. He didn't bother with shoes. Silence was more important than comfort. The bathroom waited at the end of the short hallway, dark except for the pale glow of the nightlight. James walked toward it, placing each foot carefully, avoiding the floorboard that had squeaked since they moved in. He reached the bathroom and closed the door behind him. The click of the latch sounded like a gunshot in the quiet. He held his breath, waiting. Nothing. He turned on the light. The orange pill bottle sat exactly where Evelyn had placed it, third shelf of the cabinet, next to a box of bandages and an expired bottle of ibuprofen. James took it down and read the label again. James Cole. Lisinopril 10 mg. Take one tablet daily. Dr. Mark Ellsworth. Mercy Hospital. Dispensed 09/12/37. The date was three days ago. The prescription number looked real. The pharmacy address was a CVS three blocks away. James opened the bottle and poured one pill into his palm. Small. White. Unmarked. No imprint, no manufacturer logo, nothing to identify it beyond its shape. Normal blood pressure medication usually had imprints. Lisinopril came in many forms, but most had some marking. This pill was blank. He put the pill back and closed the bottle. Then he opened the cabinet again and looked deeper. Behind the bandages, behind the expired ibuprofen, behind the extra toothbrushes and the travel-sized shampoo, James found something interesting. A second pill bottle. Different color. Different label. Different name. Michael Harrison. Metoprolol 25 mg. Take one tablet daily. Dr. Sarah Chen. Northwestern Memorial Hospital. Michael Harrison. His best friend. Also on blood pressure medication? Michael was forty-one, fit, a runner. He had no history of heart problems. James would have known. He pulled out the bottle and examined it. The pills inside were different—scored down the middle, with a small imprint he couldn't read in the dim light. Why would Evelyn have Michael's medication in her cabinet? James put the bottle back and kept searching. Third shelf, back corner, behind a box of cotton balls. A third bottle. David Bennett. Amlodipine 5 mg. Dr. Mark Ellsworth. Mercy Hospital. David Bennett. The private investigator he had never heard of until today. And yet his medication was in James's bathroom cabinet. James's hands trembled as he put the bottle back. Fourth bottle. Fifth. Sixth. Each one had a different name. Each one prescribed by a different doctor or the same Dr. Ellsworth. Each one filled at different pharmacies across the city. Seven bottles in total. Seven people whose medications were hidden in his home. James recognized three of the names. Michael Harrison. David Bennett. Evelyn Cole. His wife had a bottle of her own—some kind of antidepressant he had never seen her take. The other four names meant nothing to him. Strangers. People he had never met. And yet their prescription bottles sat in his bathroom cabinet like trophies. He stood there for a long time, staring at the collection. Seven bottles. Seven people. Seven stories he didn't understand. Then he heard a sound behind him. James spun around. The bathroom door was still closed. The nightlight still glowed. Everything looked exactly as it had thirty seconds ago. But he had heard something. A soft scrape. Like fabric against wood. He reached for the door handle, then stopped. His hand was shaking. The whole bathroom seemed to tilt slightly, like a ship in rough water. You're burning up, Evelyn had said. The medication takes time to adjust. What if she was right? What if this was all in his head? What if he had imagined the bottles, imagined the names, imagined the entire night? James closed his eyes. Counted to ten. Opened them. The bottles were still there. He grabbed his phone from the counter and took photographs of each label. Then he put everything back exactly as he had found it, closed the cabinet, turned off the light, and opened the bathroom door. The hallway was empty. The bedroom was dark. Evelyn's breathing remained slow and even. James walked past the bedroom and into the living room. The city lights of Chicago glowed through the windows, casting long shadows across the floor. He sat on the couch and pulled up his contacts. Michael Harrison. His best friend since college. The man who had stood beside him at his wedding, who had held his hand at his father's funeral, who had never once let him down. James pressed call. The phone rang four times. Then voicemail. "Hey, it's Michael. Leave a message." James hung up. He tried again. Same result. He sent a text: Call me. It's urgent. Three dots appeared. Then disappeared. Then nothing. James stared at the screen, waiting. One minute passed. Two. Five. He called David Bennett next. The number wasn't in his contacts. He had to look it up, scrolling through his call log until he found an incoming call from three days ago. David Bennett. Duration: twelve minutes. He had spoken to David Bennett for twelve minutes and didn't remember. James pressed call. "Bennett Investigations." The voice was rough, alert, like a man who hadn't been sleeping. "David? This is James Cole." A pause. Then: "James. It's two in the morning." "I know. I'm sorry. I need to ask you something." "Go ahead." "Are you taking blood pressure medication?" Another pause. Longer this time. "Why are you asking?" "Because I found a bottle with your name on it in my bathroom cabinet. Amlodipine. Prescribed by Dr. Mark Ellsworth at Mercy Hospital." The silence stretched so long James thought David had hung up. "David?" "I'm here." "Do you know Dr. Ellsworth?" "Yes." "Have you ever taken amlodipine?" "No." James closed his eyes. The world tilted again. "Then why is your name on a prescription bottle in my house?" "James, listen to me carefully. Is Evelyn home?" "Yes. She's asleep." "Get out of the house. Right now. Don't wake her. Don't pack anything. Just leave." James's blood turned cold. "What?" "Evelyn isn't who you think she is. I can't explain over the phone. Meet me at the address I'm sending you. Come alone. And James—" "What?" "Don't trust anything she's told you. Not about the medication. Not about the doctor. Not about Chloe." The line went dead. James stared at his phone. A text message appeared a moment later. An address in the South Loop, near the old train yards. Not a neighborhood he knew well. He looked toward the bedroom. The door was still closed. Evelyn was still inside. What did David mean, Evelyn isn't who you think she is? They had been married for nine years. He had seen her graduate with her master's degree. He had held her when her parents died. He had nursed her through the flu and celebrated her promotions and fallen asleep beside her every night for almost a decade. He knew Evelyn. Didn't he? James stood up. His legs felt unsteady, but he walked to the front closet and pulled out a jacket. His wallet was on the kitchen counter. His keys hung on the hook by the door. He was halfway to the door when a voice stopped him. "Going somewhere?" Evelyn stood in the hallway, wearing the same clothes she had fallen asleep in. Her hair was mussed. Her eyes were wide awake. James's hand hovered over the doorknob. "I couldn't sleep," he said. "Thought I'd go for a drive." Evelyn walked toward him slowly. Barefoot. Silent. Her eyes never left his face. "At two in the morning?" "Insomnia." "You've never had insomnia in nine years, James. You sleep like the dead." He forced a smile. "First time for everything." Evelyn stopped three feet away. She crossed her arms over her chest and tilted her head, studying him the way she studied her patients when they were hiding something. "Who called you?" "No one." "Your phone rang. I heard it. You've been on the couch for twenty minutes. Who called?" "Wrong number." "James." Her voice was calm. Gentle. The voice of a woman who had spent her entire professional life learning to read lies. "Let me see your phone," she said. "No." "Let me see your phone, and we'll forget this happened. We'll go back to bed. In the morning, we'll call Dr. Ellsworth together. We'll figure out what's wrong." "There's nothing wrong with me." Evelyn's expression didn't change. "Then show me your phone." James's hand closed around the device in his pocket. The photographs of the prescription bottles. The text message from David. The call log that would prove he had been awake for hours, investigating, doubting, digging. If Evelyn saw any of it, the game would be over. But what game? What was he playing? Who was the opponent? "Evelyn," he said slowly. "What's my middle name?" She blinked. "We already did this." "Tell me again." "Arthur. Your middle name is Arthur. After your grandfather." "And my grandfather's name?" "Arthur Cole. He died before we met. You never knew him." James nodded. Everything she said was plausible. Everything she said could be true. Except he had never had a grandfather named Arthur. His father's father was named William. His mother's father was named Edward. He had told Evelyn this years ago, early in their relationship, when they were still learning each other's histories. She had forgotten. Or she had never known. Or she had known and chosen to lie anyway. Three possibilities. One truth. "You're lying," James said. Evelyn's face went still. Not angry. Not hurt. Just still, like a pond on a windless day. "Why would I lie about something so small?" "That's what I'm trying to figure out." She took a step closer. Then another. Now she was close enough to touch. James could smell her perfume, the same brand she had worn for years. Could see the small scar above her left eyebrow, the one that had appeared three weeks ago. "I love you," she said. "I have loved you since the day we met. I will love you until the day one of us dies. Everything I do, I do for you. For us. Do you understand?" "No." Evelyn reached out and took his hand. Her fingers were warm. Steady. "You're sick, James. Your mind is playing tricks on you. The memories you have of Chloe—they're not real. They're symptoms of something larger, something we're still trying to understand. But I promise you, I swear to you on everything I have ever loved, that we will figure this out together." Tears glistened in her eyes. Real tears, or tears that looked real. James couldn't tell anymore. "You need to trust me," she whispered. "Please. Just trust me." He looked at her face. At the tears. At the scar above her eyebrow. At the steady hands holding his. Then he looked past her, down the hallway, toward the bathroom where seven prescription bottles sat hidden in the cabinet. Don't trust anything she's told you. Get out of the house. Evelyn isn't who you think she is. James squeezed her hand once. Then he let go. "I'm going for that drive," he said. "I need to clear my head." Evelyn's expression flickered. Something crossed her face—frustration, maybe, or calculation—before she smoothed it away. "Take your phone," she said. "Call me if you need anything." "I will." He opened the door and walked out. The hallway was dark and quiet. The elevator arrived too slowly. James pressed the button again and again, willing it to move faster. When the doors finally opened, he stepped inside and pressed L for lobby. The doors closed. And through the c***k, just before they sealed shut, James saw Evelyn standing in their apartment doorway. She wasn't crying anymore. She was smiling.
Free reading for new users
Scan code to download app
Facebookexpand_more
  • author-avatar
    Writer
  • chap_listContents
  • likeADD