I did not answer the question.
Not because I could not. Because I sat cross legged on that bed staring at those scratched letters until the food went cold and I counted at least nine different answers and could not decide which one was true. Which one was first. Which wound opened the door for all the others.
That was the thing about being broken gradually. You stopped being able to locate the origin.
I ate the food cold. It tasted like nothing specific but it was warm going down and my body accepted it without drama. Then I sat the empty bowl back exactly where I found it and I waited.
He did not come.
The fire burned. The dark outside the window stayed dark. Time moved differently here. I could feel it, sluggish and thick, like it was not in any hurry to get somewhere because somewhere did not exist in the Hollowed Dark. Just here. Just this room. Just the scratched question in the stone that I was pretending to ignore.
I lasted four hours before I picked up a loose stone chip from the floor and scratched my answer beneath his question.
Everything. Nothing. I stopped keeping track.
Then I put the chip down and went back to the bed and stared at the ceiling and waited some more.
He appeared in the doorway without sound. No footsteps announcing him. No shift in the air. Just absent and then present the way a thought arrives suddenly and with full weight.
He looked at my answer in the stone for a long time.
"That is not an answer," he said.
"It is the only one I have."
He looked up at me then. Something sharp in it. Recognition almost. Like I had used his own words back at him and he was deciding whether that was deliberate.
It was deliberate.
He crossed the room and lowered himself into the chair beside the fire an actual chair, solid, old, like everything here and he sat the way ancient things sit. Like the concept of discomfort had simply never applied to him.
"Pick one," he said. "The first real one."
"Why."
"Because I am asking."
"You are not owed answers just because you have not killed me yet."
The fire shifted between us. His eyes did not.
"No," he said. "I am not." A pause. Long and deliberate. "I am asking because in six times I have never asked. Because you are the first one who arrived without something to say. Without begging or bargaining or screaming into the dark." His jaw tightened slightly. "Because the silence you carry is not empty and I find I want to know what fills it."
The honesty of it caught me off guard.
I had prepared for a monster. Cold, efficient, final. Something that consumed without curiosity. Something I could hate cleanly from a safe distance and let that hatred be the last thing I felt.
This was harder than a monster.
I looked at the fire.
"My sister," I said finally. "Maren. She is two years younger and she is everything I am not. Warm. Wanted. The kind of person a room reorganizes itself around." I paused. "I used to tell myself I was not jealous. That I loved her too much for jealousy." I paused again. "I was jealous. Every single day of my life I was jealous and I loved her anyway and neither feeling cancelled the other out."
Silence.
"That is not what broke you," he said. Not unkindly. Just accurate.
"No," I agreed. "But it is where the crack started. Everything else just found the crack and pushed."
He was quiet for a while after that. Long enough that the fire cycled through three slow pulses of light.
"Cracks," he said eventually, low, almost to himself. "Yes. That is usually how it works."
Something in his voice made me look at him properly. The severe face. The deep water eyes. The absolute stillness of a body that had existed long enough to stop fidgeting, stop performing, stop pretending at ease.
He was not untouched. I could see that now. Whatever he was, whatever centuries had built him into, there were cracks in it too. Old ones. The kind that had been there so long the edges had smoothed over.
"What broke you first," I said.
His eyes came to mine immediately. Not startled. More like he had been waiting for me to ask and was still somehow unprepared for it.
He did not answer.
He stood. Straightened. Became the severe unreadable thing again like pulling on a coat.
"Sleep," he said. "I will come tomorrow."
"You said that last night."
"I came."
"In the corridor. You stood outside my door and you listened."
He went absolutely still.
I had not known for certain. Just suspected from the quality of silence in the morning. The feeling of having been watched without being seen. But his stillness confirmed it faster than words could have.
"How," he said. Just that.
"I have been the person nobody watches for a very long time," I said. "I know the difference between being alone and being observed."
He looked at me for a long moment that had weight to it. Texture. Like the dark here — not empty but full of something that had not been named yet.
Then he left.
And this time I did not feel alone after.
That frightened me considerably more than the dying did.
In the morning I woke to find no food.
No bowl. No warmth. Just the fire and the dark window and the scratched words in the st
one and a second chair beside the first one that I was certain had not been there the night before.
Pulled close to the fire.
Sized exactly for me.