Ijeoma called two days later, her voice tight with the particular urgency of someone who had spent forty-eight hours making the kind of phone calls that made old friends suspicious of why she was suddenly asking.
"Her name was Somebody Nkiru," she said. "Nkiru Obi. I tracked down two people who remembered her one of Danny's old university friends, and a woman who used to work with him at his first job out of school. Both of them said the same thing, more or less. Danny was serious about her. Talking marriage-serious. And then, sometime in that final year before you and Emeka were supposed to get married, it fell apart, badly, and Danny disappeared from that whole social circle for almost two years afterward. Nobody really knew why. People assumed heartbreak. Normal heartbreak, the kind that makes a person pull away from mutual friends for a while."
"Did anyone know why it ended?"
"That's the part that took the longest to find out," Ijeoma said, and Adaeze could hear her friend take a breath, steadying herself for whatever came next. "Nkiru left him for someone else. That's the story, anyway, according to the friend from his old job Nkiru met somebody else, fell for him fast and completely, and ended things with Danny in a way people described as sudden. Cold, even. He didn't see it coming, apparently. It devastated him."
"Who did she leave him for?"
There was a long pause on the line.
"Nobody I talked to knew his name for certain," Ijeoma said. "But one of them remembered Danny saying it, once, bitterly, at a party, maybe a year after it happened, drunk enough to say more than he meant to. She said Danny called him 'the golden boy.' Said it like it was poison in his mouth. Everyone assumed he meant some rival at work, some general resentment. Nobody thought anything more of it."
Adaeze felt something drop through the floor of her stomach.
*The golden boy.* Emeka's own family had called him that, affectionately, for years his mother's pet name for him at every family gathering Adaeze had ever attended, a joke about how effortlessly he'd moved through life, university, career, love, as though nothing had ever truly cost him anything.
"Ije," she said, her voice barely above a whisper. "I need you to say the rest of it. All of it. Whatever else you found."
"There isn't much else," Ijeoma said. "Nkiru married the other man Danny's rival, whoever he was not long after. I couldn't find out for certain if it was Emeka. Nobody I spoke to knew Emeka personally enough to confirm the connection. But the timeline, Ada. The timeline fits in a way that made my stomach turn over when I worked it out. Nkiru left Danny roughly a year and a half before your wedding was supposed to happen. If she married Emeka in that window if Emeka had some previous relationship you never knew about, before you two got together "
"He did," Adaeze said slowly, memory surfacing now, unbidden, a fragment she hadn't thought about in years. "There was someone before me. He mentioned it once, early on, very briefly said he'd been engaged once before, that it ended badly, that he didn't like to talk about it. I never pushed. I never even asked her name. It felt like ancient history at the time, something that had nothing to do with us."
"Ada." Ijeoma's voice had gone very quiet. "What if it wasn't ancient history at all. What if Daniel spent years watching the woman he loved marry the man who took her from him — and then, when that man died, in a fire nobody properly investigated, found his way, eighteen months later, into the life of the woman that man had been about to marry instead. Not you specifically, maybe, at first. But somehow, eventually, you."
Adaeze sat with the full, sickening shape of it the theory assembling itself with a horrible, coherent logic she couldn't argue her way out of. A man who had lost the woman he loved to a rival. A rival who died suddenly, violently, in circumstances an experienced fire officer had flagged as suspicious and been overruled on. And then, not long after, that same man arriving patient, unhurried, endlessly understanding into the life of the rival's grieving fiancée, building a marriage on a foundation of carefully curated ignorance, letting her believe, for three years, that he had never known any of them at all.
It explained everything. The photograph hidden in the shoebox. The insistence, repeated so often it had become a kind of comfort, that he'd never had the chance to know Emeka. The nightmares that had begun, so conveniently, the exact week she started asking questions.
It did not yet explain the letters who was writing them, why now, after eight years of silence, someone had decided it was finally time for Adaeze to know.
"I have to go," Adaeze said, her hands cold around the phone. "I have to think."
"Ada don't do anything yet. Don't confront him. Not until we know more. Please."
"I won't," Adaeze said, though even as she said it she understood, with a strange, distant calm, that some clock inside her had already started counting down toward the moment she would.