DLAN
Three days before the proposal, I sent Julia a text, telling her I needed to see her. My fingers hovered over the screen before I pressed send, as though delaying it by a few seconds might somehow change what was coming.
When I picked her up that afternoon, the silence inside the car felt alive, thick enough to press against my chest. Streetlights slid across her face in soft golden flashes while my hands tightened around the steering wheel hard enough to ache. I wanted to speak—wanted to memorize the sound of her laugh one more time—but every word seemed to die somewhere between my heart and my throat.
I drove us to the same park where we had once stayed until midnight, talking about impossible dreams and forever promises. The gravel crunched beneath my shoes as I walked around to open her door. Julia slipped her hand into mine automatically, her fingers warm and familiar, and that simple touch nearly unraveled me. Together we walked beneath the dim glow of the lamps, the evening wind stirring the trees above us while silence stretched between us like fragile glass waiting to shatter.
By the time we stopped, my pulse was hammering so violently I could hear it in my ears. My stomach twisted itself into knots, and every breath scraped painfully against my throat. I turned to face her, and the moment our eyes met, the world seemed to still. There was something in her expression—a quiet, aching understanding—that made my chest cave in. It was as if she could already see the goodbye forming behind my lips, already feel the crack about to split both our hearts in two.
"I'm sorry, Julia. I've agreed to marry Sherry."
“Julia…” Her name broke from my lips like a prayer I no longer deserved to speak. I swallowed hard, forcing the words out before my courage failed me completely. “I’m sorry… I agreed to marry Sherry.”
The moment the sentence left me, it felt like watching something beautiful collapse in slow motion. The color drained from her face, her fingers slipping from mine as though the truth itself had burned her. And yet the pain that tore through her eyes carved just as deeply into me. It was the kind of wound that leaves no blood, only ruin.
She shook her head immediately, small desperate motions at first, then stronger, as if denying it could somehow stop it from becoming real. “Please don’t do this,” she whispered, her voice trembling beneath the weight of tears she could no longer hold back. “Please.” Hearing her beg, shattered whatever strength I had left. Every part of me wanted to pull her into my arms, tell her none of it mattered, tell her I would choose her over everything else.
But I couldn’t.
Duty had already tightened its grip around my life long before I ever fell in love with her. My obligations, my family, the promises made for me before I had the courage to make my own—those chains held tighter than my heart ever could. Loving Julia had been the most natural thing I had ever done. Leaving her was the cruelest.
She turned away from me then, covering her mouth as a broken sob escaped her chest. Her shoulders trembled beneath the fading evening light, and I stood frozen behind her, useless against the pain I had caused. I wanted to comfort her, but my own grief sat like shattered glass inside me. How do you soothe the person whose heart you are destroying when yours is breaking beside it?
The wind moved softly through the trees above us, carrying the scent of rain and summer grass, but the world we had built together was already slipping away. We loved each other completely, deeply, hopelessly—and still, somehow, love was not enough to save us from a future neither of us had chosen.
Julia turned to face me again, tears shining on her cheeks like silver beneath the pale glow of the park lights. Her lips trembled as she searched my face, as though she was looking for something solid to hold onto before everything slipped away completely.
“Do you love me?” she asked softly.
There was no pause. No uncertainty. No space for doubt.
“I do.”
The words left me with a certainty so fierce it almost hurt. I stepped closer to her, my hands trembling as they found her face, brushing away tears that refused to stop falling. “Julia,” I whispered, my forehead resting against hers, “My heart has never belonged to anyone else. It’s yours. Only yours. It will always be yours.”
Her eyes closed at my confession, as if she needed to feel the truth of it sink into the broken places inside her. For a moment, the world around us disappeared—the wind, the trees, the ache of what was waiting for us beyond that night. There was only the fragile space between our breaths.
Then she looked at me again, wounded and desperate all at once. “Promise me something.”
“Anything.”
Her fingers tightened around mine. “Promise me you’ll never love her.” Her voice cracked on the last word. “Promise me you never touch her.”
For a moment, I could not believe she was asking this of me, but I felt her pain, and I knew I had to assure her that part of me was only for her.
The pain in her eyes nearly undid me. I could see the fear buried beneath her plea—not jealousy, but the terror of being erased, of becoming nothing more than a memory in the life of the man she loved.
I held her closer, as though I could shield her from the future itself. “She will never have my love,” I said quietly, each word deliberate, solemn. “And she will never share my bed. That part of me belongs to you, Julia. Only you.”
A fragile breath escaped her lips, somewhere between relief and heartbreak. Then she rose onto her toes and kissed me.
It was not a hurried kiss, nor one born from passion alone. It felt like a vow exchanged in the ruins of a dream—tender, trembling, devastating. Her lips moved against mine as though she was trying to memorize me, and I kissed her back with the desperation of a man holding onto the last beautiful thing he would ever truly have.
When we finally parted, I rested my forehead against hers once more, needing her to hear it again, needing her to carry it with her long after that night ended.
"Sherry will never have my love and I will never share a bed with her," my declaration was final.
Planning the proposal had come easily. Too easily, maybe.
I had never needed to guess what made Sherry smile. I had known her my entire life—before scraped knees turned into long summer evenings, before we were old enough to understand what forever meant. Our childhood had unfolded side by side like pages from the same book.
And there was one place that belonged to both of us.
The lake.
Hidden behind winding trails and towering pines, the water stretched wide and still beneath the golden evening sky. At the edge of the shore stood the old oak tree, enormous and weathered, its branches curling over the bank like protective arms, and a small bench sat under it. We had spent years beneath it—stealing apples from neighboring orchards, daring each other into the freezing water, lying in the grass counting stars until our parents came searching with lanterns and angry voices.
We both loved that tree.
So that was where I would ask her to marry me.
I could already picture it: the soft breeze rolling off the lake, sunlight catching in her blonde hair, the way her eyes would widen in surprise before filling with tears. She would laugh first—she always laughed when she was overwhelmed—placed her hand over her mouth, and then throw her arms around his neck.
The image should have filled me with joy.
Instead, a strange heaviness settled in his chest.
Staring across the dark water, hands shoved deep into his pockets.
Marrying Sherry was the right thing to do.
The safe thing.
The honorable thing.
I cared for her deeply. God, I always would. But love and being in love were not the same thing, no matter how many times I tried convincing myself otherwise.
Still, I had made my choice.
Family comes first.
The words echoed through my mind like a prayer I was desperate to believe.
Family comes first above everything else.
I repeated it silently until it almost sounded true.
And then Julia called.
The sharp ring of my phone shattered the quiet.
“Julia?” I answered immediately.
All I heard at first was breathing. Uneven. Broken.
Then a soft sob.
My stomach tightened. “What’s wrong?”
“I need to see you, Dylan.”
Her voice cracked on my name, and something inside me cracked with it.
Twenty minutes later, I was pushing through the doors of a small café downtown, rain clinging to the shoulders of his jacket. The rich scent of espresso and cinnamon drifted through the warm air, but my attention locked onto Julia instantly.
She sat alone near the window.
Her dark hair spilled loosely over her shoulders, slightly damp from the weather. Her fingers twisted nervously around a coffee cup she clearly hadn’t touched. The moment she looked up at me, her eyes glistened.
And just like always, the rest of the world disappeared.
I slid into the seat across from her. “Hey,” I said softly. “Talk to me.”
Julia’s lip trembled.
“I miss you.”
The words landed harder than they should have.
I leaned back slightly, exhaling through my nose. Being around her had always felt dangerous in the most beautiful way. Familiar. Addictive. Every glance from her felt like being pulled beneath deep water.
The rain had stopped, and the sun was picking out when I glanced at the window.
Outside the café window, movement caught my eye.
I paid no attention to it. I took Julia's hand and we walked out. She stopped me right outside the café and hugged me, placing a soft kiss on my cheek. I returned the hug with an intensity that matched hers.
A cluster of women emerged from a boutique across the street, laughing as they carried garment bags.
Then he saw her.
Sherry.
She stood in the center of the group, radiant even from a distance, her soft blue dress swaying around her knees. But she wasn’t laughing anymore.
She was staring directly at me.
At us.
One of her bridesmaids leaned toward her whispering something, and another glanced toward the café with open curiosity.
My pulse stumbled.
I immediately looked away, pretending like I hadn’t seen her at all.
“Julia,” I said under my breath, tension tightening his voice, “Did you know Sherry would be here?”
Julia frowned faintly. “What are you talking about?”
“The bridal shop.” Gesturing toward the store. “She’s across the street.”
Julia turned slowly, spotting them.
“So?” she replied with a shrug.
I blinked at her. “So? Julia, I’m getting married in a few days.”
“And being seen with me is a problem now?”
The hurt in her voice sliced clean through me.
“No—that’s not what I meant.”
But it was. At least partly.
Running a hand through my hair before quickly standing directly in front of her. “Come on.”
I guided her back inside the café, away from the windows and curious eyes. Julia followed reluctantly, her expression hardening even as tears shimmered in her eyes.
Once we sat down again, I leaned forward. “Tell me what’s really going on.”
For a moment she said nothing.
Then her composure broke.
“I just…” Her voice wavered. “I just miss you so much, Dylan.”
The ache in her eyes unraveled me completely.
From that day on, Julia called constantly.
Morning. Midnight. In between. Even dropped by on the days I went to my company for training.
Every time her voice cracked over the phone, every time she whispered that she needed me, I went running.
And somehow—every single time—Sherry was nearby.
At first, it felt coincidental.
A restaurant where Sherry was having lunch with her cousins.
A bookstore she visited every Thursday evening.
The florist downtown.
The café she often visits with her friends.
Always just close enough for Sherry to see us together.
To wonder.
To hurt.
As the wedding crept closer, guilt settled heavier on my shoulders, but so did my dependence on Julia. I told myself I was protecting her. Keeping a promise. Being there the way I always had.
But deep down, I knew the truth.
I was unable to let her go.
The wedding cake tasting should have felt ordinary—two people planning a future together, choosing flavors and smiling over samples of frosting and sugar flowers. And in many ways, it was painfully simple. Sherry already knew what I liked before I even spoke. The moment the baker placed the place with the red velvet on it, I asked her to try it because I knew this was the one. I smiled softly and nodded toward her, and I realized we had both made a decision without hesitation.
The baker laughed warmly at our quick agreement, calling us “easy clients,” but the sound barely reached me. Around us, the little shop smelled of vanilla and fresh buttercream, sunlight spilling across glass displays filled with delicate white cakes decorated with other love stories. Sherry sat beside me discussing frosting details while I answered automatically, my attention drifting somewhere far beyond the walls of that shop. When she said cream cheese frosting, I gave her a small nod.
When we stepped back outside, the afternoon air hit cool against my skin. Cars rolled slowly along the street, people passing by without a second glance, the city carrying on as though lives were not quietly unraveling every day beneath its noise.
And then I saw her.
Across the street, half-hidden beside the window of a bookstore, stood Julia.
Even from that distance, I would have known her anywhere.
My chest tightened so suddenly it stole the breath from my lungs. She wasn’t looking at the traffic or the surrounding shops. She was looking at me.
No—looking at us.
For a moment the world seemed to narrow painfully into that single glance. Her dark hair moved gently in the breeze, her face unreadable except for the sadness lingering quietly in her eyes, the kind of sadness that no amount of pretending could hide.
Without thinking, I stepped farther away from Sherry.
It was subtle enough that no one else would notice, just a few careful inches placed between us as we walked. But to me, it felt enormous. Necessary. I couldn’t bear the thought of Julia seeing me too close to another woman, couldn’t endure the idea of her mistaking obligation for affection. Every movement became deliberate after that—the distance between my hand and Sherry’s, the way I kept my shoulders angled away, the restraint in every word I spoke.
Because even standing outside a wedding cake shop with another woman beside me, my heart still reached for Julia as naturally as breathing.
After that day, every spare moment I had belonged to Julia.
The hours I spent away from her felt empty, mechanical, something to simply survive until I could see her again. But the moment I was beside her, the world softened. The noise in my head quieted. I lived for the small things—the way her eyes lit up when she saw me waiting for her, the warmth of her hand slipping into mine, the sound of her laughter breaking through the heaviness that had settled over both of us.
I refused to let her feel like she was standing in the shadows of my life.
So I loved her openly in every way I still could.
I memorized the little details that made her smile. I brought her coffee exactly the way she liked it without asking. I kissed her forehead when she grew quiet with sadness. I held her a little longer whenever it was time to leave, as though I could somehow stop time itself by refusing to let go. On evenings when words became too painful, we would simply sit together beneath the fading light, my fingers tracing slow circles against her skin while silence said everything our hearts could not survive speaking aloud.
And whenever doubt crept into her eyes, I made sure to erase it.
Not with promises alone, but with the devotion she could feel.
No matter what the world called me—fiancé, husband, obligated son—none of those titles touched the truth living inside me. Julia was the first thought in my mind every morning and the last ache in my chest every night. Every decision, every stolen moment, every quiet act of tenderness revolved around her.
Because I needed her to understand something words alone could never fully hold:
She was never “the other woman.”
Not in my heart.
Not for a single second.
To me, Julia was everything real, everything sacred, everything love was ever meant to be. The rest was merely circumstance wrapped around a life I never truly chose.
The night before my wedding, I was not with family, friends, or surrounded by celebration.
I was with Julia.
Rain tapped softly against the windows of our hotel room while the world outside carried on toward a tomorrow neither of us wanted to face. The room was dim except for the warm glow of a single lamp beside the bed, casting shadows across tear-stained cheeks and exhausted eyes that had cried far too much already.
Julia sat curled against my chest, trembling every few minutes as another wave of grief overtook her. Her sobs were quiet at first, the kind people make when they are trying desperately to stay strong. But as the hours passed, they became broken, uncontrollable sounds that seemed to tear straight through both of us. Every time she cried harder, I held her tighter, my arms wrapped around her as though I could somehow shield her from the morning that was coming.
“I don’t want tomorrow to happen,” she whispered to me, her voice raw and fragile.
Neither did I.
But the truth sat between us like a death sentence neither of us could escape.
I pressed my lips into her hair and closed my eyes, breathing her in slowly, trying to memorize everything—the softness of her skin beneath my fingertips, the warmth of her body against mine, the way she fit perfectly in my arms as though she had always belonged there. I held her with the desperation of a man clinging to the last moments of a life he loved before it was taken away.
My phone would not stop vibrating.
Again.
Again.
Again.
My parents.
Calls. Messages. Questions about where I was, reminders about the ceremony, the guests, the responsibilities waiting for me at the church in just a few hours. Each vibration felt cruel, like the outside world forcing its way into the fragile sanctuary we had built for ourselves that night.
I ignored every single one.
Nothing beyond those walls mattered to me then.
Not the wedding. Not the expectations. Not the future already arranged before I had any say in it.
Only Julia.
Only the woman crying in my arms while I silently broke apart with her.
Time moved mercilessly fast. At some point, the sky outside began to pale with the first hints of morning, and panic settled heavily into my chest. Dawn meant goodbye was getting closer.
Still, I didn’t let her go.
I stayed with her until there was barely an hour left before I had to stand at the altar beside another woman. Even then, when I finally pulled back just enough to look at her, my hands lingered against her face, brushing away tears that would not stop falling.
Because leaving her that morning felt less like walking toward a wedding…
And more like abandoning the only home my heart had ever known.
I left Julia just as the sun began to rise, carrying the weight of her tears on my skin like something permanent. The drive home passed in a blur of empty roads and aching silence. My hands still remembered the feel of her clinging to me, and every red light felt like another moment stolen from the only place I had wanted to be.
By the time I stepped through the front door, the house was already alive with movement. Voices drifted through the halls, hurried footsteps crossing polished floors, phones ringing, doors opening and closing. The entire world seemed determined to push me toward the altar before I could stop and think too hard about what I was doing.
I went straight upstairs.
The shower water poured over me in relentless heat, but it couldn’t wash away the exhaustion beneath my eyes or the hollow ache sitting heavily in my chest. I stood there longer than necessary, forehead pressed against the cool tile, trying to gather enough strength to survive the day ahead.
When I finally dressed, adjusting the cuffs of a suit that suddenly felt more like armor than celebration, something tugged at the edge of my memory.
The necklace.
My grandfather had commissioned it years ago—something delicate and timeless, meant for Sherry someday. Before he died, he had entrusted it to my grandmother for safekeeping, believing it would one day symbolize love, loyalty, family tradition.
For a long moment, I simply stared at myself in the mirror.
Then I went to retrieve it.
The necklace felt unexpectedly heavy in my palm, cold against my skin, as though carrying the weight of every expectation placed upon me long before I had a choice in any of it.
As I headed toward the door, my father stepped into my path.
“Where were you all night?”
His voice was calm, but there was something sharp beneath it, something knowing.
I couldn’t answer him.
What could I possibly say? That I had spent my final night before marriage holding the woman I truly loved while both of us quietly fell apart?
So I said nothing at all.
I walked past him without lifting my eyes, silence hanging between us heavier than any argument ever could.
The drive to the church felt endless.
My father sat in the front beside my best friend Duane while I stared out the window, watching the city blur past in muted shades of gray. No one spoke much. The closer we got, the tighter my chest became, until breathing itself felt difficult.
And then we arrived.
The church stood tall against the pale morning sky, grand and beautiful and suffocating all at once. Guests were already gathering outside, laughter and conversation floating through the crisp air while bells echoed faintly in the distance.
The moment I stepped out of the car, my father’s hand landed firmly on my shoulder.
I stopped.
“Don’t mess this up, Dylan.”
His voice was low, steady, carrying years of expectation in just four words.
Then he gave my back a firm pat and walked away, disappearing up the stone steps without looking back, leaving me alone with the storm raging inside my head.
For a second, I couldn’t move.
I stood there staring at the church doors, feeling less like a groom and more like a man marching toward a life that belonged to someone else.
Inside, the scent of fresh flowers and candle wax filled the air. Guests smiled as I passed, but their faces blurred together until I spotted my grandmother near the front pews.
The moment she saw me, her expression softened.
I reached into my pocket and carefully placed the necklace into her hands. The diamonds caught the light as she opened the velvet box, and for an instant, emotion flickered across her face so strongly it nearly undid me.
Her fingers closed gently over mine.
“Your grandfather would be so proud of you,” she whispered.
The words settled heavily into my chest.
And all I could think was how proud he might have been…
if I were walking toward love instead of away from it.
Standing at the altar, dressed in a tailored black suit with polished shoes and a carefully arranged tie, I looked exactly like a man about to begin the happiest chapter of his life.
But inside, something had already died.
The church glowed with soft candlelight, white roses lining every pew while quiet music drifted through the air like a blessing. Guests smiled warmly from their seats, whispering to one another with excitement and admiration. Somewhere nearby, someone laughed softly. Another person dabbed at tears before the ceremony had even begun.
To everyone else, it was beautiful.
To me, it felt like mourning.
The weight in my chest was so crushing it almost bent me forward. Every breath came shallow, scraped raw against the tightness in my throat. My fingers curled stiffly at my sides while the priest spoke quietly beside me, his words fading into meaningless noise beneath the roar of my own thoughts.
All I could see was Julia.
I pictured her exactly as I had left her only hours earlier—eyes swollen from crying, curled against me as though holding on could stop the inevitable. I could still hear the tremble in her voice when she whispered she didn’t want this day to come. I could still feel the warmth of her tears soaking through my shirt while I held her helplessly in the dark.
And now here I stood beneath stained-glass windows, preparing to promise forever to another woman while the only person I truly loved was somewhere out there breaking apart without me.
The realization hollowed me out completely.
I felt numb and shattered at the same time, like a man standing at his own funeral watching dirt being thrown over the coffin one handful at a time.
Then the music began.
The first delicate notes echoed through the church, and my entire body locked.
A sharp drop hit my stomach so violently it made me dizzy. My heartbeat stumbled painfully against my ribs while my throat tightened until breathing itself became difficult. The room suddenly felt too warm, too crowded, the air unbearably thin.
This was it.
There was no more time left.
No more excuses. No more stolen nights with Julia hidden away from the world. No more pretending I still had a choice.
I gripped my hands together tightly to stop them from shaking.
For one reckless second, panic clawed at me hard enough to almost turn my feet toward the side doors instead of the aisle ahead. I imagined running. Leaving everything behind. Finding Julia before it was too late.
But duty held me in place stronger than love ever had permission to.
So I forced a breath into my lungs.
Forced my shoulders straight.
Forced myself to turn toward the entrance despite every instinct screaming not to.
And then—
The moment the doors opened.