Marissa didn't answer the first three times Sasha called the accounting office. On the fourth, she finally picked up, her voice tight and wary. "I told you to leave this alone."
"We're not here to force anything," Sasha said, glancing at Nathan for support. "We just want to ask what you want. Not tell you what we think should happen."
There was a long silence on the line. When Marissa spoke again, her voice had changed — still guarded, but something in it had cracked open a little. "Not on the phone," she said. "There's a diner off Route 9. Tomorrow, after five. Come alone. Both of you, but no one else."
The diner was half-empty when they arrived, fluorescent lights humming over a scattering of booths. Marissa was already there, hands wrapped around a coffee cup she wasn't drinking.
"I need you to understand something," she said, before either of them could speak. "It wasn't just him. When it happened — when I finally worked up the courage to tell someone — I went to the assistant principal. Ms. Draper. She told me it would 'complicate things' so close to graduation. She told me to think carefully about what accusing a well-liked teacher would do to my own reputation." Marissa's hands tightened around the cup. "She made it sound like I'd be the one with something to lose."
Nathan felt something cold settle in his stomach. "Draper's still the assistant principal."
"She's been groomed for the principal position for years," Marissa said. "Voss is retiring next year. She's the front-runner to replace him."
Sasha and Nathan exchanged a look. This wasn't just one teacher hoping an old note stayed buried. It was an institution that had made a decision, ten years ago, about whose future mattered more — and that decision had a second person actively protecting it.
"Did you ever try telling anyone else?" Sasha asked gently. "A parent, a friend, another teacher?"
Marissa's laugh was short and humorless. "I tried, once, with a friend. She didn't believe me — said Callahan was too nice, too well-liked, that I must be misunderstanding something. After that I stopped trying. It's easier to just carry something alone than to keep being told you're wrong about your own life."
Nathan felt something tighten in his chest, an anger he hadn't quite expected to feel this intensely toward people he'd never met. "That's not fair to you."
"No," Marissa agreed simply. "It wasn't. Isn't." She wrapped both hands around her coffee cup again, staring down at it like it might offer some kind of answer neither Nathan nor Sasha could give her. "I've spent ten years telling myself it doesn't matter anymore. That I'm fine. Mostly I believe it. Then two teenagers show up outside my work with an old note, and suddenly it feels like no time has passed at all."
"We're sorry," Sasha said quietly. "For dragging it back up."
"Don't be." Marissa looked up, something steadier in her expression now than there had been at the start of the conversation. "I've spent ten years wishing someone would ask the right questions. I just never expected it to be two kids barely older than I was when it started."
Nathan glanced at Sasha, watching her carefully absorb everything Marissa was telling them, none of her usual restlessness present for once — just quiet, focused attention. He understood, watching her, that this conversation was changing something in both of them, hardening a resolve that had started as simple curiosity into something closer to genuine purpose.
"What do you want to happen now?" Sasha asked gently. "Not what we think should happen. What you actually want."
Marissa considered the question for a long moment, turning her coffee cup slowly between her hands. "I don't know yet," she admitted. "Part of me wants him gone. Part of me is terrified of what happens if this comes out and he manages to spin it, makes me look unstable or vindictive instead of telling the truth. I've watched that happen to other people."
"We won't push you into anything," Nathan said. "We just wanted you to know what we found, and that we're not going to just walk away from it."
"I believe you," Marissa said, and for the first time since they'd approached her outside her office weeks ago, she almost sounded like she meant it completely.