Empty Boxes
1269 Words
Clara stood outside Noah's door under the starry sky.
Debating with herself.
Because this wasn't her.
Was it?
Not once, not ever, had she been in a situation like this. No time had she ever had two men competing for her, let alone,
this.
She had always considered herself lucky to get a halfway decent one-night stand.
This?
This was something else entirely.
The small cabin sat dark and still in front of her, one narrow window spilling a pale rectangle of lamplight across the dirt. The moon hung high and unhelpful, bright enough to see by, bright enough to be seen.
Behind her, a cricket cut steadily through the quiet.
She shifted her weight.
Didn't move.
Elijah had fallen asleep only minutes before. She could still hear the slow pull of his breathing through the wall, still feel the weight of his arm where it had rested across her waist.
The kiss he pressed to her temple had been unhurried.
Certain.
The kind of kiss that expected her to still be there in the morning.
Her fingers lifted to her lips.
This felt wrong.
Not just a little wrong.
Deeply, undeniably wrong.
She wasn't,
Not,
She wasn't the kind of person who stood outside a man's door in the middle of the night.
But she had crossed time.
Left everything behind.
And she needed answers.
She knocked.
The door opened before the sound had fully faded.
Noah filled the frame, one hand braced against the post, lamplight catching the edge of his face.
He hadn't been asleep.
Not even close.
His gaze moved over her once, taking in the nightgown, the bare feet, the hesitation.
Then settled on her face.
Waiting.
Not asking.
"I shouldn't be here," Clara said.
Noah's mouth shifted, not quite a smile.
He stepped back.
"No," he agreed quietly.
Then, after a beat,
"But you are."
That didn't help.
Clara stepped inside anyway.
The room was smaller than Elijah's.
Simpler.
Less settled.
Like it belonged to someone who hadn't decided where he was meant to stay.
Or someone who never planned to.
Noah closed the door behind her.
The latch clicked softly.
Final.
He stayed there a moment, back against the wood.
Bare from the waist up, suspenders hanging loose, lamplight moving across him as he breathed slow and steady.
Waiting.
Clara turned to face him.
"This is insane," she whispered. "I just left my husband's bed."
Something shifted across Noah's face.
Not offense.
Not jealousy.
Something softer.
Certain.
His hand lifted, brushing her cheek, tilting her face up like he'd done it before.
Like he knew she'd follow.
"No," he said quietly. "You came back to your husband's bed."
Her breath left her.
"This isn't about him."
His thumb traced her hand, slow and familiar.
"It's always been about us."
That hit.
Harder than it should have.
Because for one dangerous second,
she wanted it to be true.
Noah pulled her closer, his hand firm at her waist, heat bleeding through the thin cotton of her nightgown.
His mouth brushed beneath her ear.
Slow.
Deliberate.
"I need you in my bed."
Every thought scattered.
Elijah's steady breathing a cabin away.
The kiss at her temple.
The quiet certainty.
She knew exactly whose bed she had left.
And still,
Clara nodded.
The walk across the room felt too loud.
Too real.
Each step small.
Irreversible.
Her heart hammered as they reached the bed.
And something in her snapped.
Noah didn't give her time to think.
His hand caught hers, pulling her in, his mouth finding hers without hesitation, with a certainty that made her gasp into him.
His touch was rough, grounded, nothing like the careful control she had left behind.
Clara's hands found his shoulders, her body pressing into his before she could catch up.
Too fast.
Too easy.
Too,
She didn't finish the thought.
Didn't want to.
Because he knew her.
That was the problem.
The way his hands moved.
The way he didn't search.
Didn't hesitate.
Didn't guess.
He knew exactly where she would react.
Exactly how.
He shouldn't.
He lifted her, and her legs wrapped around him before she could stop them.
Her body choosing.
Her mind scrambling to keep up.
The mattress gave beneath her.
His weight followed, not all at once, but enough to hold her there.
Real.
Solid.
Dangerous.
His hands moved slowly, gathering the fabric of her nightgown, letting cool air slip beneath it.
Not taking.
Not rushing.
Like he was returning something.
To where it had always belonged.
Something caught in her chest.
Not guilt.
Not want.
Something worse.
Because it felt familiar.
"Noah, "
The word barely formed.
His mouth found her throat.
Her collarbone.
The place beneath her ear.
Each touch pulling something from her she hadn't meant to give.
Her fingers twisted into the sheets like she needed something solid.
Something real.
Something she could hold onto.
Then,
He stopped.
Not pulling away.
Just...
still.
His hand found her wrist.
Slow.
Deliberate.
He lifted it between them.
Into the candlelight.
Her wedding ring caught the glow.
Gold against the dark.
Simple.
A line she hadn't crossed yet.
"Take it off."
Clara froze.
Her breath uneven.
Her pulse loud.
Her body still angled toward him,
even now.
"I can't," she whispered.
And there was nothing behind it.
No conviction.
No resistance.
Because she hadn't left.
Because she hadn't pushed him away.
Because the door was ten feet away,
and she hadn't moved.
Still here.
Still choosing this.
Noah's thumb brushed over the band.
Back and forth.
Not forcing.
Not pulling.
Just reminding her it was there.
"You already chose," he said quietly.
The words settled deep.
Clara's breath caught.
Her fingers trembled.
The gold was warm now.
From her skin.
From his touch.
From the moment.
And that felt like the worst part.
That it no longer felt foreign.
That it felt like it belonged here.
"This is wrong," she whispered.
But her fingers moved anyway.
The ring caught slightly at her knuckle,
then slid free.
Into her palm.
Small.
Weightless.
Devastating.
Clara's breath left her all at once.
The world tilted.
Not metaphor.
Not feeling.
Reality.
Clara stumbled back,
her breath sharp, her pulse racing,
and then,
She wasn't there.
She was standing.
Fully clothed.
In her steel-gray pantsuit was smooth and unaffected.
Her apartment.
Cold marble floor.
Perfectly placed furniture.
Everything exactly where it should be.
Exactly where it had been.
Her eyes dropped to her hand.
The ring was still there.
Not on her finger.
In her palm.
Exactly where it had been when she took it off.
The memory hit all at once.
The delivery.
The unknown sender.
The small box.
The ring inside.
She remembered putting it on.
Laughing at herself.
And then,
waking up in Elijah's bed.
Clara gasped.
"No... no, that wasn't, "
Her voice broke.
"I imagined it. I had to have, "
But the box was still there.
Untouched.
Waiting.
Slowly,
carefully,
She reached for it.
Opened it.
Empty.
Just like before.
Clara let out a shaky breath.
"See?" she whispered. "It was just, "
She stopped.
Because now,
There was something inside.
A folded piece of paper.
Clara stared at it.
Hands trembling.
"No..."
She picked it up.
Unfolded it.
And her stomach dropped.
A newspaper clipping.
Worn.
Faded.
Mail Order Bride Wanted
Honest man. Cattle rancher. Starting out. No riches to offer, but a steady hand and a good heart...
Clara's knees nearly gave out.
Because he had told her.
She hadn't believed him.
Not fully.
Her fingers tightened on the paper.
"Elijah..." she whispered.
Her voice shook.
"What did I do?"
- Writer
- chap_listContents
- likeADD