University life marched on, but Maya felt like she was always walking against the current.
She tried. God, she really tried.
She forced herself to go on study dates, let a sweet guy from her economics class walk her home, even kissed him once outside the library. His lips were warm, gentle. But the whole time she was waiting for something—the rush, the fire, the feeling of losing control.
It never came.
Because every time she closed her eyes, it was Mike’s mouth she remembered. Mike’s hands, Mike’s voice teasing in her ear, Mike’s touch that set her whole body alight.
And she hated herself for it.
---
The months slipped by. Exams came and went, the seasons shifted, and before she knew it, it was spring again. Liam’s birthday invitation arrived through Anya.
“You have to come,” Anya insisted over the phone. “It’s Liam’s twenty-first. Everyone will be there. Don’t you dare flake.”
Maya hesitated, chewing her lip. “Everyone?”
“Yes. Everyone,” Anya said knowingly. “Including him.”
Maya’s heart clenched, but she forced her voice steady. “Fine. I’ll come. For Liam.”
---
The party was held at a pub in town, louder and wilder than Anya’s birthday had been. Maya arrived in a fitted wine-red dress, her hair loose around her shoulders. She told herself she wasn’t dressing for anyone. She told herself lies.
Inside, laughter roared, music pounded, and the smell of beer and smoke clung to the air. She spotted Liam first—grinning, already half-drunk, hugging everyone in sight.
“Maya!” he shouted, pulling her into a bear hug. “You made it!”
She smiled, hugging him back. “Of course I did. Happy birthday, idiot.”
As they pulled apart, her eyes flickered across the room.
And there he was.
Mike.
He leaned against the pool table, a drink in hand, his eyes already locked on hers. That same infuriating smirk curved his lips, but his gaze was darker this time. Hungrier.
Maya turned back to Liam quickly, forcing herself to laugh at something he said. But her skin tingled, her chest tight, because she could feel Mike watching her.
Later in the night, she slipped away to the quieter corner near the back, needing space from the noise. That’s when he found her.
“Running again?” His voice came low and teasing, but softer than before.
She stiffened. “Don’t start.”
He stepped closer, his presence overwhelming. “I didn’t think you’d come tonight.”
“It’s Liam’s birthday. Not everything is about you, Mike.”
“Could’ve fooled me.” His eyes glimmered with mischief, but his voice carried something heavier underneath. “You still look at me the same way, Maya.”
Her jaw tightened. “You think too much of yourself.”
“Do I?” He leaned closer, close enough that she felt the brush of his breath. “Because you haven’t forgotten me. Just like I haven’t forgotten you.”
Her chest ached. Anger and longing tangled inside her, too heavy to hold back anymore. “You don’t get it, do you?”
His smirk faltered. “Then tell me.”
She swallowed hard, her voice trembling as the words spilled out. “That night… that first night we were together—it wasn’t just some fling for me, Mike. It was everything. I was—” she stopped, breath catching, but forced herself to go on, “—I was a virgin. And I gave myself to you because I thought it meant something. Because it did mean something to me.”
Mike’s eyes widened, shock flashing across his face. “Maya…”
She shook her head, her voice breaking. “But then you went back to her. Like it was nothing. Like I was nothing. You broke me, Mike. You don’t even know how much.”
His hand twitched at his side, like he wanted to reach for her but didn’t dare. His voice was raw when he finally spoke. “I didn’t know. Maya, I swear to God, I didn’t know. If I had—” He stopped, dragging a hand through his hair. “f**k. I was so stupid. I thought I was protecting myself, but all I did was destroy you.”
She blinked hard, tears threatening. “And now you think I can just forgive you? Trust you again? How am I supposed to do that, Mike?”
He stepped closer, his voice low and desperate. “Then let me prove it. Give me a chance to prove I’m not that guy anymore.”
Her chest heaved, her heart racing at the raw sincerity in his tone. For a terrifying moment, she wanted to believe him.
But the memory of the heartbreak was still too sharp.
She pulled back, shaking her head. “I don’t know if I can.”
Their eyes locked—hers filled with pain, his with regret and longing. The noise of the party roared around them, but in that corner, it was just the two of them, standing on the edge of something that could either heal them… or break them for good.