His hand at her waist was steadier than she expected, and closer than the arrangement strictly required, and Elena told herself the warmth spreading up through her spine was nothing but proximity and champagne, a physiological accident with no bearing on anything real.
"You handled Marcus well," Nicholas said, guiding her through the first slow turn. "Most people freeze the first time he does that. The arithmetic thing. He does it to everyone eventually — finds the one uncomfortable number and says it out loud in a crowded room, just to watch what happens to your face."
"What was supposed to happen to my face?"
"Guilt, usually. Panic. Something he could report back to the board as evidence." A faint, humorless almost-smile. "You gave him warmth instead. It was the correct move. It was also, I suspect, not entirely a performance."
"Maybe I'm just better at lying than you think."
"Maybe," he said, not sounding as though he believed it, and turned her again, and for a moment neither of them said anything at all, the quartet's slow waltz filling the space where the conversation had been.
"You're thinking very loudly," Nicholas said eventually. "I can hear it from here."
"I'm thinking that your grandfather likes me, and I don't know what to do with that. Liking me wasn't in the contract."
"No," he agreed. "It wasn't." A pause, his hand tightening fractionally at her waist, an adjustment so small she might have missed it if every part of her weren't currently, humiliatingly, tuned to him. "Neither was this, if we're cataloguing exceptions."
"What's 'this'?"
"I don't know yet," he said, and for once he didn't sound like a man withholding an answer he already had. He sounded, briefly, like a man who genuinely didn't know — the same unfinished quality she'd heard in his voice on the phone two nights before, the rawness he usually smoothed over before anyone could catch it. "I've spent a great deal of energy over the years making sure I never had to find out what things like this were. It's inconvenient, discovering the system has a gap in it."
She should have laughed it off. She almost did. Instead she found herself looking up at him, close enough to see the faint, unguarded line between his eyebrows, the first c***k she'd seen yet in the careful architecture of his face, and something in her chest turned over, slow and unwilling, like a key in a lock she'd sworn she wouldn't use.
"Nicholas—"
"Don't," he said, low, not unkind. "Whatever you're about to say. Not here. Not with three hundred people deciding, right now, whether they believe us." His eyes held hers, and there was something almost like an apology in them, or a warning, or both at once. "Later, if you still want to say it. Not here."
The song ended before she could decide whether she still wanted to. He stepped back, the distance between them snapping into place like a mechanism resetting, and by the time his hand left her waist he had already rearranged his face into the version the room was allowed to see, and Elena understood, with a small cold drop in her stomach, that she had just watched him do to himself exactly what she'd been trying not to do to herself all night.
They didn't get a later that evening. A photographer from a society page cornered them near the coat check, and then Vanessa reappeared with two more women in tow, angling for introductions and information in equal measure, and by the time the car finally pulled away from the curb at eleven-forty, Nicholas had receded so completely back into the composed, unreachable man from the office on Lexington that Elena almost convinced herself she'd invented the whole thing — the unguarded line between his eyebrows, the don't, not here — until his phone buzzed on the seat between them and he glanced at it and went very still.
"What is it?"
He turned the screen toward her without a word. A gossip account, already twelve thousand likes deep, a photograph of the two of them mid-dance, her face turned up to his, an expression on it that Elena did not entirely recognize as her own — something too open, too easy to read.
The caption said: Nicholas Cade's mystery bride looks a lot less like a business deal and a lot more like a woman in love. Wonder if he's noticed.
"He's noticed," Nicholas said quietly, almost to himself, and did not look at her again for the rest of the drive.
Elena stared out the window at the city sliding past, cold glass under her fingertips, and thought about Priya's voice on the phone three weeks ago — just don't assume that being able to see the trap means you can't still fall into it — and understood, with the particular clarity that comes only after it's already too late to use it, that she had not been careful enough, not tonight, possibly not from the very first moment she'd walked into that office on Lexington and decided the money was worth whatever came after it.
The car slowed outside her building. Nicholas didn't move to walk her up.
"Elena." Her name, not Ms. Marsh, for the first time since she'd signed his contract, and something in the way he said it made her chest tighten before he'd finished the sentence. "Whatever that photograph looks like — we are still exactly what the document says we are. I need you to remember that. For both our sakes."
"Are we?" she asked, and hated how much she wanted him to say no.
He didn't answer. He didn't need to. The silence lasted exactly as long as it took the driver to come around and open her door, and by the time she was standing on the sidewalk looking back into the car, Nicholas Cade had already put his face back on, composed and unreachable and entirely unconvincing, for the first time all night, to the one person in the world he'd actually been trying to fool.
Upstairs, Elena didn't turn on the lights. She sat on the edge of her bed still in the green silk dress, her phone face-down beside her because she didn't trust herself not to look at the photograph again, not to study her own face in it for evidence of something she wasn't ready to name.
Four weeks ago she'd had four hundred and twelve dollars and a mother in a hospital bed and a stranger's contract with her name already typed into the blank at the top. She had told herself, signing it, that the only thing at risk was time — a year of her life, rented out like anything else, returned to her intact at the end with a number attached to make the absence worth it. She had not accounted for a grandfather who looked at her like she mattered. She had not accounted for a board member doing arithmetic in public, hunting for the seam where the lie showed. And she had not accounted, not for one second in that windowless office on Lexington, for the particular unbearable weight of a man saying her first name like it cost him something to say it.
Her phone buzzed once against the comforter. She turned it over before she could talk herself out of it.
Are you all right? — Nicholas.
She looked at it a long time before she answered, turning the words over, hunting for the calculation underneath them the way she'd learned to in three short weeks, and finding, for once, that she couldn't locate one.
I don't know yet, she typed back, which was the only honest thing she'd said to anyone all night, and set the phone down, and did not expect an answer, and got one anyway, four minutes later, four words long, the closest thing to a confession Nicholas Cade had offered her since she'd signed his name away next to hers.
Neither do I.
She read it twice, then a third time, then set the phone face-down again on the comforter as though distance might undo it. Outside her window the city went on the way it always did, indifferent to the particular kind of trouble she'd just gotten herself into — four words from a man who did not say things he didn't mean, in a contract that had never once accounted for the possibility of either of them meaning anything at all.
Six weeks, she reminded herself. A year, technically, but six weeks until the wedding made it real on paper, and three hundred and fifty-nine days after that until it was over and she walked away with the second half of a number large enough to fix everything it had been meant to fix. She had signed on for a transaction. She had not signed on to lie awake at midnight rereading four words like they were a language she was only just learning to read.
She fell asleep, eventually, with the phone still face-down beside her, and did not dream about the money at all.