My Fiancé Claimed I Loved His Brother, I Called Him "Husband"Updated at Sep 8, 2026, 02:16
After the car accident, I pretended to have amnesia just to mess with my boyfriend, Gareth Merrick.
I told him I'd fallen for him at first sight.
Instead of seeing the delighted reaction I'd expected, I heard him say, "You already have a boyfriend. His name is Brennan Whitaker. You've had a crush on him since you were little. You confessed to him last week and he said yes. Now you two are a couple. I'm actually the person you hate most."
I froze. Forcing down the pain, I didn't call him right away.
I simply watched him leave.
Outside the door, my best friend, Rhea Dempsey, asked in shock, "Are you sure this is a good idea? Everyone knows Brennan can't stand Nadine. If she actually believes you and goes looking for him, she's finished. That's the Whitaker heir we're talking about."
Gareth replied, "She's so damn annoying. Besides, I only accepted her confession last week because you told me to. You're the one I like."
When I heard that, I called Brennan with a blank expression. "Hubby, come pick me up. I'm sick."
No one knew that Brennan had given me three love letters over the years, and I'd rejected him mercilessly every time.