I thought my first love was finally in the past.... ...until Kai Sorensen transferred to my college and joined the hockey team captained by my boyfriend, Caleb. Kai was the boy who knew me better than anyone, then disappeared without a word. Now he’s back, standing beside Caleb on the ice, and every glance between us threatens everything I’ve built with my boyfriend. As Caleb’s perfect image begins to crack and the truth behind Kai’s disappearance slowly comes to light, I’m caught between the boy I chose and the boy I never truly got over. And this time, someone is bound to get hurt.