A third 1
POV: Lena
I stared at the ceiling, the fan spinning lazy circles above our bed. Ethan’s breathing was already deep and even beside me, his arm slung heavy across my waist like it had a thousand nights before. It should have felt comforting. Safe. Instead, it felt… familiar. Too familiar.
I slipped out from under his arm, careful not to wake him, and padded to the bathroom. The mirror showed the same woman I’d been looking at for twelve years of marriage. Thirty-four, still pretty enough, with soft curves Ethan used to worship. But lately? Our nights had turned into quick kisses, polite goodnights, and the occasional Saturday morning quickie that left me staring at the wall afterward, wondering where the fire had gone.
I loved him. God, I did. Ethan was steady, kind, the kind of man who remembered my coffee order and fixed the leaky faucet without being asked. But love wasn’t the problem. The spark was.
Our last date night flashed through my mind—dinner at that Italian place we always went to, talking about work and the kids’ school schedules, splitting a tiramisu like we’d done a hundred times. I’d worn the red dress he used to love peeling off me. He’d smiled, told me I looked nice. Nice. The word still stung.
I crawled back into bed and curled against his back, breathing in the familiar scent of his skin. My hand slid down his chest, lower, teasing. He stirred, made a sleepy sound, but didn’t turn over. “Tomorrow, baby,” he mumbled. “Long day.”
I swallowed the disappointment and closed my eyes.
The next evening, girls’ night at Sarah’s house was exactly what I needed. Wine flowed, laughter bounced off the walls, and for a couple of hours I wasn’t the wife wondering what happened to her s*x life. We were just four women who’d known each other since college, talking s**t and eating too much cheese.
“Mike tried this new thing last weekend,” Rachel said, wiggling her eyebrows. “Brought home some toys and a blindfold. I’m telling you, it woke us the hell up.”
Sarah snorted into her glass. “Please. Jake and I talked about bringing in a third. Not seriously, but damn, the fantasy was hot. You ever think about it, Lena?”
I nearly choked on my wine. The room erupted in giggles as they all turned to me.
“Come on,” Mia teased, nudging my knee. “You and Ethan have been married forever. You gotta spice it up before you turn into one of those couples who only do it on anniversaries.”
I laughed along with them, but the words stuck. Bringing in a third. The idea should have shocked me. Instead, heat bloomed low in my belly. I pictured strong hands that weren’t Ethan’s on my skin. A new mouth. Someone watching us, wanting us. My thighs pressed together under the table.
By the time I got home, the house was quiet. Ethan was on the couch, scrolling through his phone. He looked up and smiled that same warm smile that still made my heart flip.
“Hey, beautiful. How was it?”
“Good,” I said, kicking off my heels. “Really good.”
I sat beside him, closer than usual. My hand rested on his thigh. He set the phone down and pulled me in for a kiss—slow, sweet, the kind that used to lead somewhere. Tonight it stayed sweet.
I pulled back a little, heart pounding. The words from girls’ night wouldn’t leave me alone. They’d been simmering in my head the whole drive home.
“Ethan?”
“Hmm?”
I traced a finger along his jaw, gathering courage. “Have you ever… thought about inviting someone else into our bedroom?”
The words hung between us. His eyes widened, surprise flashing across his face. For a second, neither of us moved.
He swallowed. “What?”
My cheeks burned, but I didn’t look away. “I’m serious. I love you. I love what we have. But I miss… us. The way we used to burn for each other. I was thinking maybe…”
I let the sentence trail off, watching his reaction. Part of me expected him to laugh it off or get upset. The other part—the part that had been aching for weeks—hoped he’d feel the same spark of possibility I did.
Ethan stared at me, his hand tightening on my hip. Something dark and curious flickered in his eyes.
“Lena… you’re really asking that?”
I nodded, biting my lip. The air between us felt charged for the first time in months.
His thumb brushed my lower lip, voice low. “Tell me more about what you’re thinking…”