Snowfall

chapter thirteen

Ethan woke before dawn on Christmas Eve, the house silent except for the soft hum of the furnace. Moonlight filtered through the blinds, casting silver bars across the bedroom floor. He lay still, staring at the ceiling, heart already racing.

Today was the day.

He had barely slept. Every time he drifted off, the old memories surfaced: the snowy road in 1863, boots crunching, the ring in his pocket, distant gunfire. Waking with Emily’s name on his lips—Amelia then, Emily now.

By six a.m. he was up, hobbling on his nearly healed ankle to the kitchen. He started coffee, then stood at the window watching her house. No lights yet. The street lay under a fresh inch of snow that had fallen overnight—perfect, untouched, glittering in the first pale light.

He spent the morning preparing.

First, the tree. He added the final touches: a string of cranberry popcorn he’d made the night before, small wooden ornaments he’d carved over the years—tiny horses, birds, a porch swing. At the top he placed a simple star cut from silver cardstock.

Then the evidence. He laid it carefully on the coffee table: notebooks open to key pages, printouts of records, sketches. The reconstructed journal entries—dozens of them, written in his hand over the years as memories returned. Side-by-side photos: Amelia’s tintype from the locket (he’d asked to photograph it days ago) next to Emily’s face today. The similarities were undeniable.

He rehearsed one last time, pacing slowly.

“I know this will sound impossible. But please, hear me out. I’ve lived with this for seventeen years. I’ve searched for you across half a lifetime.”

He baked—badly. Store-bought cookie dough, slightly burned on the edges, arranged on a plate anyway. Cocoa mix ready on the counter. The house smelled of chocolate and pine and nervous hope.

At nine a.m. Emily’s porch light flicked on. She emerged in coat and boots, clearing a light dusting of new snow from her steps. She glanced at his house, waved when she saw him in the window. He waved back, stomach flipping.

Text from her at 9:17: Merry Christmas Eve! Still on for tonight? I’ve got something for you too.

He replied: Absolutely. Come over whenever you’re ready. I’ll have cocoa waiting.

All day he waited, jumping at every sound. He wrapped the one gift he’d prepared: a small wooden box he’d carved, inside it a new sketch—her face as Amelia by the river, and as Emily now, side by side. On the lid, engraved simply: Forever.

Snow continued to fall, soft and steady, turning the world quiet.

At four p.m. the sun began to set, sky turning rose and gold. Emily’s house glowed warmly; he saw her moving behind curtains, wrapping presents or finishing baking.

At six, darkness settled. Streetlights came on, holiday lights twinkling brighter against the snow. His tree lights cast colored patterns on the walls.

At seven, he lit candles—small ones on the mantel, the table. The room felt sacred.

At 7:42, a knock.

Ethan’s heart thundered. He smoothed his shirt, took a breath that did nothing to calm him, and opened the door.

Emily stood on the porch, snowflakes catching in her auburn hair, cheeks pink from cold. She wore a red coat and scarf, carrying a foil-covered tray and a small wrapped gift. Her eyes were bright, a little nervous.

“Merry Christmas Eve,” she said softly.

“Merry Christmas Eve,” he answered, voice rough.

She stepped inside, stamping snow from her boots. The warmth enveloped her; she unwrapped her scarf, revealing the silver locket gleaming at her throat.

“It smells amazing in here,” she said, handing him the tray. “Gingerbread, of course. And a few other things.”

He took it, set it on the counter. “Cocoa’s ready. Come sit by the tree.”

They moved to the living room. She paused, taking in the decorations, the candles, the careful arrangement on the coffee table.

“Ethan,” she said quietly, “this looks… important.”

“It is,” he said. “Please. Sit.”

She sat on the couch. He poured cocoa into two mugs—hers with extra marshmallows, the way she liked—handed her one, then sat beside her. Not too close. Not yet.

Snow tapped gently against the windows.

He took her free hand. She let him.

“Emily,” he began, “seventeen years ago, on Christmas Eve, I remembered something impossible. I remembered dying. In 1863. On a snowy road, trying to get home to the woman I loved.”

Her eyes widened, but she didn’t pull away.

“I was Elijah Harper,” he continued, voice steady now. “You were Amelia Rose Whitaker. We promised each other by the river that if we couldn’t be together in that life… we’d find each other in the next.”

He watched her face—shock, confusion, the beginnings of recognition.

“I’ve spent half my life looking for you,” he said. “And the first person I asked for help when I moved here… was you.”

Emily’s breath caught. She set her mug down with trembling hands.

“The dreams,” she whispered. “The soldier in the snow. The promise. I thought… I thought they were just dreams.”

“They’re memories,” he said gently. “Both of ours.”

He opened the notebook beside him, turned to the first page—the entry from Christmas Eve 2015.

She read it, tears welling.

Then the sketches. The records. The side-by-side faces.

Everything.

When she looked up, tears tracked down her cheeks, but her eyes were clear.

“Elijah,” she said, voice breaking on the name.

And in that moment, the years fell away.