Chapter 1&2. Never Really Faithful
Fall had settled over Boston, bringing a sharp chill and a low gray sky that hovered above rows of old brick buildings. Maple leaves scattered across the sidewalks, painting the streets in quiet shades of orange.
Evelyn was on her way to the hotel ballroom when a message popped up on her phone. For a second, her world caved in. She veered into the women’s restroom, gripping her phone like it might slip out of her hands.
Inside the stall, her eyes locked on a photo. The man in it was Lucas Callahan, her husband. But he wasn’t the part that made her breath hitch. It was the woman beside him. Her face was blurred, but the small rose tattoo on her shoulder was crystal clear. Too clear.
The sound of a faucet turning on broke the silence, followed by two coworkers chatting without realizing Evelyn was still inside.
“Isn’t it kinda weird? Evelyn’s always busy and they’ve been married over three years, but still no kids. No wonder Mr. Lucas found someone else.”
“I heard she can’t get pregnant.”
Laughter followed, then faded, leaving something far more painful behind.
Evelyn pushed the door open and stared at herself in the mirror. She looked the same as always. Her hair pinned in a neat bun, a beautiful dress, sunglasses perched on her nose. Calm, mature, polished. Exactly how Lucas liked her to be.
The image from the photo flashed in her mind. She tried to deny it, convincing herself it had to be fake. But that tattoo…
Lucas had always been good to her. Even after learning she couldn’t have children, he never blamed her or complained. He only grew more attentive. For the past three years, Evelyn had handled everything. Their home, her job, even helping save the Callahan family business. She thought they were a team. She thought they loved each other.
“Evelyn!”
A voice pulled her back to the present. She turned sharply and saw Chloe Hartman by the door, looking worried.
“Are you okay? You look really pale,” Chloe said as she stepped closer.
Evelyn splashed cold water on her face and tried to steady her breathing. When she glanced up again, she finally registered what Chloe was wearing.
A long white dress, too sexy for a work event. Her blonde hair was styled in an elegant updo, her makeup more dramatic than usual.
“Why are you dressed like that?” Evelyn asked, drying her hands.
Chloe smiled warmly and slipped an arm around her shoulders like nothing was wrong. “What? Tonight’s the celebration with the Reed family. Our project was a massive win and you were the star of it. You can’t just show up looking plain.”
Of course Evelyn didn’t want to look plain. For three months, she and Chloe had worked side by side negotiating a major deal with Sebastian Reed and his family. It was finally done, and tonight was the celebration. But Lucas never liked her dressing up too much. He always said he wanted her to look simple.
Not that any of that mattered now.
Evelyn was about to reply politely when her eyes caught the back of Chloe’s dress. Her shoulders were bare. And there it was. The same rose tattoo in red and black ink.
She froze. Her gaze locked on the tattoo as if the whole room had gone silent.
“Evelyn? What’s wrong?” Chloe turned slightly, still sounding casual and almost innocent. The tattoo became even more visible.
And just like that, Evelyn’s final thread of denial snapped. Maybe the photo was fake. Maybe it was someone who just looked similar.
But no. The woman in the photo was standing right in front of her.
Chloe Hartman. Her friend. The girl she had personally recommended to the company. The coworker she trusted more than anyone.
Lucas used to joke that Chloe was too sweet to be just a colleague, but Evelyn never imagined that out of everyone, Chloe would be the one to stab her in the back.
“Evelyn?” Chloe waved a hand in front of her face, eyes wide with concern. “Are you sure you’re okay? If you’re not feeling well, I can call Lucas. I can handle the work stuff, don’t worry.”
Evelyn curled her fingers into a fist, holding back the storm rising inside her. She forced a thin smile.
“I’m fine. You go ahead.”
Starting a scene now would only make her look weak.
“Alright,” Chloe said, checking her phone. “Lucas and I promised to meet Mr. Reed’s team before the party starts. They need to review the rundown. I’m heading out first, okay?”
Evelyn gave a small nod. “Yeah, go. I’ll fix my makeup.”
Chloe chuckled lightly. “Okay. Don’t take too long.”
Evelyn smiled back. “See you there.”
Once Chloe left, Evelyn went to the room prepared for her, but her mind stayed stuck in the restroom, on that tattoo, and on Lucas’s eyes that maybe hadn’t truly seen her in a long time.
Callahan Property Group had been on the brink of collapse a few years ago. Then Lucas married Evelyn, and the company rose from the ashes.
In just three years, the once sinking ship had become a major player in Boston real estate. This month marked their peak, thanks to the partnership with the Reeds that she had spent months securing. The future looked brighter than ever.
* *
Thirty minutes later.
Evelyn entered the ballroom wearing the same black dress as before, but with fresh makeup and her hair loosened around her shoulders. She looked sexier now. More striking.
The room buzzed with jazz and conversation. People glanced at her as she walked in. Across the space, a crowd surrounded Lucas and Chloe, who stood beside him looking every bit like the real Mrs. Callahan.
Normally, Evelyn would walk straight to them. Tonight, she chose a seat alone and started drinking. Thoughts of Lucas and Chloe pressed against her throat. She emptied one glass after another until her head went light.
Since when were Lucas and Chloe this close? How far had they gone behind her back? Did Lucas actually love Chloe? Had he been pretending to be faithful while secretly resenting Evelyn for not giving him a child?
When she saw Chloe brushing Lucas’s arm while laughing, Evelyn stood and walked toward them. Guests whispered about the Callahan couple, their admiration cutting sharper than knives. Praise for Lucas rang like a joke, because every achievement he claimed was built on Evelyn’s work.
The moment Evelyn approached, Chloe pulled her hand away from Lucas and forced a stiff smile, while Lucas greeted her warmly and wrapped an arm around her waist like the perfect husband.
“You made it,” Chloe said, her tone too bright, too careful. She looked embarrassed, maybe even annoyed. The fake wife caught in the spotlight.
Evelyn held back the urge to pull away from Lucas’s touch. Her hand nearly slapped him, but she controlled herself. Her eyes were cold, but her lips curved in a polite smile. “What were you talking about?”
“Oh, so you’re Mrs. Callahan. We’ve heard so much about you,” said one of the foreign businessmen.
They had clearly assumed Chloe was Lucas’s wife. Now they were picking up on the tension.
Evelyn lifted her glass with a steady smile, greeting familiar faces, while Lucas, still playing the devoted husband, gently took the drink from her hand and looked at her with tender concern. “Honey, you shouldn’t drink too much.”
“Mr. Callahan and his wife look so in love. I’m jealous,” someone whispered nearby.
Chloe’s expression tightened. Evelyn smiled, slipping fully into the role expected of her. “Okay, sweetheart. You drink for me.”
Lucas didn’t hesitate. He downed the glass in one go, earning applause from the crowd, as if they had witnessed a sweet moment between spouses.
Suddenly Chloe stumbled. Her wine spilled, staining her white dress a bright, unforgiving red. “Oh my God!” she yelped in exaggerated panic. Lucas immediately rushed to her.
Evelyn narrowed her eyes, catching the brief flicker in Chloe’s gaze. Almost satisfied. Almost triumphant.
Chloe shot her a sharp look before saying, “Evelyn, I ruined my dress. I have a change of clothes in Lucas’s car. Would it be okay if he grabbed it for me?”
She looked at Evelyn as if asking for permission. Her expression gentle, but Evelyn saw right through it. This wasn’t guilt. It was a challenge.
She was the one who sent that photo. The tattoo wasn’t a coincidence. It was a message. A taunt.
And Lucas? What was his part in this?
Evelyn felt something crack inside. She glanced at her husband, the man who once made her feel safe. Now everything felt fake.
Was Lucas in on this too? Did he let it happen, hoping Evelyn would eventually walk away?
Still wearing the mask of the world’s most loyal spouse, Lucas said, “Evelyn, I’ll take Chloe to change. You can stay here and talk to the guests.”
Bitterness scorched her throat, but Evelyn held her smile. Thin. Hollow. “Okay.”
As they turned and left, Evelyn waited a beat. Then she followed, keeping enough distance to stay unnoticed while still seeing where they went.
The two of them entered one of the elevators. Evelyn pressed the button for the other one and stood there, staring at the cold metal doors with her hand clenching her purse so tightly her knuckles turned white. She could march in there and blow everything up. Expose them. Humiliate them.
But not tonight. Not by acting impulsively.
Ding.
The elevator beside her opened. Inside stood Sebastian Reed and his assistant. Evelyn hesitated for a moment before stepping in. The doors closed.
Sebastian watched her closely, like he could read right through the cracks she tried to hide. When the elevator reached the lobby, Evelyn stepped out immediately. But after a few steps, his voice followed.
“Evelyn.”
She stopped. Turned slowly. “Yes, Mr. Reed?” Her voice was flat and controlled.
Sebastian looked at her from the elevator doorway, his expression unreadable. “If this project is too much for you, I can take it off your hands. It’s fine.”
Evelyn blinked, already guessing he had sensed something. “Don’t worry, Mr. Reed. I know how to separate personal problems from work.”
Sebastian didn’t respond. His gaze stayed on her, and Evelyn felt as if he had just peeled back every layer she tried to keep intact.
Then he smiled faintly. “Good.”
The doors closed, leaving Evelyn in the lobby with her pulse racing and Sebastian’s quiet smile lingering in her mind. But she didn’t have time to think about it. Her mission wasn’t over.
A few steps outside, she spotted Lucas’s car and headed toward it. But before she reached it, she stopped.
She heard something. A soft moan from inside the vehicle. Her entire body froze. The car moved. Only a little, but enough to make everything clear. In the quiet basement, she could hear faint sounds. A woman’s voice. A man’s low groan.
Intimate. Undeniable.
Instead of storming over, Evelyn turned around and walked away. Playing the fool who knew nothing.
Not tonight. Let them dance in their own filth and lies.
Their time would come.