You, Him, and I (Glee Fanfiction)

Chapter 19

"Maddy, my mom is getting married with Kurt's father and she wants you to be the bridesmaid." Finn stops my way.

"But why me?" I raise my eyebrows and walk together with him.

"I...dont know. But you know that you're like a daughter for her right? And maybe because of that." Finn says.

"When the wedding begin?" I ask Finn.

"Next week. You can right? Oh come on please." Finn begged.

"What if I dont want to?" I raise my eyebrows.

"I will persuade you, no matter what because this is what mom wants." Finn says to me.

"And I will be the bridesmaid with you?"

"If you want to, you can." Finn grins.

"Aww sweet but I dont want to." I put my tongue out of him.

"You want it or not?" Finn asks me.

"Show me how you will persuade me if I dont want to." I chuckle.

"Alright, hold my bag." Finn give me his back. I just frown then he kneel down on his knees and show me his hand. "Maddy please I want you to be my mom bridesmaid." Finn says.

I take his body and make him stand up. "You know what? The others is looking at you like you want to propose me." I chuckle.

"You want me to propose you right now? Sure I want to but I dont have any ring and I have gym class now but I guess I can skip that." Finn says to me.

"Finny, we are not dating anymore." I roll my eyes then turn my face into my locker.

"And what if we still dating?" Finn stand up next to my locker.

"I want to be a bridesmaid for your mom." I smile at him.

"Mad, you always turns our talk about us." Finn frowns at me.

"Because I think that we dont need to talk about that anymore." I shut my locker and walk off.

I'm sorry, Finn. You know that I always avoid to talk about us with you because I dont want to talk about it anymore and bring back my past.

"Babe! Watch out!" Puck suddenly grabs my body and bring me to corner.

I was walking and thinking about Finn until I dont realize that broken roof almost hit my head without Puck grabs me.

"You okay?" Puck asks me. I didnt say anything and hug him so tight. "Wait what happened?" Puck asks me.

"You safe my life." I pull my hug and kiss him.

Puck kisses me back then smiles at me. "Walk you to the fields?" Puck show me his hand.

"Sure." I take his hand and we walk together from the hallways to the field.

Finn's POV

"Quinn! Quinn!" I call Quinn as I saw her walk in the hallways alone.

"What?" Quinn turns her face at me.

"Can I talk to you about something?" I ask Quinn.

"About Madison?" Quinn raises her eyebrows.

"You can guess that." I giggle. "Can you help me to make her break up with Puck?"

Quinn frowns. "What? Finn, I dont wanna to that things anymore. I will support with whoever she dates now and I dont want to be stupid." Quinn shake her head.

"But you broke my relationship with her."

"Yeah it was my stupidness. I wont do that anymore."

"I'll give you anything you want." I said to her.

"I want Madison to be happy so you need to back off. Just let them dating, you know what is Puckerman and there will be 10% if Puck didnt cheat behind her back." Quinn says.

"But seems like Puck become a good guy with her."

"Finn, you have to deal that your love story is over. If you both were meant to be together, you'll be together. I dont want to do stupid things you asked me." Quinn says to me then walks off.

"Quinn....." I call her.

Damn! What should I do to get her back? I need someone to break them up but oh damn! I want her back. Like really.

Ah I know that. Something catches my eyes.

"Santana!" I call Santana and walk to her locker.

"What's up Frankeeteen?" Santana raise her eyebrows.

"Would you do me a favor?" I smirk at him.

"What?"

"Break Puck and Madison relationship." I grin at her.

"What? No f*****g way. Puck is hot in bed and my ex and I wont do that because Madison is my girl." Santana shake her head.

"Please Santana." I begged.

"No, no way." Santana shake her head and walk off.

I sigh and roll my eyes. Who will help me this time now? Huh? Nobody? I guess so.

"Finn, coach Beiste called you." Artie says to me.

"Thank you, dude." I said to him and walk to the boys locker room.

What happen next? Am I lose my locker key or something? Oh God.

I enter the boys locker room where coach Beiste already there and folded some clean towel.

"You called me coach?" I raise my eyebrows.

"Sit down, kid." Coach Beiste says to me.

I sit down on a bench and face her. "Is there anything wrong, coach?"

"You're not the quarterback anymore. I dont know why but your performance getting worse now and I give the postition of the quarterback to another guy." Coach Beiste says to me.

"What? You cant do that, coach!" I protest.

"Sorry, Finn. If you can prove yourself better than him. I can give your position back." Coach Beiste says.

"Who the hell is the new quarterback now?" I ask angrily.

"It's Sam Evans. The blonde guy." Coach Beiste says to me.

I kick a chair and went out from the boys locker room. Damn! Why everything is getting worse now? Since I lost Madison, I lost everything in my life and it's like I cant deny that she is my life. s**t!

I keep walking in the hallways with an angry mood right now. Until I see Sam is standing in front of his locker.

"You stole my position! First, I was happy when you joined the glee club but now you stole my position in football team!" I glare at him.

"Hey calm down, dude. It's only a game." He frowns at me.

"A game you said? You think that I dont know you teased Madison?" I push his shoulder away.

"You mad at me because of a girl? Because of a girl who is not yours anymore? Finn, open your eyes and face the truth!" Sam yells at me.

"You stole my position!" I hit him to the ground.

"You're crazy, dude!" He hit me back.

I dont care but I keep hit him. I need a victim for my angry.

"Finn! Stop it!" A girl yells and hold my body. I turn my face and Madison hold me. "Sam, you can get up?"

"I'm okay, just tell your ex to stop make anyone else as the victim of his anger." Sam says and get up.

"Finn, this is the third time." Madison frowns at me and take my hand then walk lead me.

"Ouch, my fist! Slow down, Mad." I groan.

"I can break your fist if you cant stop fighting and made anyone else as your victim!" She says angrily and keep walk lead me.

I didnt say anything and keep quiet as she walk lead me. She is my weakness and I can easily be quiet and doing nothing when she mad at me.

She keeps walking lead me until we got into the empty classroom. "Sit down there." She shows me a chair and I sit down there. "Show me your fist." She take my hand and take a towel from her bagpack.

"Ouch it hurts." I groan.

"Who told you to fight?" She raise her eyebrows.

"I was cant control it. I'm so sorry." I said sadly.

She let out a sigh and take a cold water from the wastavel to her towel then compress my hand and sit down in front of me.

"Finn, what is your mom going to say if she knows that you fighted?" She asks a little bit calm. "Tell me, what happened?"

"I lost my positions as the quarterback and it means make me lose my chance to get my football scholarship." I'm starting crying.

She keeps hold my hand then hug me. "Then you mad at someone because of that? You make him as the victim of your anger and not everything can be handle by a punch or a kick, Finn." She rubs my back.

"I lost everything in my life, okay. I lost you, I lost my position and I cant handle that. I want my life back!" I'm sobbing.

"Sssshhh everything will be fine. I dont like when you become like this. I will tell your mom about this."

"Please, Maddy dont. I dont want to let her know. I want to make her proud of me." I shake my head.

"And that's why stop complaining about your life. Finn, you have your life and you have to move on." She says to me.

"I'm sorry. I know I'm such a mess." I said with my head down.

"You're not." She shake her head and make my face facing her.

"My fist is still hurt." I said to her.

"Dont fight anymore. This is the last time okay." She smiles at me and compress my hand with her towel.

"Do you still love me?" I ask her.

She didnt say anything but turn her face from facing me. I hold her chin and make her facing me and she look onto my eyes deeply. I cup her cheek and push my face closer to her. I really wanna drown into her beautiful eyes. I keep pushing my face closer to her and kiss her softly and she kiss me back and I think I got the answer.

Suddenly a sound of things fall down stop us. Until we see that Puck is standing in front of the door and look mad. Then he walk off.

"Puck!" Madison yells and walk off leave me alone.

Madison's POV

"Do you still love me?" Finn asks me.

I didnt answer him and turn my face away from him but he hold my chin and make me face him. I cant lie and what dad said was right. I'm in love with two different person at the same time. I keep looking at his eyes deeply until he cup my cheek and pushes his face closer to me and kisses me softly. I cant handle that and kiss him back.

Suddenly there is a sound of a things fall down that make us stop. I turn my face and see Puck is standing in front of the door and look upset then walk off.

"Puck!" I shout and left Finn alone. "Puck, I can explain!" I stop him in the hallways.

"Tell me you still in love with Finn?" Puck frown at me.

"No, I didnt." I lied.

"And what was that kissed? I know you kiss him back. I can see that." Puck glare at me.

"It was an accident." I said to him.

"What accident huh?" Puck raise his eyebrows.

"It was an accident like the first time you kissed me." I said to him. "Puck, please I love you."

"I love you too but dont talk to me until you realized what you have done." Puck simply said and walk off.

"Puck please!" I yell and kick a locker.

Everything is getting worse now. Puck is mad at me and I dont know what should I do. I know that Puck is type of a person who is really hard to persuade.

I sigh and tears slowly fall down from my face. I sit down on the ground because I lost my energy.

Puck's POV

"Puck, I can explain!" She stops me in the hallways.

"Tell me you still in love with Finn?" I frown at her.

"No, I didnt." She shake her head.

"And what was that kissed? I know you kiss him back. I can see that." I glare at her.

"It was an accident."

"What accident huh?" I raise my eyebrows.

"It was an accident like the first time you kissed me." She said to me. "Puck, please I love you."

"I love you too but dont talk to me until you realized what you have done." I simply said and walk off.

I'm sorry, Mad. But it hurts me when I saw you kiss another guy and that guy is Finn. I know you dont cheated behind my back but I know you still have feeling left for him and this is what I'm afraid of.

I turn my face and I see that Madison is crying alone. I really wanna hug her but I cant. I want her realized that she is mine and not Finn's anymore.

She changed my whole life to be a better guy and thats why I dont wanna lose her or anything. I just wanna be with her.

Madison's POV

"Mad, you okay?"

I turn my face and Quinn frowns at me. I just nodded at her and wipe my tears.

"Tell me what happened." Quinn pulls my hand and make me stand up.

I grab her body and hug her then crying. "Puck saw Finn and I kissed and then he mad at me and he doesnt want to talk to me." I'm sobbing.

"You and Finn kissed?" Quinn frowns at me.

"It was accidentally. I was helping him with his bruise on his fist after he punched Sam and I cant lie that I miss him." I'm crying.

Quinn pushes my body and hug me again. "Everything will be fine. I cant believe that a guy like Puckerman who usually flirt with another girl can mad at you. It will be fine."

"But what if Puck really mad at me?"

"He wont. Maybe he will give you a silent treatment for couple days. No more than that." Quinn wipe my tears.

"But what if more than couple days?"

"Trust me. It wont more than couple days." Quinn says to me.

"But what if....."

"Ugh stop it!" Quinn cut me off and take my hand then walk lead me.

I wipe my tears with my other hand and keep walking behind Quinn. Ugh I dont know what I am going to do right now and to make Puck trust me.

We then enter the choir room. I saw Finn and Puck are there. Finn look at me with guilty face and Puck turn his face away avoiding me. Okay great. Everything is perfect now. Perfect in wrong way.