You, Him, and I (Glee Fanfiction)

Chapter 22

This week is valentine and everyone seems busy with kind of pink, love, chocolate. Actually the valentines itself will be held in two days to go but I dont really care with that since I'm single and I'm happy.

By the way how can people have two valentine dates at the same time? It's impossible thing to do actually. But I'm fine. I'm totally fine.

I'm opening my locker but suddenly love paper full with pink and sparkling fall down from above. I look around to find who did this until I see Puck is standing about three meters from me and smirks at me.

I just can give him a smile. This is cute. How can him be sweet like that? I shake my head and turn my face to my locker and put my book inside until someone touch my sleeve. I turn my face but no one is around until I turn my face to my left side.

Finn cover his face with a chocolate box with love shapes. Then he show me his face and smiling at me. "Happy valentine day." He give me the chocolate box.

"Aww this is sweet. Thank you, Finn." I smile back at him.

Finn just smile at me and walk off. Damn! God, why you gave me two sweet guys into my life at the same time? And now I cant choose one of them.

I place the chocolate inside my locker and I'll bring it home later. Now lets go to the choir room and having glee club.

I enter the choir room and this room is full with love shape and pink and roses and many things. I love valentine day but I just cant deal for being in love with two person at the same time.

I sit down in the front seat next to Brittany and Artie who cant stop smirks at each other until Mr. Schue walks in.

"Valentine. Mostly identified with love song so our glee club theme this week is Love Song!" Mr. Schue walks in as he write down on the white board.

"That's silly." I mumble.

"It's not silly at all." Artie shake his head.

"And because we lost some budgets for regionals we have to do fund raising." Mr. Schue says.

"Again?" I frowned.

"Because your cheerios stole all the budget." Kurt says to me.

"Excuse me, we are national champs and we got many sponsor for our budgets and our facilities." Santana glared at Kurt.

"Okay stop it. We will sell chocolate valentine for fund raising." Mr. Schue says.

"Mr. Schue what about kissing booth? Chocolate valentine is not really happening nowadays." Finn says.

"Wanky. Chocolate valentine is not really happening nowadays but you gave Madison a box of chocolates." Santana rolls her eyes. "Oh dont ask me how could I know that, I have many eyes on people."

"I'll make my own kissing booth and dont worry I will give the money I get for glee club." Finn says to us.

"Actually your idea sounds cool." Sam says to us.

"How much money we need for regionals?" I ask Mr. Schue.

"We lost budgets for hairspray and costume actually." Mr. Schue says to me.

"Be right back." I said to them and walk out from choir room.

I walk faster to my locker and take my wallet from my pocket and take all the money inside there then walk back to the choir room.

"1200 bucks for regionals. I guess quiet enough for hairspray and costume." I give the money to Mr. Schue.

"But Madison, you dont have to do this." Mr. Schue shrugs.

"Take it, Mr. Schue because I dont want to sell my lips." Kurt says.

"Me too. Because my kisses is not for sale." I nod as agree. "And I wont let anyone of you to sale your kisses for someone you dont love in valentines."

"Alright, thank you so much, Madison." Mr. Schue takes the money.

"You're welcome." I grin at him and walk back to my seat.

"Well, who want to show the love song today?" Mr. Schue asks.

"Can I?" Finn raises his hand.

"Take it away, Finn." Mr. Schue says and sit down next the piano.

Finn nods to the band and smirks at me until the music begin. I just frown at him and smirk back at him until he start singing.

Finn:

Hello, I love you

Won't you tell me your name

Hello, I love you

Let me jump in your game

Finn kneel down on his knees right in front of me and hold my hand while he is still singing and smirks at me.

Hello, I love you

Won't you tell me your name

Hello, I love you

Let me jump in your game

She's walkin' down the street

Blind to every eye she meets

Do you think you'll be the guy

To make the queen of the angels sigh

Hello, I love you

Won't you tell me your name

Hello, I love you

Let me jump in your game

Hello, I love you

Won't you tell me your name

Hello, I love you

Let me jump in your game

She holds her head so high

Like a statue in the sky

Her arms are wicked and her legs are long

When she moves my brain screams out this song

Sidewalk crouches at her feet

Like a dog that begs for somethin' sweet

Do you hope to make her see, you fool

Do you hope to pluck this dusky jewel

Hello! Hello!

Hello! Hello!

Hello! Hello! Hello!

I want you

I need my baby

Hello! Hello!

I need, yeah yeah

Hello! Hello!

Hello! Hello!

Finn ended up his song with full of clapping with the others. I just can chuckle and clapping.

"Such a good start, Finn." Mr. Schue says.

"I know that, Mr. Schue." Finn says as he is still smirks at me.

"Well, I just want to tell that I already booked a table for all of us in Breadstix on Valentines Day. So all of you have to come." Quinn says to us.

"Cool." I'm clapping.

The others cheering happily also clapping. This would be a great valentine day I guess. And I'm happy for this.

The bells rings.

"Alright see you guys with another love song tomorrow." Mr. Schue says to us.

I stand up from my seat and about to take my bagpack. Until Finn suddenly stop me.

"Mad, I have a problem with Algebra would you help me to do my homework beside I have test tomorrow?" Finn asks me.

"Sure. When?" I raise my eyebrows.

"Now, your house?"

"Alright." I smile at Finn and walk off to my locker.

Puck's POV

"That's a sweet lie, dude." I laugh.

"I'm competing and I win." Finn smirk at me.

"Yeah you are." I simply said and walk off.

I'm sorry, Finn but you are not win yet. You'll see what I'm gonna do tomorrow. You might be can have a date with her today but tomorrow and next, she is mine.

I already plan something and I will give it to her. No one can stop Puckerman. Even I have to competing with my bestfriend and I'm gonna win.

Love is love. Game is game.

Madison's POV

"It's kinda strange when you attend Algebra class." I frown at Finn as I take my bagpack from my locker.

"I need to find some distraction about my position as the quarterback." Finn says to me.

"I though you got your position back because I saw the last time you play the game it was good." I take the chocolate box he gave me and shut my locker.

"Not yet. Wait, you wanna bring that home?" Finn pointed at the chocolate box.

I nod. "We can eat it together." I smile at Finn.

"Cool." Finn smile back at me.

I just nod and walk to the parking lot and get home. It's been a long time Finn and I didnt go home together or doing homework together.

~~~~

Finn and I laying flat on my bed next to each other and finishing his Algebra homework and studying together.

"First of all, count this into this then got the answer. You got it, Finn?" I turn my face at Finn.

He just starring at me and I bet he didnt listen to me. "You're beautiful." Finn look onto my eyes.

I just smile shyly at him and he give me his smirk until we push our face getting closer and look at to our lips and we crash our lips and we kiss. I'm forget last time Finn kiss me but I guess it's been a long time ago and I miss him now.

"I guess we are here to study." I chuckle.

"I'm wondering that chocolate taste." Finn says and points to that chocolate box on my table.

I stand up from my bed and walk to my table then take that chocolate box then go back to sit down on my bed. I opened the wrapper and take one chocolate.

"Not bad. It's sweet like you." I chuckle as I eat my chocolate.

"Let me try." Finn take the chocolate box.

I take that chocolate box and shake my head. "No way. This is mine!"

"Maddy, give me that or I will....." Finn smirks at me.

I take a chocolate. "Open your mouth." I grin at Finn.

Finn open his mouth. I show the chocolate to him and about to put into his mouth but I eat it. Finn frown at me and I laugh so hard until he start tickling me and we laugh together.

"You're trying to play along with me so you have to pay for this." Finn laughs and still tickling me.

"Finn, stop it. Okay okay you win." I laugh and groan.

Finn stop tickling me but he grabs my body and make me fall on top of him. "I miss you so bad."

"We meet like everyday, Finn."

"Yeah but it sucks when I can see you in the hallways but I cant hold you or anything." Finn flip my hair behind my earlobe.

"This the best choice for us. I miss you too still and always but...."

"Puck?" Finn raise his eyebrows.

"I just cant." I shake my head and leave his body then sit down in front of him.

"We can secretly dating. We never show to the others that we were dating, they know because they find out. I want you to be mine. Give me second chance." Finn hold my hand.

"It's third chance."

"Whatever with that please one more chance to fix everything. We both love each other." Finn says to me.

"Secretly dating is more hurt than caught Rachel kissed you. Because it's mean that we are dating but we cant hold each other and that's what for? Finn, I dont wanna hurt both of you." I cup his cheek.

"You know that you are the best thing in my life and I dated you because I truly love you not because popularity." Finn says to me.

I dont answer him. I love him but if we date, I will hurt Puck and I dont wanna hurt Puck. I dont know who should I choose. I dont know what should I do. I just can turn my away.

Finn cup my cheeks and make my tears fall down. If I can divided my body and my soul into two parts maybe it will be fair but sadly I cant.

"I'm sorry, I cant see you cry anymore." Finn wipe my tears.

"It's okay." I half-smiled at him.

"Do you want me to leave?" Finn asks me.

"No, we havent finish eat this chocolate. I dont want to be fat alone." I chuckle.

"You even didnt give me that." Finn rolls his eyes.

I take a pieces of chocolate and feed it to Finn. He smiles at me while chewing that food. And I just smile back at him when he feed me that chocolate. We are smiling at each other then Finn put his hand around my waist and I put my hand around his shoulder until we push our face getting closer and make our forehead and our nose touching and we still smiling at each other. This is sweet.