You, Him, and I (Glee Fanfiction)

Chapter 23

One day before valentines day tomorrow and I dont have valentine day because I dont want to. I want to but I cant choose which one of Finn or Puck so I'd rather to be alone.

"Hey, princess Collins." Someone play a puppet with a puppy doll behind my locker door when I wanna take my book.

"Hey, what are you doing, puppy?" I chuckle.

"I'm sending here by Puckerman to send you valentines gift."

I just chuckle and shut my locker. "And what's that?" I raise my eyebrows.

"This puppy is your gift now because I know you like puppy." Puck chuckle as he is still doing the puppet.

"Aww sweet." I chuckle and hold the puppy doll he gave me.

"Do you like it?" Puck asks me.

"This is cute." I smile at him.

"Like you." Puck smirks at me.

"Thank you so much, Puck." I giggle.

"One more thing." Puck shows me a bouquet of white roses from his back.

"Puck, this is sweet." I smile at him.

"One more thing again." Puck says to me. "Show me your hand."

I show my hand to Puck then he place something on my palm of hand. I look at it and it's a candy love and it wrotes 'kiss me'.

I smile at him and put my hand around his shoulder while hold all his gift and he wrap my waist then I kiss him and he kisses me back.

"Happy valentine day, my princess." Puck smiles at me.

"This is sweet." I smile happily at him.

"I know I am. See you in glee club!" Puck says to me then walk off.

I just smiling through this cute doll and the flowers he gave me. Such a sweet one. I cant believe that I'm single but I got many valentine gift.

Finn's POV

I'm walking down in the hallways alone until I see Puck gave something to Madison.

Wait, it's not something but it's two things. A puppy doll also a bouquet of flowers? Damn it!

Oh no it's not two things. Puck put something into Madison's hand. Like a candy. And now it's three things.

They both just chuckle until Madison kisses him in front of her locker. God, I won yesterday but I lose today. And now I'm still stuck here like an i***t.

"Jealous much, Finn?" Quinn walks passes me and laughs.

Ugh no way. I wont let Puck win this time. I have to prepare something bigger than what he gave and something that Madison want and I bet he didnt know it.

Dont play along with Finn Hudson.

Madison's POV

"Seems like you got many valentines gift and you're single." Quinn chuckles.

"They're sweet. I cant even think which one is the sweeter. I spent the rest of the day with Finn yesterday in my home and it was cute and sweet. And now, Puck gave me these and it's sweet. I'm gonna die." I chuckle.

"Haha they both really competing to get your heart." Quinn chuckles.

"And I dont know what to do. If I could divided my body into two parts, maybe it would be fair." I sigh.

"Haha stop it. Decided it later, the real superman will show off himself. Now lets have lunch." Quinn takes my hand.

"What do you give to Rachel?" I ask Quinn.

"Nothing but I guess I want to ask her out later. What do you think?" Quinn asks back.

"If you think that's good, why not." I smile at her.

"Yeah I hope so." Quinn sighs then smiles at me.

We keep walking to the cafetaria until I enter cafetaria and someone stops me and give me a love baloon wrotes 'I love you'.

"From?" I raise my eyebrows.

That geeky guy only pointed at the corner. I turn my face until I see Finn is standing and smiling at me. I give him a smile back and walk to get my lunch then have a seat with the others.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Lunch is over and classes is also over and now it's time for the glee club. This is the best valentine ever.

I'm walking in the hallways until someone stops me again and give me a love card. I open the love card and it wrotes 'I love you from someone on the corner'.

I turn my face and Puck is smirks at me until he walk off to another place. Oh God, damn they are sweet like really sweet. This is my first valentine because last year or before, I never be in a relationship before until I dated Finn.

I hold the paper card and walk to the choir room. Cant wait for another surprise like this. God, you drive me crazy.

I enter the choir room and sit down on the front seat next to Artie until Mr. Schue walks in.

"Alright guys, who wanna show their love song today?" Mr. Schue asks.

But no one answer and we turn our face to the door a big Barney is walk into the choir room. Bring some love baloons.

That barney standing in front of me and give me a love card and it wrotes 'be my forever'. I just can chuckle and wondering who is that because Finn and Puck is not here.

"Who are you?" I chuckle.

That Barney open his mask and it's Finn. Oh God this is really sweet and I cant imagine he would do that for me.

"I love you, you love me. We are meant to be. With a big hug and kiss from me to you. Wont you say you love me too?" Finn singing and smirks at me.

"Aww this is so sweet." I chuckle.

"That's not. This one is will make you flattered." Puck walks in bring a guitar.

Puck gave me a stalk of white rose then play his guitar and singing.

Puck:

I've tried playing it cool

But when I'm looking at you

I can't ever be brave

'Cause you make my heart race

Shot me out of the sky

You're my kryptonite

You keep making me weak

Yeah, frozen and can't breathe

Something's gotta give now

'Cause I'm dying just to make you see

That I need you here with me now

'Cause you've got that one thing

So get out, get out, get out of my head

And fall into my arms instead

I don't, I don't, don't know what it is

But I need that one thing

And you've got that one thing

Now I'm climbing the walls

But you don't notice at all

That I'm going out of my mind

All day and all night

Something's gotta give now

'Cause I'm dying just to know your name

And I need you here with me now

'Cause you've got that one thing

So get out, get out, get out of my head

And fall into my arms instead

I don't, I don't, don't know what it is

But I need that one thing

So get out, get out, get out of my mind

And come on, come into my life

I don't, I don't, don't know what it is

But I need that one thing

And you've got that one thing

Woah-oh-oh-oh

Woah-oh-oh-oh

Woah-oh-oh-oh

You've got that one thing

Get out, get out, get out of my head

And fall into my arms instead

So get out, get out, get out of my head

And fall into my arms instead

I don't, I don't, don't know what it is

But I need that one thing

So get out, get out, get out of my mind (out of my mind)

And come on, come into my life

I don't, I don't, don't know what it is

But I need that one thing

Yeah, you've got that one thing

I cant stop smiling when he sang this song in front of me. This is one of my favorite song and I love when he sang it for me.

"This is sweet." I chuckle.

"I have one more thing." Puck says and take something under a piano.

A big box like really big. He place it on the ground in front of me. I open the cover until I see a real puppy inside.

"Oh my gosh this is Pomeranian puppy and it's cream color and she is a girl!" I yell happily. "Aww thank you so much, Puck." I smile at Puck and take the puppy.

"I also have one more thing." Finn says and walk to the back row.

I hold the puppy and look at him as he take a big box and bring it to the front and place it on the ground next to Puck's box. I open the box and a meow come out.

"Oh my god, this is a persian grey kitten. And she is also a girl. Oh cutie." I said and place the puppy in the box then take the kitten.

"Are we paid here to watch two guys are trying to get a girl's heart?" Santana rolls her eyes.

"Shut up, Santana because I still have one more thing." Puck says and walk to the behind a big stereo. "Who loves Cookie Monster?" Puck smirks at me and shows me a blue cookie monster doll.

"What about this big Teddy?" Finn shows me a big teddy bear like really big.

"Come on, Puck do you have anything left?" Kurt asks Puck.

"Sadly I dont." Puck sighs.

"What about you, Finn?" Kurt asks Finn.

"Only these balloons." Finn says and give the love balloons.

"I dont know what to say but this is so sweet and really sweet. I will give the puppy name with Puck and the kitten name with Finn. Thank you so much, guys." I smile at Finn and Puck.

"So who?" They both says together.

"Who what?" I raise my eyebrows.

"Who will be your valentines this year obviously." Kurt rolls his eyes.

"It's Sam." I simply said.

"What? Babe, you've gotta be kidding me." Puck gaps and shake his head.

"Madison, you're mine." Finn protest.

"I'm sorry but Sam gave me a new comic books that I really wanted to." I said to them.

"But this is all the things you want." Puck says to me.

"Yeah, Mr. Collins said that you really want a kitten." Finn says to me.

"Guys, I'm sorry. The things you both gave me are my christmas wishlist last year." I said to them. "But thank you so much. I got all my christmas gift earlier. Cant wait to tell my parents." I chuckle.

Finn and Puck look disappointed and sighs.

"Finn, Puck. Go back to your seat and remember is not allowed to bring a pet to school." Mr. Schue says to us.

I turn my face to Puck and Finn one by one. I'm sorry guys, this is for the best because I cant choose one of you. And if I choose it will hurt anyone else so last night I already prepare and asked Sam to help me out and he wanted to. I love you both too.