The email arrived at 4:12 p.m.
It said, in the flat language of customer service, that the order placed on Monday at 8:38 p.m. to Gerber Hall under the name L. Atwood had been claimed at 8:44 p.m. by the phone number associated with the account, and that the order was retrieved from locker 14. Caroline's order, placed at 8:41, had been delivered to locker 14 as well, and had been claimed at 8:47 by a different phone number - one that did not match any account on file.
I read it three times.
Luke had claimed his own order at 8:44. Caroline's order had been claimed three minutes later by someone using a different phone. Luke's post said Sophie had taken Caroline's food at 8:47. But Sophie's phone had been in the library the whole time, and the library had cameras, and the library records
