
Amity Falls is an intelligent student with a 4.2 GPA, a tendency to hold a grudge, and a cat in a bag that she can't afford to let out. When her first week in a new school after her parent's sudden divorce gets a rough start, Amity finds herself being paired with one of the school's most eligible bachelors through the school's very own private dating system, aka the Lust List.
Ezekiel "Zeke" Wright is Middleton High's star quarterback and the captain of the football team, due to that, he gets frequently matched on the Lust List and is known for always getting the girl. He has wit, charm, and striking features, which is a concoction that dooms all girls to fall for him. However, with his GPA dropping past a 4.0, he's in desperate need of a tutor in order to keep his spot on the football team.
The student council, who runs the Lust List, takes it upon themselves to place Amity as Zeke's personal tutor, possibly more their gain than his. But after a couple of days of him trying to woo her, he's baffled by the fact that his charming personality has zero effect on her. Will Amity be able to keep her secret? Will she be Zeke's next victim or will her heart remain intact?

