Chapter 4: Awakening
Benjamin's POV
I cannot sleep because the image of Judith severing that Iron Claw warrior's bond keeps replaying in my mind, and I do not know if what I feel is awe or terror. She stood there with power radiating from her skin and broke a wolf's connection to his Alpha with just a touch, and the warrior collapsed like his strings had been cut. I have trained my whole life to be strong and dominant, but Judith's power makes my physical strength seem meaningless.
My father paces his office and argues with Matthew and Robert about what the attack means, whether Solomon will try again or if driving him back was enough to deter future attempts. Robert insists we should hand Judith over before we end up in full war, that one omega is not worth pack lives, and rage burns through me at the casual dismissal. She is not just some omega and she is not property to trade away, though I struggle to articulate exactly what she is to me beyond the certainty that she is mine.
Except she has made it very clear that she is not mine and does not want to be, and her rejection haunts me more than it should. Every wolf is taught that finding your mate is the ultimate joy and that the bond completes you, but Judith insists she feels nothing and wants nothing. I have tried to convince myself that she is confused or scared, that she will recognize our connection once she accepts it, but her scream telling me to leave her room still echoes in my ears.
Matthew finds me in the training yard where I am beating a practice dummy to splinters, and he watches silently until I finally stop and face him. He tells me carefully that I need to consider whether my feelings for Judith are real or if I am just reacting to the loss of my bond with Sandra, seeking replacement for what was taken. The question makes me angry because I know what I feel, but Matthew continues gently and asks if I have actually listened to what Judith has told me about herself.
I want to argue but Matthew's expression is too knowing, and he reminds me that Judith has said repeatedly that she does not want a mate, that she has never felt the pull other wolves describe, and that forcing my attention on her is making her miserable. He asks me what kind of mate I would be if my presence causes her pain, and the words hit harder than any physical blow. I have been so focused on my certainty that we are destined for each other that I never actually considered her truth.
Sandra visits me later that day and I almost do not recognize her because she looks lighter somehow, less burdened than she did when we were bonded. She tells me that breaking the bond was the best thing that ever happened to her, that she has felt trapped in our arrangement since childhood but had no way to refuse without shaming her father. Her honesty shocks me and I ask why she never said anything, and she laughs bitterly and asks when she could have, when refusing an Alpha's son is not really an option.
We talk for hours and Sandra explains what it felt like to have her future decided before she was old enough to have opinions, how the bond formed at the ceremony felt like chains settling into place, how Judith breaking it felt like being able to breathe for the first time. She tells me that she has been talking to Richard and discovering what it means to choose someone rather than being assigned to them, and I realize with uncomfortable clarity that I have been doing to Judith exactly what the pack did to Sandra.
That night I sat outside Judith's door like I have every night since she was confined, but instead of planning how to convince her we belong together, I actually think about what she has told me. She said she is aromantic, that she does not feel romantic or s****l attraction, that her inability to want a mate is not brokenness but simply who she is. I have dismissed this as impossible because every wolf is supposed to want their mate, but Sandra's confession about feeling trapped has shaken my certainty.
I remember my mother before she died and how she used to tell me that the mate bond was a gift that should never be forced, and how my father changed after losing her, becoming rigid and controlling in his grief. I have spent my whole life trying to be the Alpha my father wants, following the rules about bonds and duty and pack hierarchy, but maybe those rules are wrong. Maybe Judith's power exists to break bonds that should never have been formed, and maybe I am one of those mistakes.
The thought terrifies me because if I am wrong about Judith then I am wrong about everything I have built my identity on, but I cannot unsee Sandra's relief or unhear Judith's pain. Matthew returns and sits beside me in the hallway, and he tells me quietly that real strength is not forcing others to submit but having the courage to change when you realize you are wrong. He says that if I truly care about Judith then I need to protect her freedom even if it means walking away from what I want.
I ask him how I am supposed to do that when everything in me screams that she is mine, and he smiles sadly and tells me that the screaming is not my heart but my training, years of being taught that Alphas take what they want and that wolves exist in bonded pairs. He suggests that maybe I should spend less time trying to claim Judith and more time actually getting to know her as a person, without agenda or expectation, and see if friendship is possible.
The idea feels both revolutionary and terrifying, but I agree to try because the alternative is becoming the villain in her story and I do not want that. I knock on Judith's door and ask if we can talk, really talk without me pushing for a bond, and after a long silence she agrees. She sits on her bed and I sit on the floor to be less threatening, and I ask her to explain what aromantic means because I genuinely do not understand.
Judith studies me suspiciously like she expects a trap, but slowly she begins to talk about never experiencing crushes or attraction, about feeling broken when other wolves talked about finding mates, about learning to hide her difference because admitting it made others uncomfortable. She tells me that she has built a good life helping Claire with healing work and maintaining friendships like the one with Eden, and that she does not need or want romance to feel complete.
Listening to her speak without planning my counterarguments is harder than any fight I have been in, but I force myself to really hear her words and the pain beneath them. When she finishes I tell her that I am sorry for not listening before, for assuming I knew her feelings better than she did, and that I will try to do better. She looks stunned by the apology and I realize that no one has ever apologized to her for dismissing her identity.
We talk into the night and I learn that Judith loves the smell of healing herbs and the feeling of helping injured wolves recover, that she wants to travel someday to neutral territories and see how unbonded wolves live, that her favorite color is the deep green of forest shadows. I tell her about the pressure of being Alpha heir and never being allowed to fail, about losing my mother too young and having a father who shows love through control, about my friendship with Stephen that is the only relationship where I can be myself.
When dawn light creeps through her window we are both exhausted, and Judith tells me carefully that she appreciates my apology but that one conversation does not erase weeks of ignoring her boundaries. She says that if I truly want to change then I need to prove it through actions not words, and I agree because she is right. I leave her room feeling like something fundamental has shifted in me, and I realize that whether or not Judith ever wants any kind of relationship with me, I need to become someone who respects her choice.
My father finds me and demands to know why I am not pursuing Judith more aggressively, and for the first time in my life I openly disagree with him.