Hailey thinks her relationship with Jaiden is perfect, but a business trip throws her into the arms of Ethan, who uses his identical face and a smooth lie to claim her for himself . Discovering that the brothers' old high school feud has reignited over the same girl, the twins' mother forces a secret alliance with Hailey's wealthy parents to make her disappear without a trace. When the twins finally track Hailey down six years later, Jaiden discovers Ethan's massive betrayal, and Ethan realizes his secret game cost them both the only woman they ever loved.