The Unholy Trinity

The Mean Triplet (Zoey's POV)

“If only there was a way you could get invited to the Thortons.” Tate stated.

“Um and why would I do that?”

“Oh there must be heaps of evidence of what Marsden is doing in that house.”

“I doubt I’d find it.” I laughed. 

“You’re probably right. Let’s focus on something that matters.” He kissed me hard as he snapped his fingers. The lights went out. 

Tate said he liked s*x in the dark. He loved relying on touch to get off. He wanted to hear me moan instead of just seeing it. 

Tate’s hands pulled roughly at our clothes until we were completely naked. I was also kind of getting into s*x in the dark. It was kind of exciting. 

I gasped as Tate played with my c**t with one hand and grabbed my hand, guiding down to his growing erection. I moved my hand quickly, wanting to get him ready quickly. I wanted him inside of me immediately. 

Tate’s hips bucked erratically, desperate for more friction. 

My own hips rolled as I felt the build up in the pit of my stomach. I was so close. Tate rubbed faster as he removed my hand from his d**k. He pressed his tip to my entrance. As my orgasm overtook me, Tate pushed inside of me. 

He cried out, feeling me tighten around him. He grunted as he rammed into me powerfully. I reached up and my fingers found his hair. I pulled it hard.

“Pull it harder,” He begged. 

I listened, loving the reaction I got out of him. I loved when Tate screamed and thrusted into me harder because he couldn’t help himself. 

I sighed as his hand wrapped around my throat. I never knew I was into this before being with Tate. 

Tate’s mouth was now right next to my ear. “f**k, it feels so good being inside of you.”

“Harder, Tate,” I whimpered. 

I knew he loved hearing me plead like that. 

“You like that?” He panted. 

“Yes Tate!”

He removed his hand and put his lips on my neck. He sucked hard as his powerful thrusts continued to send pleasure throughout my entire body. 

He pulled out and flipped me over on my stomach. I breathed shallowly through Tate’s passionate pumps. His palms slid to the back of my hands and intertwined his fingers with mine as he pushed deeper inside of me. 

He gently nibbled on my shoulder. “I’m so close,” 

“Finish for me baby,” I murmured. 

“Oh f**k!” Tate gasped loudly as he came deep inside of me. He stayed on top of me breathing loudly. “That gets better every single time.”

As much as I loved s*x with Tate and how our s*x life had developed, I was still thinking of Cade’s horrid words. Why had it taken Tate so long to start out s*x life? Was it because we were so busy or he just wasn’t that interested in being with me like that at first? 

I snapped the lights back on as Tate rolled off of me. He laid on his back, catching his breath. 

“Hey, Tate?” 

“Yeah Zo?”

“I love you.” I whispered. 

“Yeah, I love you too.”

He was still saying the words, so he must have meant them, right?

--

I felt strange after talking to Joey in the mirror. I didn’t think I liked that she was getting so close to Brielle. Joey didn’t need to be anymore involved in that family than she already was. 

Tate wasn’t in our room and then I remembered he was in Raina’s. I decided to see how that was going.

I heard them talking and listened. 

“Wow, what I said really bothered you, huh?” Raina laughed. 

“I didn’t say that!”

“It’s clear. I mean I remind you how much you couldn’t keep your d**k out of me and suddenly you’re f*****g Zoey?”

When did they have that conversation? 

“I just thought it was time to elevate our relationship,” Tate said stubbornly. 

“How is it with her? Do you tell her what to do and how to do it the way you did with me?  Do you pull her hair and f**k her from behind? Do you have to look in her eyes when you finish?” Raina questioned. “God do I miss those times in the dark.”

I racked my brain. I didn’t think Tate had once finished while looking at me. It was always from behind, even in the dark. 

“What Zoey and I do is none of your business.”

“It’s not as good with her is it? Oh poor Tate. You know my arms and legs are always open for you.”

Oh that’s it!

“Done in here Tate?” I asked breezing into the room. 

“Yep,” He said quickly. “Let’s go babe.”

I shot Raina a dirty look before following him out. 

“Did you like s*x with Raina better than you do with me?” I blurted out. 

“What? Why would you ask me that?” He questioned. 

“I heard you two talking! Was your s*x life better with her?”

“God, no Zoey! She was just trying to get under my skin!”

“Yeah, well it looks like it worked! And that's because there’s some truth to it!”

“No there isn’t!” Tate insisted. “We just started having s*x, it’s still new.”

“And why is that we just started, huh?” I demanded. “Because she pointed out that we didn’t? Was it about proving her wrong or something?”

“I just wanted to have s*x with you, Zoey! Why am I being punished for that?” Tate yelled. “Like I said, Raina just wanted to bother me!”

“When did that conversation happen, by the way? You’re just having talks with your ex-girlfriend and not telling me?” 

“I didn’t realize I had to run every single conversation I have by you!”

“Conversations with your ex? Oh you definitely do!” I stated. 

“You act like I’m gonna cheat on you!” Tate shook his head. 

“Can you blame me? You cheated with me!”

“You cheated with me too!”

I gasped. “I-that was totally your fault!”

“No one told you to kiss me back Zoey.”

“Well, you’ll be lucky if I kiss you at all for the rest of the night!” I snapped. 

I couldn't believe Tate and I were fighting like this. We never fought. We were pretty much always on the same side. 

This was stupid Raina’s fault. I couldn’t let her tear us apart.

I sighed. “I’m sorry.”

“Really? “Tate asked. 

“Of course. I am making a big deal out of nothing.”

“Oh…um I’m sorry too. I was being kind of a prick. I should know better than to be having private conversations with my ex-girlfriend. Especially a girl who is clearly still interested in me.”

“I forgive you,” I smiled slightly. Tate stared at me in awe. “Why are you looking at me like that?”

“She never apologized first. Like ever. And it’s…I don’t know, refreshing. It just confirms that I made the right choice when I chose you.”  Tate smiled. 

“I see,”

It felt amazing to hear Tate say those words. He chose me. I had to remember that.

And to keep an eye on Raina.

--

I couldn't believe Raina had just introduced Cade as her boyfriend. 

I glanced over at Chloey whose eyes looked like they would fall out of their sockets. 

“Oh f**k no,” Rune said. “You’re not dating him, Raina!”

“You can’t tell me who to date!” She gasped. 

“Yes, I can! You are not dating my girlfriend’s ex!”

“You’re dating my ex’s girlfriend’s sister!”

“That’s a mouthful,” I muttered, still completely in shock. 

“That’s different! Tate and I fell in love two thirds of a set of triplets at the same time! You’re doing this to be nasty!” Rune hissed. 

“In love?” Chloey asked. 

“That’s…we can talk about that later.”  Rune muttered. 

“Cade and I bonded over getting our hearts broken, I’m sorry you don’t like that Rune, but you’re going to have to get over that.” Raina stated. “It’s not our fault we fell in love with cheaters.”

“Cheaters?” Chloey questioned. “I didn’t cheat on you Cade!”

“Emotionally you did. You were basically lying to me,” He said dramatically .

“You really were lying to me!”

“I don’t want to fight Chloey.”  

“Raina why would you want to date someone who lied to their last girlfriend?” Rune questioned. 

“I’m not a priss like Chloey, I don’t care that Cade isn’t a virgin. He wouldn’t be one with me very long anyways.”

I glanced at Tate. There was pure fury in his eyes. I couldn’t tell if he was still mad about Cade cursing him or if he didn’t like seeing Raina with another guy. 

“This is embarrassing,” I laughed. 

“How so?” Raina challenged. 

“Cade is in love with my sister. He told me so himself. So this is now the second time you have a boyfriend that’s in love with one of us. Are you embarrassed at all that the guys you date aren’t very interested in you? If Marsden and Joey break up, are you gonna date him while he desperately pines after her? Is that who you want to be Raina? The second choice? Kinda sad.”

I was shocked when I saw tears fill Raina’s eyes. I think I actually struck a nerve with what I said. 

“You’re a b***h, Zoey.” Raina whispered. “You stole my boyfriend-”

“I didn’t steal anything! He kissed me! Multiple times while you two were together. I told him to stay with you.” I laughed. “But he still chose me. You don’t get to blame me for not being able to keep your boyfriend interested in you, Raina. And don’t blame me for getting another boyfriend that’s not into you. Maybe ask yourself why they’re not interested. I think it’s your personality, personally.”

“Let’s go Cade!” Raina pulled him out of the dining room, with him looking longingly back at Chloey.

“Zoey!” Tate looked at me like I was crazy. “What is wrong with you?”

“What? Did I say something that wasn’t correct?” I asked. 

“You didn’t have to be so mean,”

“She cursed me in my own home! How am I the bad guy here?”

“You wouldn’t have said all that if you weren’t threatened by her.” Tate shook his head. 

“Do I have a reason to feel threatened?”

“I don’t know,” He got up and walked off. 

We were silent for a moment before Chloey spoke. “I don’t think I like Raina very much.”

--

Tate would barely talk to me. I couldn’t believe he took Raina’s side on this. 

She must still have some powerful hold on him. 

Chloey wanted to talk to Joey again just to check on her. I think she wanted to see if Joey finally missed us or was still having a good time without us. 

“Hi!” Joey smiled in the mirror. I was glad to not see Brielle with her. 

Her smile however was fake and we could both tell.

“What happened?” I asked. 

“It’s nothing,” She assured us. 

“Joey, we can tell it’s not nothing,” Chloey stated. “Just tell us. Do you miss us?”

“I mean, yeah, but that’s not what’s wrong.”

Chloey and I both felt disappointed hearing this. 

“So what’s going on?” I asked. 

Joey bit her lip and sighed. “I saw Dad.”